7 ms·
We bought a 15" 2016 Macbook Pro ("Retina" is redundant; there are no 2016 MBPs that lack a Retina display.) We also bought a LG 27UD88-W monitor to go with it
by otterley 10y ago
We bought a 15" 2016 Macbook Pro ("Retina" is redundant; there are no 2016 MBPs that lack a Retina display.) We also bought a LG 27UD88-W monitor to go with it. (It's one of the few that has a USB-C input.)
I have to say, I'm really impressed by the single-cable solution. The monitor charges the laptop (57W maximum, which is less than the Apple charger, but "good enough"), and the laptop sends both video and USB peripheral connections to the monitor, which acts as a USB 3.0 hub.
One cable. It's kind of amazing and magical if you think about it.
There are some rough edges, though:
(1) Sometimes the computer reports that it's not charging. Sometimes it does. We don't know why just yet. We can always connect the Apple-supplied charger though.
(2) When the display goes to sleep, it disconnects all the devices on the hub. This is a problem for external disks, as the OS complains that it has been detached without being ejected first. I hope LG fixes this in a future firmware version.
(3) We can't use the Apple-supplied USB charging cable to connect the laptop to the display. The connectors are the same, but.. it just doesn't work. As a technical person, I understand why; but it's going to be unnecessarily confusing to people if two cables that look alike don't act alike. This is going to raise technical support costs greatly until all USB-C cables are capable of all transports and functions and the old ones are phased out. Why Apple didn't ship a fully-capable cable in the box is puzzling to me.
- Siecje 10y agoWhy doesn't the Apple-supplied USB charging cable work?
- cpmsmith 10y agoNot all USB-C connectors are created equal. Something with that connector can support or not support a number of protocols, e.g. USB, Thunderbolt 3, USB-C power throughput, etc.
- wlesieutre 10y agoIn this case, the cable used with the monitor needs to be a Thunderbolt 3 cable, not just a USB-C cable. I haven't seen a teardown of the new ones, but at least for the previous generation there's a bit more to it than your average cable. https://www.wired.com/2011/06/thunderbolt-cable-teardown-reveals-enough-chips-to-make-a-computer/ https://www.wired.com/2011/06/thunderbolt-cable-teardown-rev... Thunderbolt 2 had the same compatibility issue in that it was the same connector as Mini DisplayPort but couldn't run over a standard DP cable. That was pretty minor since it's not like everyone has a pile of loose DP cables sitting around. On the other hand, your average consumer never uses a Thunderbolt device to begin with on account of them being significantly more expensive than other accessories. They'll likely never run into this even with it using a USB-like cable, and the people who do need TB will figure it out.
- otterley 10y agoIt's not a Thunderbolt issue. It's about supporting "DisplayPort Alternate Mode." This particular monitor doesn't support Thunderbolt.
- wlesieutre 10y agoOh interesting, I didn't think monitors could run video over the USB cable and still offer a USB hub on the same connection, but it looks like the DisplayPort data goes over the additional USB-3 lines and preserves the original USB-2 connection for accessories. Good to know. Thunderbolt displays can do hubs at full speed, the 5K LG Ultrafine has 3x USB 3.1 gen 1, which IIRC means up to 5 Gbps (vs 480 Mbps for USB 2). Not sure why your comment was marked [dead] but I just vouched it so it should be back.
- lvh 10y agoThe cable is a USB-C cable, but not a Thunderbolt 3 cable. This is confusing, because they use the same USB-C port. My understanding is that Thunderbolt cables have the thunderbolt logo on them.
- otterley 10y agoIt's not a Thunderbolt issue. It's about supporting "DisplayPort Alternate Mode." This particular monitor doesn't support Thunderbolt.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- illumin8 10y agoIt's for charging only. This seems to be a huge disadvantage to USB-c... you have to buy different cables for different purposes, even though they have the same physical connector. Can you imagine if AC power had the same plug for both 110V and 220V? And you just had to "guess" which one was the right one?
- revelation 10y agoThey do? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60320 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60320 That's a common problem with power supplies that require setting a hard switch to choose between 110V and 220V.
- throwanem 10y agoWhich is why it's rare at best to encounter such power supplies in new manufacture, and has been for quite some years now. Instead, they sense the line voltage and configure themselves accordingly. It's hard to see the profusion of semi- and incompatibilities permissible in the USB-C connector as anything but a regression.
