5 ms·
When people say they will act one way and have financial incentives to act another, expect them to follow the financial incentives. Appropriate regulation can
by btilly 17y ago
When people say they will act one way and have financial incentives to act another, expect them to follow the financial incentives.
Appropriate regulation can help for a bit. But unfortunately the regulated party has incentives to provide incentives (such as contributions to political campaigns) to gain control of the regulations. This leads to regulatory capture that then renders the regulations ineffective.
In a perfect world we'd be forcing the banks right now to write down securities that took a hit, forcing them to declare losses, which would mean that they wouldn't be paying out absurd bonuses. This would absorb the money we gave them from the bailout. In a slightly less perfect world we'd be enacting useful regulations that would avoid this problem returning for a few decades (such as happened during the Great Depression).
In the real world we gave the banks a big bailout, have let them mark securities to models of their choice, and they paid themselves big bonuses on their "profits". Of course they are still sitting on lots of toxic securities (like bad CMBS and the junk bonds issued by private equity) that they have not marked down yet. When that blows up we have good odds that they'll ask for another bailout. And the behavior of both parties says that the leadership will try to get it for them. They nearly didn't manage to deliver it last time, and given the public outrage since, they may not be able to deliver it next time.
This could lead to interesting times. Interesting times.
- gaius 17y agowhich would mean that they wouldn't be paying out absurd bonuses No it wouldn't. Investment banks are huge and diverse businesses. If you're an FX trader, nothing whatsoever to do with mortgage-backed securities, and you've done your job well this year and made excellent profits (which for the bank as a whole offset their losses) then why shouldn't you get a bonus as usual? Of course the loss-making traders shouldn't get bonuses (that is after all the point of the bonus system) but lumping everyone in with them is both inaccurate and counter-productive.
- joe_bleau 17y agoI've wondered this too. As an employee of a small company, I really wish I could use the same argument (and trust me, I've tried). "Hey boss, I'm doing the work of two people, at about a 40% discount to market rates for the average embedded engineer. You don't seem to think I'm average, and there's no question that you're more than happy with my performance. I realize business is off right now and sales suck, but why shouldn't I get a bonus/raise?" "Cause we don't have any more money, and the government won't give us any." I really like my job, but sometimes it's tough not to be jealous of the world of big money and government. I guess my answer to your question might be: "because Joe two floors down blew up, and we wouldn't exist as a company anymore if not for the government bailouts".
- yummyfajitas 17y agoTry asking for the bonus Wall St style: "Hey boss, you know I am worth a lot. Pay me more or I quit. " Your boss may find the money, or your new job will pay more.
- btilly 17y agoThe better way to do this is to find the other job, get that offer, then go to your current employer and say, "Another company is gave me an offer for more salary elsewhere, but I don't want to go there for reasons X, Y and Z. However (name financial reason - spouses are convenient) is pushing me to take the money. Can you help me?" The fact that you went to your employer first, and you made it clear that you didn't want to leave, both go a long way to mitigate the possibility of bad emotional reactions. (They don't eliminate it, but they mitigate it.) And they put you in a position to renegotiate your salary. Furthermore if it doesn't work, your fallback is a new job at higher pay. Be warned, though, that this is a bullet you can only fire once. Having done it, you've burned some social capital. If you keep going back to that well, your employer is going to eventually cut you loose. Also be warned that if you have actually accepted a job elsewhere, you should never accept a counter-offer. In that situation your employer will be willing to offer a lot because they are desperate, but they know that it is just a question of time until they lose unhappy people. So they will work to replace you, and it is just a question of time until you are fired with no job offer in hand. That's why if you try this it is critically important to go to your employer with the message that you want to stay, but (financial situation X) is a problem for you. (It helps, a lot, if the financial situation is both real and known to your employer.)
- anigbrowl 17y agoI'm sure the head chef on the Titanic wasn't too happy when it started sinking either. Big powerful organizations attract skilled employees by offering status, pay and economic security. And at the individual level, diligent and honest performance should indeed be rewarded. But the whole reason most of us obey the law and pay our taxes is founded on the idea of mutuality: our interdependence is essential to freedom economic success. Commercial losses are ultimately a shareholders' problem. But when the public become shareholders or creditors by necessity, it's facile to say that individually successful employees are economic free agents who should earn the full reward of their productivity. Nothing prevents them from leaving to join a more stable competitor, or establishing their own funds: if they choose to stay with an organization that benefits from public expenditure, they've made a choice of financial security over financial liberty. Besides, limiting the bonus payments of the productive employees when other staff rack up huge losses is a fabulous economic incentive to improve risk management and governance within the organization. Those who consider such matters above their pay grade or outside their job description are obviously not ready to leave the kiddie pool.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoEffective regulations are those regulations that change the balance of incentives to remove moral hazards and internalize externalities.
- btilly 17y agoThat is true. But the organizations that have been forced to internalize externalities have a strong desire to externalize them again. And will try to change the regulations to allow them to do so. Success is generally a question of when, not if. As an example we averaged one credit crisis per decade for over a hundred years. Then Depression era regulations such as Glass-Steagall put an end to that for several decades. The regulations were eroded then finally removed, and a decade later we had a credit crisis. The Depression era regulations succeeded. But a later generation came to believe that the threat they were blocking was hollow, and the regulations changed.
- anamax 17y agoAnd unicorns are magic horses. The properties of ideal entities aren't much use in a universe where nothing approximating such entities actually exists. Note that Fannie and Freddie actually lied about the mortgages pools that they constructed (said mortgages contained more subprime than they admitted). This not only defrauded the folks who bought those pools, it also made the entire mortgage market look safer than it actually was. Note that it was regulators who pushed subprime mortgages and insurance for such securities (so they could justify "encouraging" banks to hold them as regulated assets). Said regulators also gave ratings monopoly AND told banks that they had to hold Fannie and Freddie stock, which put many of them into technical default when Fannie and Freddie went down. At best, regulation is systemic risk. Often, it's corruption backed by a threat of violence.
- Symmetry 17y agoWhats that economics law that says something like "Once pressure is put upon an observed regularity in the markets for control purposes it tends to disappear"? When buyers only cared about the truth of a rating they had a pretty good reason to want the ratings to be as accurate as possible (counteracting the seller's incentives). But as soon as reserve requirements are dependent on how what the credit rating says suddenly both the buyer and the seller have an incentive for things to be rated as highly as possible.
- barry-cotter 17y agoLucas Critique http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique