8 ms·
This is long past due. I'm on a facebook list for dads, and after it came out that a homeopathic teething gel killed 10 kids (http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19
by empath75 10y ago
This is long past due.
I'm on a facebook list for dads, and after it came out that a homeopathic teething gel killed 10 kids (http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19/health/teething-remedies-infant-deaths.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/19/health/teething-remedies-i...) someone asked if it was worth the risk to keep giving to his kids, since it worked.
I tried to explain to him that homeopathic medicine is either 1) Nothing, if they diluted it 'correctly', or never bothered to put the poison in there to begin with or 2) Poison, if they failed to dilute it properly 3) Maybe some kind of actual medicine, in which case it's not actually homeopathic.
There are no other options.
He responded: "Well, it seemed to work for my kid, so I'm going to keep using it."
- DanBC 10y agoThat teething gel really changed my opinion from "harmless, but dumb" to "potentially fatal or severely harmful, and also dumb, and also allowing children to suffer the teething pain". There were an additional 400 children caused serious harm. I'm baffled by the attitude of parents like the one you mention.
- Veen 10y agoI don't think the "it's harmless" argument holds water whether or not they screw up the dilution: http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html
- Alex3917 10y ago> Nothing, if they diluted it 'correctly', or never bothered to put the poison in there to begin with There are both high-dilutionists and low-dilutionists within homeopathy.[1][2] I'm not saying you should run out and buy a bunch of homeopathic remedies or whatever, but also realize that the mainstream 'skeptic' account of homeopathy is not especially accurate. Also realize that the latest scientific research on food allergies involves homeopathic-like mithridatism, so even though the idea of a like-cures-like high dilutionist treatment isn't anywhere near a universal panacea, it does at least appear to work in certain limited cases. [1] https://www.amazon.com/History-American-Homeopathy-Academic-1820-1935-ebook/dp/B01KI63DYU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1479752156&sr=8-1&keywords=academic+history+of+homeopathy https://www.amazon.com/History-American-Homeopathy-Academic-... [2] http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/202602 http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/202602
- tdb7893 10y agoIf they actually go through the proper channels and test their cures then I'll gladly accept them. Until that they are pretty much just a pseudoscience.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWoah, are you seriously comparing immunotherapy to homeopathy? One has no basis in reality and no known mechanism of action. The other has a solid scientific and biological foundation behind it. Nor is immunotherapy the "latest scientific research," its been around for decades. James Randi famously starts out talks swallowing an entire bottle of homeopathic sleeping pills. He's not dead yet despite being almost 90.
- will_brown 10y agoI agree with him, but I don't believe he is comparing immunotherapy to homeopathy. Moreover, if you read the article it pretty much drops the use of Homeopathy for the very specific definition of like cures like and calls it like cures like pseudoscience and stated like cures like has never worked for any condition. I don't mind attacking homeopathy but once we begin using the very specific definition of like cure like and calling that basic principle pseudoscience...that is when I take issue with it because that is the exact principle immunnotherapy for allergies is based on.
- ryuker16 10y agobad idea.... I wouldn't be surprised if one shady homeopathic maker just put real pills in to save cash and increase efficiency.
- Alex3917 10y ago> James Randi famously starts out talks swallowing an entire bottle of homeopathic sleeping pills. And that's exactly why I posted my comment, because it's wildly irresponsible to post comments leading people to believe that they can do the same thing and come away unharmed. The fact is that if you chug a bottle of 3x diluted poison ivy oil then you're almost certainly going to die. And not because it wasn't diluted properly, because it had other ingredients, etc. Most homeopathic treatments on the market today are highly diluted. But not all. And since historically there was more of an even split between high dilutionists and low dilutionists, it's not unlikely that in the future even more low dilution homeopathic products will come on the market. So when you post shit that's going to come up in Google for the next twenty years that's implicitly encouraging folks to try some stunt that could easily get them killed, don't expect to not get called out on it.
- paublyrne 10y agoLike a rock that keeps away tigers.
- mortenjorck 10y agoCVS widely sold a product for infants whose active ingredient was deadly nightshade? Am I reading this correctly?