- mitchty 10y agoYep, I bought some fun electronic bench gear, on the back it says validate the 110/220/240 setting prior to use. On that note, always look on the back for a manual switch. Just to be safe. Its unlikely a regular consumer would need to but I'm learning to change my habits.
- schoen 10y agoFor the socket side of the same problem, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mains_electricity_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mains_electricity_by_country and search for "Power cords with type A or B plugs which are rated at only 125 V may present a safety hazard" (each of the seven occurrences reflects a country that always or sometimes uses U.S.-style sockets with a higher voltage such as 240 V).
- lnanek2 10y agoIt probably lacks data lines. It is common for USB cables used for charging to only have power lines and skip the data lines to save money. I believe the USB cable that came with my Chromecast is the same.
- ProZsolt 10y agoIt has data line, but only supports USB 2.0
- pikhq 10y agoA given USB Type C cable can be a "USB 2.0" cable, which is only good for USB @ 480 Mbps and power, or a "USB 3.1" cable, which can handle USB @ 10 Gbps and power, as well as alternate data modes like DisplayPort or Thunderbolt. Additionally, it can be only good for 3 A, or it can have a chip in it to indicate it's good for more power (up to 5A). The Apple-supplied cable is probably a USB 2.0 cable, with a chip indicating it can handle 5A.
- Skunkleton 10y agoEven worse, you can't expect thunderbolt 3 to work over any cable length. So unless all USB C cables become active cables (unlikely), longer USB C cables won't have thunderbolt support due to signal integrity limitations.
- abakker 10y ago3 sounds like a doozy. Is there any way that the average person can learn to tell these apart once they are out of the packaging, or is it really just a guess and check?
- lvh 10y agoMy understanding is that Thunderbolt 3 cables should have the Thunderbolt logo on them.
- otterley 10y agoIt's not a Thunderbolt issue. It's about supporting "DisplayPort Alternate Mode." This particular monitor doesn't support Thunderbolt.
- hyperbovine 10y agoSteve would be pissed.
- qyv 10y agoAnd herein lies the rub of USB-C: It isn't a universal logical interface, it is a multi-use physical connector. By overloading the port's logical functions you introduce incompatible physical configurations.
- eridius 10y agoThere have always been charge-only USB cables, they're just not all that common (I believe many mice come with those for charging, but I don't know where else you'd get one). I agree that it is a problem for Apple to be shipping a charge-only USB-C cable, both because this significantly increases the number of charge-only cables in the wild, and because this is probably the first USB-C cable that their customers will have and it's confusing if it doesn't actually act as a generic USB-C cable.
- falcolas 10y agoFWIW, the only time I've seen charge-only USB cables is when they are permanently attached to a charging brick.
- Alex3917 10y agoWhat happens if you accidentally plug in your charging cable when it's already being charged from the monitor?
- philipodonnell 10y agoI read that it chooses the power source with the highest charge rate
- otterley 10y agoThis is correct. There's no harm.
- tvararu 10y agoNothing. You can plug in four chargers, one in every port, and it will only draw power from one.
- rz2k 10y agoThat looks like a good choice for a monitor. I've been thinking two of the 4K LG monitors Apple offers next to each other in portrait orientation would be nice. However, the lower UHD resolution at 27" rather than 21" probably makes a lot more sense for me if I want to be able to sit further away from the display. If my eyes are 3-4ft away, 160ppi probably doesn't even look like it has less definition than 220ppi.
- otterley 10y agoWe have no complaints about it, other than the price. (It's still $200-$300 cheaper than the 27" 5K display that hasn't shipped yet; but it's about $100-$200 more than an equivalent Dell display that doesn't have USB-C.) We also wish it charged at > 57W, but this monitor predates the release of the new MBPs.
- r00fus 10y agoI use a 60W MB charger (with magsafe adapter) with my MBP 15" at home - it has had no problems for years despite the 15" normally requiring 85W. I remember someone saying that the nominal usage wattage of a newer MBP 15" is around 15W, perhaps double if CPU taxed.
