8 ms·
>I'd guess that a similar 90+% of beginners quit the clarinet, violin, piano, drums, etc. I blame this soley on how piano is taught. Instead of focusing on mus
by dominotw 10y ago
>I'd guess that a similar 90+% of beginners quit the clarinet, violin, piano, drums, etc.
I blame this soley on how piano is taught. Instead of focusing on music and sound, music teachers try to teach note names, sitting posture, curving your hands ect. You are sent of with the impression that you'd need years of daily practice to be half decent. This is an immediate turn-off. I want to play music, not memorize ridiculous memory tricks like ' every good boy does fine' .
I would imagine most people are trying to make new music and play existing music. 99% of ppl are not trying to become professional pianist. Yet music teachers just teach how they have been taught, with endless instructions about keeping your back straigt, keeping the curve in your fingers ect. This makes one feel like they are not "cut out" for music and they give up .
We need a new crop of music teachers that can take advantage of new midi instruments, iphone apps ect to teach music. Piano should be introduced much later one you have grasped the how notes sound, how chords sound, why you need them ect on a simpler interface instead of endless repetitions of twinkle, twinkle from day one. Classical music should not be taught to a hobbyist. Instruction should be fun from day one, you should be making new music from day one. Endless learning of grammar doesn't make one a good author.
- otoburb 10y agoThe Suzuki method[1] uses a similar approach to teach music by introducing notation later on in the learning process, after desire, curiosity and music appreciation has been sparked first. [1] https://suzukiassociation.org/about/suzuki-method/instilling-desire-to-learn/ https://suzukiassociation.org/about/suzuki-method/instilling...
- analog31 10y agoMy kids both started in Suzuki programs. In fact, from what I can tell, Suzuki is now the leading teaching method for small kids on nearly all instruments. Teachers tend to modify the method somewhat. Since "Suzuki" is a brand, it comes with a specific repertoire. American teachers tend to draw from a larger repertoire, and also introduce reading fairly early depending on the kid's aptitude and interest. In my observation, classical music is not a turn-off for kids, if they are young enough that they don't have a strong sense of what is "cool." Reaching teenagers is a whole nother ball o' wax, and I suspect, is rarely as successful. Part of Suzuki's ideology involved the parents. He expected them to be enthusiastic partners in their kids learning music. This can be a problem if: 1) The parents don't like classical music. Many people viscerally dislike it. 2) They oppose all structured musical education for whatever reason, including their own childhood experience. I grew up when Suzuki was still controversial in the US, and my training (on the cello) was along classical European lines. Music is a huge part of my life, though I now play jazz on double bass almost exclusively. I'm not sure that the less structured approach to learning guitar actually leads to less attrition. Among people I know (for instance at my workplace) who still pursue an interest in music at any level, relatively few play the electric guitar. Without supporting evidence, I wouldn't assume that the supposedly structured, old-fashioned approach to teaching music is actually less successful in the long run.
- Retric 10y agoOne possibility is people wait longer to quit. A student who sticks with it for 2 years might not get very far, but they pay for a lot more lessons than someone quitting after 3 months.
- Cozumel 10y agoIf that's how you're getting taught music you need a better teacher! I strongly disagree with using 'apps' to teach music, it's counter productive and you won't learn. To learn piano you need a piano (or keyboard) and a proper teacher that's it, you're also not limited to learning classical pieces. And you won't be able to create new music until you've learnt the fundamentals, scales and chords etc and yes that takes time, effort, patience and practice. There's no shortcuts.
- dominotw 10y ago>And you won't be able to create new music until you've learnt the fundamentals, scales and chords etc and yes that takes time This meme has to die. Do you think Djembe players in west African village learned chords and scales to come up awesome sounding percussions ? I've seen young kids come up sweet rhythms with zero musical training. You can create new music on day one, it's built into us. Chords and Scales should be used to understand and enhance what you can create, its not a prerequisite .
- nandorsky 10y agoProducing a rhythm is completely different than producing a song. Rhythms don't have tones, notes do. Not understanding chord structures, scales and how songs are built will make it quite difficult to produce any type of song. There are basic fundamental building blocks of how to build a song you'll need to understand or you'll just run in circles hitting notes. Imagine trying to learn to program without understanding the basics of MVC.
