3 ms·
These ideas aren't easily disproven. The evidence you are giving (basically carbon dating) is widely disbelieved by creationists: http://www.google.com/search?
by nl 17y ago
These ideas aren't easily disproven.
The evidence you are giving (basically carbon dating) is widely disbelieved by creationists: http://www.google.com/search?q=carbon+dating+false http://www.google.com/search?q=carbon+dating+false
Basically they find themselves enough problems with the theory of carbon dating that it lets them keep an internally consistent model (eg, "yes, I am a rational person, but all those scientist using carbon dating didn't take into account the effect changes in the earths magnetic field have on Carbon 14 production" http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/nab/does-c14-disprove-the-bible http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/nab/does-c14-dispro...)
Yes, you can disprove this too. But soon you are requiring such a level of knowledge that you and the other person are just quoting random sources from the Internet.
Sure, your sources may be real peer-reviewed journals and theirs may be blogs, but then you'll have to prove your sources are better than theirs (which isn't easy, given the amount of valid criticism peer-reviewed journals get). Soon the argument will come down to authority on the internet you'll end up arguing that Perelman's (Fields medal winning) non-peer reviewed solution to the Poincaré conjecture is okay, but other crazy theories in the same pre-print archive are not okay because umm.. they just aren't.
I agree they are gullible. But I don't think proving it is as easy as you may think.
- sp332 17y ago>Sure, your sources may be real peer-reviewed journals and theirs may be blogs Or they might just start a peer-reviewed journal to point at. This one's been around for a while. http://creation.com/periodicals#journal_of_creation http://creation.com/periodicals#journal_of_creation There's even a pretty sophisticated cosmological model that tries to fix some of the timescale issues. http://www.icr.org/article/seven-years-starlight-time/ http://www.icr.org/article/seven-years-starlight-time/ This kind of thing makes the argument even harder.
- eru 17y agoI had a physics teacher who liked to discuss with crackpots (not too many hardcore Christians in Germany). He agreed with what your saying: Disproving their models is hard, and those guys aren't stupid. As an exercise: Try to convince me that the Earth isn't flat.