5 ms·
Why doesn't the financial industry consider a public blockchain? How do big financial companies consider resolving adversity like judgments/liens/etc against a
by wyldfire 10y ago
Why doesn't the financial industry consider a public blockchain?
How do big financial companies consider resolving adversity like judgments/liens/etc against an settlement based system that's an automaton?
- known 10y agoAccounting, auditing and compliance are a massive cost for business globally. (Fines alone have cost banking $200 billion since 2009.) Blockchain accounting could help cut those costs. For example, instead of a company employing its own auditors to examine the books of its various units, all transactions could be logged on an internal blockchain, and recorded centrally. Likewise, external auditors or even regulators could inspect a corporation’s books in real time. Even the accounting firms that make their money from auditing see the value in the technology: “This solution could significantly reduce the reliance on auditors for testing financial transactions,” Matt Spoke http://qz.com/629662/the-unsexy-future-of-blockchain-is-accounting/ http://qz.com/629662/the-unsexy-future-of-blockchain-is-acco...
- sseveran 10y agoBanks typically already have some sort of realtime risk management system. Goldman's SecDB is quite famous. Banks typically have whatever risk controls in place they want. Blockchains aren't going to provide any magic here. The fines banks have faced haven't come from the lack of a central repository of trades.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- appleflaxen 10y agothe real answer is because they have a monopoly on clearance mechanisms in the status quo, and want to retain control over it.
- nickonline 10y agoAlmost none of the use cases financial institutions look to blockchain to solve have anything to do with settlement or clearance.
- brilliantcode 10y agoFinancial companies and banks already trust each other. It doesn't make sense for them to be held under public scrutiny with a public ledger. Therefore, blockchain is a solution without a problem for financial institutions. Their needs are already well met and there's little incentive to change. It worked for a 1000+ years why uproot everything for a buzzword ? Of course they aren't going to change.
- alblue 10y agoActually modern finance has its roots in the coffee houses of London, circa 1650. http://www.history.co.uk/study-topics/history-of-london/londons-coffee-houses http://www.history.co.uk/study-topics/history-of-london/lond... These were the meeting places in which the maritime insurance deals were made at a time of increasing maritime exploration by the British. These also evolved to be the places such materials were bought and sold - and in fact the trading pits were (and in some cases are) based on these gathering locations. It's interesting to visit the London Metal Exchange which although computerised has the trader pit (complete with circular sofa) in which trades are still conducted between traders. In an interesting turn of fate the very docks that the traders made possible subsequently collapsed with the introduction of container shipping and ships which were too large to navigate the Thames, and pushed shipping ports to the periphery of the country. In an ironic twist of fate these docks then became the Docklands and home to London's financial district. Right up until Brexit, when the financial centre was destroyed by petty minded little England, ending four hundred years of global outlook for the sake of believing in lies.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y ago> when the financial centre was destroyed by petty minded little England Perhaps if the 'financial centre' were not so ... self-centered ...
- wtbob 10y agoNice comment, right up until your final sentence, which just drips with bitterness.
- thinkloop 10y ago> Why doesn't the financial industry consider a public blockchain? - Unnecessary uncertainty: public blockchains can fork (i.e. ethereum) or change (bitcoin block size debate, segwit, etc) unrelated to your needs. - Dealing with forks, and various other behaviors adds lots of unnecessary complexity. - Less secure since publicly open for anyone to attack. - Constrained feature development that requires consideration of all actors. - Slower and more expensive: public blockchains require world-leading mining power and lots of time (60+ mins, 6 confirmations) to remain secure from government-scale attacks. - If proof of stake is used (untested), instead of proof of work, to mitigate the cost and time issues, then you introduce many unrelated actors influencing core aspects of your business. I can't see why a private consortium of banks would replace their currently custom, private, controlled databases and code, with public ones. > How do big financial companies consider resolving adversity like judgments/liens/etc against an settlement based system that's an automaton? The system isn't an automation, there are still the same decisions being made, they are just being recorded in a smarter way that cuts out a lot of unnecessary verification/trust work. They still have relationships with each other, each other's identities, and legal agreements enforcing all their actions. If funds need to be returned, a new transaction is created to return them. Liens can be coded into assets for convenience, etc. Any automation they choose to add in smart-contract type things is optional, and can be done gradually. Without all the public features, the core blockchain becomes very simple, basically a chronological db of signed transactions - but it still gets to keeep the sexy name.