- dominotw 10y ago> Rhythms don't have tones, notes do. Ummm.. I don't think this is true. I think Djembe has open tone, closed tone, slap, base tone ect. I What about folk songs from India, how did they come up with it ? I am not arguing against music theory, I am arguing against saying music theory is prerequisite for creating music. Music is nothing like a programming language, there is no compiler rejecting your bad music. Sure people have discovered what sounds good and what doesn't and turned it into some sort of theory but those are merely guidelines not syntax rules that are enforced by the compiler.
- jasode 10y ago>Instead of focusing on music and sound, music teachers try to teach note names, sitting posture, curving your hands ect. [...] This is an immediate turn-off. 100% agree on this! I believe the teacher's first interaction with a new student on piano should be asking what song(s) they like. If possible, start the instruction using that particular song because that's the juice that got them curious about the instrument in the first place! Yes, Mozart's Sonata 16 K545[1] is an enduring staple of typical piano instruction but while it's a decent tune, that classical piece is not the music that made the student want to learn the piano. It's more likely the student was sparked by something mainstream like Adele's "Someone Like You"[2]. As a bonus, that Adele song happens to be easier than the Mozart piece. Please don't kill the budding pianist with Mozart and piano drills if that isn't what he/she likes. For some reason, it's blasphemy to let beginning piano students practice on real pop songs. (Possibly due to emphasis on sight reading sheet music of which there is more of it available for classical pieces.) This is less a problem with guitars because more kids are self-taught, lessons are informal, and every guitarist shamelessly attempts whatever is currently on the radio. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aW9t5Cn-KU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aW9t5Cn-KU [2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbXnLn5-7MA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbXnLn5-7MA
- enf 10y agoThe other hard part with trying to learn piano from pop is that most of the available arrangements of current hits are trying to transcribe the hit recording rather than to put something on paper that is comfortably readable and playable. If you want comfortable arrangements that a beginner will stand a chance of being able to make it through, you have go to back to hits from before 1965 or so. That's what I've been doing myself, but to a lot of people that's not too different than asking them to play something from 1765.
- lodi 10y agoA few thoughts from a pianist with three professional music teachers in the family: 0) Someone already came up with a classical piano repertoire that perfectly increases in difficulty from "Primary" to Grade 10, in neat, progressive steps. If you look for sheet music for that Adele song, I guarantee you you'll never find a version that's appropriate for each of those levels. You might find several versions, each somewhere in the middle of that range, but no one will spend the time to interpret "Someone Like You" in eleven different ways--from an 8-bar melody up to some 15-page virtuosic piece--and then repeat that for every other song in the top 100. Can't even crowd-source that effort due to copyright. 1) You're vastly overestimating what a complete beginner can do. Remember, these are normally 5 year old kids with barely enough motor control to hold a pencil properly, no concept of beats or rhythm, etc. Pop music is usually easier, but it still takes years to work up to that Adele song. "What about adult students?" Adult students are even worse for quitting things early because it'll still take months to play anything remotely interesting and there's no one forcing them to continue. Proof: note how many adults will join and then quit the gym between New Years and February 1st because they're not seeing results quick enough. 2) To build on the above, piano has the shortest possible path to making in-tune sounds. Think how long it takes to learn to play even a single note on an oboe. You need the many lectures on posture and finger position--not to mention tons of boring practice!--just to stop squeaking. 3) How do you go about teaching Adele without explaining note names, how counting works (fractions!), and all the associated music theory? "I play, you copy?" That's not considered good music education. Kids get decent at rote memorization of finger patterns, and then plateuau at that (very, very low) level. 4) Beginners already start with "fun" music like Old McDonald, London Bridge, etc. Most of it is lame, but then again, kids might find recently-mainstream music like N'Sync lame too. Fashion moves pretty fast. On that note, copyright/royalties on modern music are a pretty good barrier to just playing whatever you want. (And improvising or playing "by ear" is a complete non-starter. That's the kind of thing you attempt after years of experience, not as a beginner.) 