11 ms·
I don't see how charging tax on cash is the solution to this problem of people not paying their taxes. They are punishing the person who lost at musical chairs
by sschueller 10y ago
I don't see how charging tax on cash is the solution to this problem of people not paying their taxes. They are punishing the person who lost at musical chairs or am I missing something?
How does this prevent it from happening again with the new notes? Tax system is still broken.
- whowalrus 10y agoExactly. There are rumors of bigger and more hard-hitting changes by the Govt. down the line, but yes, as it stands now, the system is still broken.
- nileshtrivedi 10y agoThis measure attacks the STOCK of black money that has accumulated over decades. Govt also needs to attack the FLOW of black money, and those changes are coming soon.
- whowalrus 10y agoGenuine question, any official sources about the changes that are coming soon?
- sameerds 10y agoThis government has always been pretty tight-lipped about upcoming changes. Decisions are made, directives are sent to the appropriate governing bodies, and then public statements are made. It's a refreshing change from the past.
- mangamadaiyan 10y agoThe tax isn't on cash. It's just regular tax - sales tax, or income tax, for that matter. Some businesses pretty much run on cash payments. That way, they can store the cash physically, and not pay tax on it. The "crackdown" is to basically ensure that this happens no longer. The intentions behind it seem to be good (from my limited viewpoint), but I guess the implementation could have gone better.
- jychang 10y agoLet's say you are an honest citizen. You earn $1000, of which all of it is properly taxed. You get $100 in cash and give it to a corrupt official in order to do something. Another person is a corrupt official/businessman; under this official, there are maybe 100 people, and each person gives this official $100 in order to get something done. This income is in the form of cash, and is untaxed. If you force everyone to put their money into a bank, then anyone who pays their taxes already has their $900 in assets accounted for and don't need to pay more taxes. If you have $10,000 in cash you need to deposit into a bank and no documentation for it... you'll have a bad time. There is no musical chairs, since the money flows upwards. If you are honest, you should not get hit by any additional taxes. This is the reason why currently most of India supports the move of discontinuing the old currency and replacing it. Unless you take in a large amount over your taxed salary as untaxed bribes, it doesn't affect the amount of money you have.
- mangamadaiyan 10y agoThank you, that explanation worked better than mine. You pretty much hit the nail on the head.
- wav-part 10y agoExcept Govt is making more harder to prosecute corrupt public officials. See my other comment here [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13012515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13012515
- whowalrus 10y agoBut what I don't see are measures to ensure that people will continue to deposit money in the banks / pay their taxes. While I appreciate the move to force the turnover of black money now, what stops someone from starting to accumulate black money again, lets say a few months from now? I hope there are measures being taken in that account.
- a9entroy 10y agoIndian logic, in a nutshell.
- an_account 10y agoThey aren't charging a tax on cash. But if you exchange a large amount of cash, they will look up your past income tax records and if it doesn't line up with the amount of cash you have then you get taxed. Indian has a problem with large hoards of cash being used to evade taxes. This is basically a come to Jesus moment for tax evaders with these hoards. It is a pretty crazy policy, but this article glosses over some major points.
- jacobolus 10y agoThere are plenty of folks who think that the US should phase out $100 bills and Europe should phase out €500 bills for essentially the same reason: they are used primarily by people trying to do very large transactions in an untraceable way, which has big overlap with money laundering, drug deals and other illegal purchases, tax evasion, etc. Most day-to-day cash transactions work perfectly fine using $20 bills. See e.g. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/02/16/its-time-to-kill-the-100-bill/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/02/16/its-t... > [...] illicit activities are facilitated when a million dollars weighs 2.2 pounds as with the 500 euro note rather than more than 50 pounds as would be the case if the $20 bill was the high denomination note.
- macrolide 10y agoLet's see the US government do it; it'll be the end of the dollar. People around the world presently rely on the dollar; they'll eagerly move to an anonymous cryptocurrency (not Bitcoin).
- patrickk 10y ago80% of US currency is in $100s[1] The ECB is getting rid of the €500 note[2] [1] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/08/14/340356790/should-we-kill-the-100-bill http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/08/14/340356790/shoul... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/05/business/international/ecb-to-remove-500-bill-the-bin-laden-bank-note-criminals.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/05/business/international/ecb...
- tdkl 10y ago
- moh_maya 10y agoThis move is just one of many steps. Let me first establish the context and list the other pieces (as I understand them): > India recently executed / implemented a nationwide biometrics id scheme which has now allowed the govt. to create bank accounts for a very large fraction of the population that previously didnt have access to banking. The untaxed / cash based transaction system has distorted multiple facets of the Indian society and economy: from vote buying to a distorted realty market. This also blocks investment. When 20% of your net economy is sitting in closets, it is a large wasted opportunity. > Apropos the fragmented tax system, the Indian parliament finally passed a monumental tax reform pack (first proposed by the opposition parties when they were in power and then opposed by BJP, the current dispensation in power, but I digress). > This bill, among others moves the country to a digital transaction / electronic payments based tax & transaction system. > The govt has clearly established a desire (and has now demonstrated the will) to move towards an electronic payment / transaction system, the benefits of which are obvious, especially in terms of minimising pilfering of welfare money, etc. (The national ID scheme now allows for direct cash transfers without middlemen, corruption, etc.) (You can see where this is leading..) 86% of the Indian currency is high value (denominated in the ₹500 and ₹1000 notes that have now been banned). The govt has stated that the new high denomination notes that are being issued will not replace the entire 86% in physical cash. It will be a smaller fraction. This does two things: a) people who deposit old currency notes will now, perforce, have to move to electronic / card based transactions. b) it forces individuals to declare their "black" or untaxed money and also move to the electronic payments system. So, I think this move helps significantly since it is part of a larger push towards electronic transactions etc. In conjunction with the changes in the tax system (and expected / anticipated reduction in income tax rates / increase in exemptions), this move, while painful in the short term, is potentially transformative for the Indian economy and society.
- DesiLurker 10y agolike your name
- moh_maya 10y agoThanks :)
- NTDF9 10y ago>> They are punishing the person who lost at musical chairs or am I missing something? There was an amnesty window leading up to this. Until Sept 2016, all black money could have been deposited in bank accounts in India, no questions asked, taxed at usual income rates. The people suffering now are the ones who took the Indian Tax system for granted. >> How does this prevent it from happening again with the new notes? Tax system is still broken. Fear of losing more than half your net-worth again.
- pramit 10y agoI agree. Modi should have gone after making the Indian tax system efficient. And less corrupt.