- teilo 10y agoAs to 3: the reason is cost. If you are using a cable with your power adapter, you are only using it for charging. To use a USB-C 3.1 cable for that is wasteful because it costs double what the charging/USB2 cable alone would cost. And yeah, it is going to confuse a lot of people.
- taurath 10y agoIts a $2500 laptop. Apple should ship the cable.
- ryanlol 10y agoIf I buy a $2500 flight I get a toothbrush, why does the $2500 macbook not come with a toothbrush? Edit: In case it wasn't obvious to the readers, the reason behind the missing toothbrush and missing USB-C 3.1 cable are the same. Who the hell expects a toothbrush with their laptop? Or a random USB cable in that matter?
- netsharc 10y agoBecause a lot of people fall asleep on flights, and want to refresh their oral hygiene when waking up, and the airline realizes this extra will be appreciated. Now, do people need USB-cables when using their electronic devices? And would that little extra be appreciated?
- baq 10y agoThe toothbrush has a single purpose. The cable could be used to charge and to transfer data. It can't be used for the second case for no good reason apart of saving a couple bucks per box. I'm pretty sure Jobs wouldn't have it.
- khedoros1 10y agoThe company talks big about a beautiful vision of multi-purpose cables, carrying power in one direction, data in both directions, etc. They provide one of those cables...but it turns out that it only carries power. So, imagine if your airline was talking about the benefits of brushing your teeth with good toothpaste, and their provided teeth-cleaning kit just has a toothbrush. Since Apple's shipping a "random USB cable" anyhow, it would make sense for them to ship the version of it that actually does all the things they've been advertising.
- Freestyler_3 10y agoWhat do you think the effect of constant charging will be on battery life in the long term?
- matthewmacleod 10y agoThere is no practical impact on modern batteries from being constantly connected to power.
- Freestyler_3 10y agoI guess, I confused it with the batteries amount of charges before decline. good to get it confirmed here.
- rasz_pl 10y agothis is not true, liion dont like being constantly kept at full.
- r00fus 10y agoDo you connect your laptop to a monitor without also connecting the charger? My MPB is used in 2 ways: on a desk or lapdesk without any peripherals, or with 3-4 connectors (including hub/monitor and charger).
- Freestyler_3 10y agoI did before, but in that setup I turned the laptop screen off.
- to3m 10y agoProbably not huge - my MBP's battery is 644 days old, and I use it plugged in pretty much all the time. So it's had 34 cycles. But it's still got 92.4% of its capacity left.
- freehunter 10y agoLord, just 34? I use mine disconnected a lot but mine has over 300 in about a year.
- Roritharr 10y agoHave you guys tried using this monitor with a Windows Notebook like the XPS 13 or 15? I wonder how the intercompatibility is between the "for Apple" branded LG Monitors and the Standard USB-C TB3 Devices.
- otterley 10y agoThis particular monitor is not one of the two "for Apple" monitors announced alongside the MBP announcement. But to answer your question: no. We don't run Windows at home and have no such test equipment.
- carsongross 10y ago> One cable. It's kind of amazing and magical if you think about it. Apple had the one-cable thing back in 1998. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Display_Connector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Display_Connector Power went the other way, but still. Crazy it's taken us this long to get back to it.
- zorpner 10y agoApple had it in 1993 (minus the power): http://www.kan.org/6100/graphicshardware.html http://www.kan.org/6100/graphicshardware.html But NeXT had it in '88, power included (!): http://www.uk.netbsd.org/ports/next68k/faq.html#connections http://www.uk.netbsd.org/ports/next68k/faq.html#connections
- eddieh 10y agoPeople always hate on Apple for proprietary connectors and cables, but I loved my Cinema display with the ADC cable.
- undersuit 10y ago>When the display goes to sleep, it disconnects all the devices on the hub. This is a problem for external disks, as the OS complains that it has been detached without being ejected first. I hope LG fixes this in a future firmware version. Is there a monitor that doesn't suffer this issue? My Dell's USB hub power is linked to the monitor power. I can't plug a mouse into the monitor if I want to use that mouse to wake up the computer.
- otterley 10y agoI don't expect the hub to work when the display is powered off or unplugged. I do, however, expect it to work when the monitor is "asleep", i.e., in power-saving mode. My Dell P2715Q display does work properly as a hub when it's asleep.
