3 ms·
You can't actually use any non-Xiph codecs in an Ogg container in the real world [...] because they don't document any of it He covers this in the article. If
by ZeroGravitas 17y ago
You can't actually use any non-Xiph codecs in an Ogg container in the real world [...] because they don't document any of it
He covers this in the article. If you want to say the the documentation is lacking, just say that, and they'll explain that they don't want to encourage mixing of open and non-open codecs. If you want to focus on the can't actually use non-Xiph codecs in an OGG container side, then you'd have to explain how Dirac and Flac managed to be put in the container without any change to Ogg.
One is a (unfounded?) criticism of the technology or API of Ogg, the other is criticism of a Xiph policy decision to promote open codecs. Don't just throw stuff at the wall to see what sticks.
Also, if seeking is broken in Quicktime for both Ogg and Flac, two containers with very different approaches, maybe blaming Ogg is illogical? There's no obvious reason to even mention Flac as, despite coming under the Xiph umbrella once it was a popular free codec, it was developed independently.
- blasdel 17y agoMy point was not that using alternate codecs was technically impossible, but that it was de facto infeasible — nobody does it (because you'd only want to use it if you already wanted to use a free codec for it's freedom), as such nobody tests against it, so it won't be well supported by implementations, not even to necessarily give you a 'codec not found' error message. You're right that OGG and native Flac are different containers, with differently stupid approaches (aiming too high and too low, respectively). The later Flac formats do specify OGG's broken metadata system, one of several reasons that nobody ever distributes Flac files with any internal metadata. I've never seen a Flac-in-OGG file in the wild, but I imagine that seeking is at least as broken there. Seeking in Quicktime works just fine for all manner of esoteric codecs and containers — the problem is with the FOSS stuff where they decided that they'd do something inventive, and ended up with something pointlessly different — enough to make it annoying to integrate into any existing system — and no better than what everyone else does. Sometimes what scratches your own itch and is fun to implement is no good for anyone else to actually use.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoQuicktime works just fine for all manner of esoteric codecs and containers — the problem is with the FOSS stuff where they decided that they'd do something inventive, and ended up with something pointlessly different So it works with all manner of esoteric stuff as long as it's not inventive, or different? That's a very limited definition of esoteric. And I've heard enough complaining about Quicktime over the years to not automatically give it the benefit of the doubt.
- metajack 17y agoPeople have indeed put many things (some strange) into the Ogg format. I was once contracted to build MIDI + Vorbis support and I added a mapping for MIDI in Ogg fairly easily. Granted, I was heavily involved with Xiph, but I am not Monty. It took a little digging and one or two questions I'm sure, but it wasn't rocket science. The end result worked spectacularly well.