- Overtonwindow 10y agoYes this is correct. The idea of homeopathy is that "like cures like" so poison cures poison, diluted disease kills disease. It's total BS and has no basis in science what so ever.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThe idea does have some basis with vaccines. Though vaccines are a prevention and not a cure. It looks like both homeopathy and the vaccine were even introduced in the same year(1796), which was a spooky coincidence when I looked it up just now.
- dqv 10y agoVaccinations don't employ "water memory". There is a discernable, detectable pathogen that the immune system responds to. There is no "dilute this and say there is a physically impossible ratio of this chemical to water" in vaccinations.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoThese are all true facts which I agree with, and I haven't said anything to the contrary.
- fucking_tragedy 10y ago> The idea does have some basis with vaccines. Though vaccines are a prevention and not a cure. Not even close to the same thing.
- npunt 10y agoSadly, we've all been subconsciously conditioned to believe something like this from The Princess Bride scene where Wesley built up an immunity to Iocane powder. :/
- rdtsc 10y ago> Hyland’s recalled teething products in 2010, after a warning from the F.D.A. that they contained inconsistent amounts of belladonna. The company changed the formula and then began selling them again in 2011. Wow. That is messed up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atropa_belladonna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atropa_belladonna is not something to be playing with when it comes to "inconsistent amounts". --- The foliage and berries are extremely toxic, containing tropane alkaloids. These toxins include atropine, scopolamine and hyoscyamine, which cause a bizarre delirium and hallucinations,[1] and are also used as pharmaceutical anticholinergics. --- Yap, perfect for unregulated "natural" cure for babies.
- rlpb 10y ago> There are no other options. To be fair, there is: 4) Placebo. Placebos do work. So it might well be working for his kid.
- Angostura 10y agoThat would be 1) then.
- mikestew 10y agoTurns out, though, that one study found placebos are more effective than homeopathic solutions. (Too lazy to find the link, but "I read it somewhere"). At best, the links I could find claim homeopathic medicine is no better than a placebo.
- cheiVia0 10y agoIt might work for the parent, but I'm not sure a 6 month old would understand what it's stopped to do for the placebo effect to work...
- DannyB2 10y ago> homeopathic medicine is either 1) Nothing, if they diluted it 'correctly', > or never bothered to put the poison in there to begin with In that case, it would be pure water, and therefore it would be completely effective for treating the condition of dehydration.
- codezero 10y agoPure water is dangerous for treating clinical dehydration though, you'd want some electrolytes in the water.
- jamiesonbecker 10y agoThis dad has a real problem and is looking in the (dangerously) wrong place for solutions. Maybe you can suggest a few things that do work.. Rubber teethers with a gel in them that you can put in the freezer and get cold, but not so cold they burn or feel uncomfortable or could choke them (like ice cubes). Cut, cool, washed celery stalks at least 4" long, so the baby (or you) can pull them back out of their mouth if the baby starts to stuff them down their throat (which happens). The baby will instinctively pull it back out if it hurts. (Note: carrots and most other vegetables are NOT safe, because the baby can break off little pieces and choke on them, but you can put them in a baby straining mesh thing to keep small pieces from choking them.) To all parents (especially on sites that are not HN): please do not put anything in your baby's mouth that might hurt them. It's better to listen to them cry then to risk hurting them. EDIT: removed anbesol/orajel suggestion as unsafe and probably ineffective anyway.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThe FDA recommends against any medicines (including Anbesol and Orajel) for the "treatment" of teething but then they wallow a little bit and add "except under the advice and supervision of a health care professional." They recommend putting pressure on the child's gums and/or providing a cold washcloth or teething ring to chew on. Make sure you supervise so the child doesn't choke. http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm385817.htm http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm385817.ht... The AAP are more direct "The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend putting any prescription or over-the-counter pain relievers or medication that contain lidocaine [Anbesol] or benzocaine [Orajel] on babies' gums. These products are not useful for teething pain because they wash out of the baby's mouth in minutes." https://www.aappublications.org/content/35/8/32.1 https://www.aappublications.org/content/35/8/32.1 In short, the actual medicine is just as bad. It also doesn't work and causes death. Neither organization recommend the use of vegetables.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Elhana 10y ago