- slantyyz 10y ago>> My Dell P2715Q display does work properly as a hub when it's asleep. The P2715Q has all sorts of quirks. I have a pair of them connected to my Windows computer, and when they go to sleep, Windows basically forgets where all the open windows were and disperses them somewhat randomly. Of all the monitors I've used, I've only ever experienced this with the P2715Q. I also notice that the power output of the USB ports on the monitors is barely enough to charge any recent mobile device.
- tachion 10y agoThat's interesting, because it happens randomly for my two Dells connected to a MacBook Pro and I was blaming OSX for this. Have you found any hack/solution to this?
- slantyyz 10y agoNo, I think it's the monitors themselves. Instead of "sleeping", they appear to make the OS think they've been powered down/disconnected instead. When a monitor goes to sleep, I can hear the "device disconnected" chime in Windows, which should not happen.
- eruditely 10y ago"I have to say, I'm really impressed by the single-cable solution. The monitor charges the laptop" Is this a new feature? I've never heard of monitors charging laptops before.
- Bud 10y agoIt's part of the benefits of Thunderbolt (and now, USB-C). The Apple Thunderbolt Display also charged Mac laptops via its built-in MagSafe cable.
- otterley 10y agoThe last revision of the Thunderbolt Cinema Display used two separate cables. USB-C is the first single-cable solution I'm aware of.
- npunt 10y ago> (2) When the display goes to sleep, it disconnects all the devices on the hub. This is a problem for external disks, as the OS complains that it has been detached without being ejected first. I hope LG fixes this in a future firmware version. This is why I'm quite disappointed that Apple exited the display business. Small issues like this highlight the different scope of LG and Apple business models. As a display manufacturer, LG is primarily concerned with a display that works well in its primary use (e.g. when it's on) and much less concerned about secondary uses - it's not really their problem. Apple, on the other hand, is concerned with the overall user experience, and has designed their business model around this (including cost centers like customer service / genius bar appointments). LG just feels a lot less pain on this issue than Apple would. Hopefully Apple can find a way to preserve a certain level of user experience now that they're no longer manufacturing. There's no MFi certification equivalent for Mac, but it seems like there should be. This is probably also relevant for wifi routers, now that they've left that business too.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"This is why I'm quite disappointed that Apple exited the display business." Is this official? Did they make some kind of statement? I think during the even they showed a Mac Pro connected to a monitor but it wasn't Apple. I was kind of confused by that at the time but now it might make sense. There was also a thread on here yesterday about how they've existed the router business. Very odd, since so many of their customers like having a complete ecosystem.
- eridius 10y agoApple discontinued its last display a few months ago, and after the MBP announcement they confirmed that they've fully exited the display business. https://twitter.com/reckless/status/792069952916197376 https://twitter.com/reckless/status/792069952916197376
- bitserf 10y agoI have a Thunderbolt display from Apple, it also powers off the USB devices when it goes to sleep.
- snowwrestler 10y agoWith respect to #2, it seems ridiculous to me that in 2016 we still have to manually eject USB devices from Macs. How have they not figured this out yet? I hope it finally gets fixed next year with the new AFS.
- otterley 10y agoApple can't guarantee that write caching is disabled on every removable storage device out there, even if they send the correct command to do so (some devices ignore it to improve their performance benchmark scores). The best they can do is flush the data on unmount, which requires they be notified in advance via a user action. What else do you expect them to do? BTW, Windows and Linux have the same problems. The fault lies with the storage device vendors.
- ianburrell 10y ago#3 is because the USB-C charge cable only does USB 2. It doesn't have all the wires that would be needed to do USB3 or alternate modes. The reason is that USB2 cables are cheaper and easier to make longer. The charge cable is 2m and $19, the Belkin 1m is $22, the Belkin Thunderbolt 0.5m is $22, and the Belkin Thunderbolt 2m is $52. Also, the charge cable is emarked and supports charging at 5A (100W). Regular USB C cables only support 3A and 60W.
- k_bx 10y ago> When the display goes to sleep, it disconnects all the devices on the hub I also have an audio interface connected to my sound monitors, and it is also quite bad for it to lose its power, producing a loud blasting sound. If monitor becomes a power supply, we need it to never stop supplying it, just like notebook doesn't stop when it goes to sleep.