5) Trust me, teachers are intimately aware of the fine balance between motivating their kids with fun repertoire and actually teaching them something. Vocal teachers probably work that fine line the hardest since every pop song is fair game. 6) Pop songs in addition to classical repertoire is fine; not a single music teacher will object to this. My mother held three recitals a year (popular, christmas, classical) and kids held free reign over repertoire selection in two of the three (and the third was mostly a "trial run" of the pieces they'd have to play anyway for their upcoming piano exams). Pop songs as a replacement for classical repertoire is not fine. Adele wasn't thinking about teaching you anything about fingering or expression marks when she wrote her songs. On the other hand, Chopin/Liszt/Czerny/Debussy/etc. were writing with exactly those concerns in mind when they wrote their Etudes (read "studies"). They're written to be lyrical and interesting, but also to focus your practice towards a specific, technical challenge (perhaps one etude is just about fast arpeggios for the right hand, another etude for long trills with the weak fingers of the left hand, etc.) 7) Along the same lines, "classical" education isn't just Classical-era music, like Mozart. Good teachers want to expose you to lots of styles. Yes, every pianist has to play Bach--even if you hate Bach--because it's instrumental to learning about polyphony. But somewhere in that repertoire book there'll also be jazzy music, latin music, cinematic-style music, etc. written by still-living composers (although probably not as modern as Adele). In RCM books you'll find that kind of thing in sections 'D' and 'E'. 8) And yes, nobody likes scales, but drills are drills; you just have to accept that some parts are laborious and annoying. Athletes spend time running between plastic pylons and sweating it out at the gym because you can't efficiently build fundamentals just by playing games. You need a good mix of performance and practice. If you're only looking to "have fun", you can just stick to pick-up games with your friends (or teach yourself how to strum a few guitar chords), but if you're taking professional lessons in something there's an implied expectation that you're there to improve. Obviously music is there to be enjoyed. And I'm certainly not claiming that traditional music education can't be improved. I just wanted to make the point that teachers already try to balance motivation with other goals, and that no activity worth doing is "all fun, all the time".
- foobarian 10y agoKind of an ugly but related anecdote about learning piano: I know someone who grew up in Tennessee, and started playing around on his family's piano in his teens. He liked jazz so that's what he tried to teach himself. At one point his grandma said he can't keep playing like n....rs and enrolled him in lessons like parent talks about.
- analog31 10y agoSurprisingly, that's how most jazz musicians learned to play, for the past century: Take the formal lessons that you're supposed to take, then sneak out and learn jazz yourself. White parents were conflicted by the racial biases in music, but even black parents wanted their kids to learn "proper" music as defined by the academe. My parents had no idea that jazz was my main musical interest.
- flinty 10y agoThis sounds conceptually similar to how teaching CS or teaching programming to some one later in life focusses on algorithms data structures and other "inside baseball" concepts rather than asking them what is something you would like the computer to do for you or a real life application they would like to see in the world and show them the simplest path to getting a MVP of the thing they are interested in. Once they have that they will be more curious to build something else using their first experience as a base. Maybe a few months or a year or so later they would explore deeper concepts like learning data structures, algorithms and other optimizations
- akytt 10y agoYou do need years of practice to get half decent. All of that stuff - posture, note names, etc. - is stuff you'll be missing down the road.
- akytt 10y agoYou do need years of practice to get half decent. All of that stuff - posture, note names, etc. - is stuff you'll be missing down the road.
- dizzystar 10y agoThat can't be true. Most ex-musicians I know quit for many reasons, and most of those were self-taught. Posture is important so you don't hurt yourself while sitting on a backless piano bench for hours on end. Finger position is important because playing with splayed fingers will limit your repertoire down the road. The best way to prevent bad habits is preventing them from forming in the first place. The same goes with guitar. I don't teach, but I could and I can assure you that the two exercises I would begin students with would be pretty bad, but so fundamental that it'd be inexcusable of me to not teach them this stuff. Do a down strum on each one count while I count to 4 and repeat. This is surprisingly difficult to do when you first start. This one is actually pretty fun and can make people laugh at themselves. Hold your fret hand on your lap, then try to make a C chord. Pick each string from bottom to top. If one of the strings don't ring out, fix your hand and keep down picking until each string rings out. Keep doing this until you get it right on the first time five times. Got C? Lets work on G. I'm actually surprised at how many experienced musicians can't do this. Yes, it is hard, yes it is work, but it's no different than programming. Nothing worth having is given to you.
