3 ms·
By recursion. The initial iteration is that they pool a bunch of loans together to aggregate the risk. They know from history (short term history - a vulnerab
by gvb 17y ago
By recursion.
The initial iteration is that they pool a bunch of loans together to aggregate the risk. They know from history (short term history - a vulnerability that turned into a failure mode) that mortgage defaults are quite unlikely to happen in the first, say 5, years, so they can sell paper that matures in 5 years and be confident that it has a low failure rate from the (flawed) historical perspective. The longer term paper on the loans will historically have a higher probability of failure, so the longer term paper has lower ratings.
Then the recursion occurs.
1) Homeowners kept refinancing their houses (encouraged by the insatiable appetite for new mortgages to slice and dice into AAA-rated paper), so their loans never aged, they just kept getting reset.
2) The bankers took the remaining less-than-AAA-rated aggregated debt and used to create a new debt vehicle and then claimed all over again that the "new" debt (which was really old debt reheated) could be re-sliced into AAA-rated debt plus residual lower rated debt.
This quickly turns into a house of cards which inevitably failed when short term history (low failure rates based on long held mortgages and "perpetually" increasing house values) failed to model reality.
- grandalf 17y agoExcellent explanation. Also, I think it's relevant that the models that undergirded the ratings also had to assume some probability distribution of mortgage market price volatility... which was generally perceived as being far more stable than it turned out to be...
- roc 17y agoTrick is, the ratings agencies knew 1 and 2 were happening; questions about the practice were raised. That no-one did anything when questions were raised is what brings us back to fraud. The ratings agencies were allowing a known-flawed system to apply known-incorrect ratings because it served their own financial interests.