5 ms·
Not supporting DisplayPort with an adapter is just insane. Apple's new top-end laptop is incompatible with the most common way to connect external monitors? I'
by mikeash 10y ago
Not supporting DisplayPort with an adapter is just insane. Apple's new top-end laptop is incompatible with the most common way to connect external monitors?
I've been willing to give Apple and the new MBP the benefit of the doubt on this stuff, and in particular I don't mind that it needs dongles now if that means we get universal USB-C adoption faster. But the dongles need to actually exist and work now!
- stormbrew 10y agoMy understanding is that it's specifically the thunderbolt-2 adapter that doesn't support further adapting to other alternate mode mechanisms. This might be because of incompatibilities between TB2 and TB3/USB3.1 alternate mode implementations? It doesn't mean it can't do DP over a specific type-c to DP cable/dongle, which presumably are or will be a thing (eg: https://store.google.com/product/usb_type_c_to_displayport_cable https://store.google.com/product/usb_type_c_to_displayport_c...). The author appears to want to wait for docks that do both DP and power delivery, if I understand correctly.
- lvh 10y agoYou're correct on both counts: Apple suggested I purchased such a dongle. Unfortunately, as per the post, that's not easy; most USB-C devices currently available don't work. I'm holding out specifically for rMBP2016-compatible devices; and it seems a little silly not to wait for a dock now and get the tempting one-cable experience.
- rayiner 10y agoThere are USB-C to DisplayPort cables. You need some sort of converting cable anyway--the old MBP had Mini DisplayPort and I've never seen a monitor with a MiniDP input.
- lvh 10y ago(Author here) The Dell P2515Q I have has both DisplayPort and mDP2 in and out (for chaining).
- slantyyz 10y agoAs does the Dell 4K P2715Q. I have to admit, my assumption for the monitor having both sizes of the display port (vs both being full sized DP) and including a DP-> mDp cable were so that the monitor worked out of the box no matter what type of port the source computer had. All possible combinations are satisfied.
- compuguy 10y agoDo the new MacBook pros support display port chaining now?
- ProZsolt 10y agoOlder Macbook Pros also supported chining, but not the OS. It's working under Windows.
- pxndx 10y agoI have an Asus mg279q with both a DP and a miniDP input. The provided cable is a DP to miniDP, so you can plug most devices with a single cable (just reverse it). I guess other monitors from the same line have miniDP inputs too.
- randallsquared 10y agoMy Philips bdm4065uc has both DP and mDP.
- mikeash 10y agoYes, it sounds like it's doable, it's just insane that Apple doesn't offer the necessary adapter (and further insane that Apple doesn't make it clear that the TB2 adapter won't do the job). I'm OK with the computer using USB-C exclusively, but Apple needs to make adapters available for other common ports. Relying on third parties for something as common as DisplayPort is not good.
- teilo 10y agoIf you have an existing Thunderbolt dock, you can use the 3-to-2 adapter, and just plug the DisplayPort monitor into the other Thunderbolt port on the dock. I do not know why this works, but it does.
- hash-set 10y agoThe dongle shit killed it for me. I use Macs to code due to certain conveniences, but Apple is not looking out for me. Cheap bastards.
- Stratoscope 10y agoWith my late 2013 MBPR and ViewSonic VX2475SMHL-4K, all I had to do was use a mini-DP to DP cable and everything just works, both in OSX and Windows 10. I hardly ever boot into OSX any more - most of my work is in Windows and I generally like Windows better anyway - especially with the crisper font rendering after using the ClearType tuner compared to the fuzzier OSX text. (Yes, OSX - I haven't even bothered to upgrade to Sierra.) So I guess my next upgrade will be back to another ThinkPad, and I'll keep this old MBPR for OSX/macOS/iOS testing.
- mescalito 10y agoYou normally use Windows on your 2013 MBPR? All hardware working nicely?
- slantyyz 10y agoApple's Boot Camp drivers tend to be quite good. Also, Windows generally feels snappier than OSX on the same hardware.
- Stratoscope 10y agoYes, with Apple's Boot Camp drivers it actually makes a very nice Windows machine. I used to run Windows in a Parallels VM under OSX, and that worked well for a while, but at some point my OSX installation started getting very slow, and Parallels even slower. So I started using Boot Camp more and found it to be very snappy. Also I was doing some VR work on Windows, and that only works on physical hardware. (The MBPR is not a great machine for VR, but it's good enough for the system integration stuff I was doing.) The only hardware issues I've run into compared to running Windows in Parallels are: * Apple's Ethernet dongle is not hot-pluggable in Windows like it is in OSX/macOS. A reboot is required if you want to plug it in. You can plug and unplug the Ethernet cable on the fly, just not the dongle itself. * By default, the trackpad two-finger scrolling works in the traditional "scrollbar" style (swipe your fingers down and the display content moves up). I prefer the "natural" style where it is more like using a touchscreen. I found an easy registry tweak to fix this on this page: http://waded.org/2013/01/15/perfecting-trackpad-scrolling-in-windows-8-on-a-macbook-air/ http://waded.org/2013/01/15/perfecting-trackpad-scrolling-in... I didn't use any of the other tweaks on that page, just the scroll direction. * The touchpad driver is not as good as the one in OSX. Specifically, it's much more susceptible to false right clicks, and it's fussier about the style of click-dragging where you hold the touchpad down with one finger and drag with another. In OSX this works pretty naturally; in Windows it works only if I hold the pad down at the left bottom corner and then drag with another finger. * And of course, I miss the TrackPoint from my ThinkPads. The finishing touch was to get one of these Windows logo decals to cover up the Apple logo: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B014I1ICX8/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B014I1ICX8/ So now my MacBook Pro is officially a WinBook Pro!
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> Apple's new top-end laptop is incompatible with the most common way to connect external monitors? You mean HDMI? On non-Apple/non-Microsoft laptops HDMI is by far the most common way to connect external displays followed likely by VGA and then finally DisplayPort.
- freehunter 10y agoEven on Apple laptops, my 2015 rMBP came with HDMI, and I have an adapter for VGA. The only machine I've ever used DisplayPort for is an older Thinkpad, and even then when I asked Best Buy to sell me a DisplayPort cable, they didn't have any in stock. They kept offering Mini DisplayPort, which is AKA Thunderbolt which is built into every MacBook since ever.
- scottlamb 10y agoThey exist. I bought a Plugable USB 3.1 Type-C to DisplayPort adapter off Amazon. It works with my new 15" Macbook Pro and my new LG 27UD68-W 4K display; full resolution, 60Hz. There are also various adapters to plug in HDMI, but they don't seem to do 4K at 60Hz, so I avoided them. The article is saying that a TB3 -> TB2 adapter and a mini-DisplayPort -> DisplayPort adapter don't chain correctly. I haven't tried that; I assume the author is correct.