- lmm 10y agoThis is very contrary to my experience. I suspect the vast majority of people who learn piano do so with the desire to play classical music, because frankly that's the main thing it's good for. Playing piano arrangements of pop songs is a cool party trick the first few times, but loses its lustre pretty quickly (they end up all sounding similar); for composition there are probably better options in the age of computer sequencers, and fundamentally most people aren't in a position to get much value out of doing original composition.
- aczerepinski 10y agoThere is nothing wrong with introducing kids to an endeavor that still requires good old fashioned hard work. Music (like all arts) really does require thousands of hours of practice, and that isn't a problem that needs to be solved by replacing it with the video game version. You could easily make the same argument for any discipline. Chemistry shouldn't be about learning boring periodic tables, it should be fun explosions. 99% of ppl are not trying to become professional novelists, so English classes should focus on comic books. If some give up along the way because they don't enjoy it, so what? I gave up on baseball at a young age because I didn't like it and wasn't good at it. Does it matter?
- emodendroket 10y agoI agree, but actually hooking up guitars to software seems like a cost-effective way to get supplemental "lessons."
- emodendroket 10y agoI'm not a musician but this sounds a little bit like urging people to write a program without learning what functions are.
- jeremiep 10y agoI strongly disagree. What you're suggesting leads to really mediocre practice and that in the long run will get people to give up because they've reached a plateau they set upon themselves without realizing it. Your teachers know and understand stuff you're years away from grasping as a beginner. Its not about being "professional" but rather having the proper foundations upon which you can build knowledge and muscle memory. Its about spending the least amount of effort at any point in your practice so it becomes actually effective. Its about having a logical progression where each new concept adds up to existing knowledge (music theory is VERY well structured in that regard.) I personally dread that new crop of teachers using MIDI/apps to teach music. This is anything but teaching music - its teaching MIDI and apps. You dont learn to ride a bike by downloading an app or playing "bike simulator" - its just obvious. Saying "endless learning of grammar" and other forms of "oh god, I have to put in effort?!" mentalities show off a very shallow understanding of the domain - this is what you expect a teenager to say when looking at his courses because he's years away from understanding why they're useful. Sorry to sound harsh but its just how it comes out as.
- theobon 10y agoThe people you are talking about giving up when they plateau are likely the same people that would have given up when forced to learn the grammar. The net result is a similar number of people at the higher level but the people at the beginner level have more ability to generate music. Down the road an ability to bang off a tune at a party is far more useful to a beginner than knowledge of music theory. Makes people happier too!
- jeremiep 10y agoOne doesn't prevent the other! I was lucky that my music teachers found it important for us to both learn theory every week, but also a complete song matching our skills level. So while we'd have scales and chords to practice, we'd also have songs to play at parties and whatnot from the beginning. What I didn't realize at the time is that practicing chords and scales not only builds knowledge of how notes sounds and relate to each other, it also builds muscle memory and makes you play with less and less effort until it becomes effortless. At which point the songs you learned really, really start to shine. Its easy to dismiss practice as boring and "only for professionals" but once you start seeing what it yields you realize it is incredibly important to any musician. Much like reading a book from an author who understands grammar and has a large vocabulary is a much richer experience than reading a book from someone who hasn't put the effort in learning it all. Not only that, understanding the grammar makes you appreciate the works of others on a much deeper level. Same goes for understanding music theory - it improves your listening experience.
- nitrogen 10y agoInstead of focusing on music and sound, music teachers try to teach note names, sitting posture, curving your hands ect Poor hand and back posture can lead to very serious injury, potentially even the loss of mobility. Of all the tedium of learning to play the piano, this is one area you should not skip. Further, you need to learn note names so you can communicate with others about your music. You need to learn good fingering or you'll never be able to play fast, and your fingers will be tripping over themselves all the time.
- liveoneggs 10y agooh how I wish any of my guitar teachers would have bothered to teach technique, music, notes, hand positioning, anything! All of them asked for their $40 and then asked me to bring in music I liked so I could memorize a few songs without any explanation for what was going on.
- serge2k 10y ago> Endless learning of grammar doesn't make one a good author Being able to write out passages from your favorite book doesn't either. Even if you can write out Ulysses from memory. Having a strong knowledge of the rules of language and the structure of story will make you a better author.