6 ms·
> People won't listen though because... ... they don't particularly want to lift floorboards, and drill through floors and ceilings if the wireless solution is
by Angostura 10y ago
> People won't listen though because...
... they don't particularly want to lift floorboards, and drill through floors and ceilings if the wireless solution is 'good enough'.
- equalarrow 10y agoExactly. I have a few things wired in the house where they're actually close enough to a switch. But for phones and tables and laptops (we have several), wired is not an option. This is also shitty news because I had very high confidence that an Apple router would not ship with any kind of malware or other crap I don't need. Now, I have to find something better, comparable in price, and works well with Mac household.. Sad face.
- Declanomous 10y agoIt's important to note that wiring what you can makes the WiFi that much faster for everything else as well.
- freehunter 10y agoBut when wifi is faster than 1Gbps, does it matter anymore? Obviously if you're talking servers and enterprise equipment, faster is better. But does my smart TV or iPad really need that extra little bit of speed? Netflix only streams as fast as my Internet connection, which is 60Mbps. I could have 15 devices on my network streaming Netflix each on their own dedicated Internet connection and still not saturate an 802.11ac router (theoretically).
- adiabatty 10y agoYou'll get 4K Netflix eventually. Plus, theoretical speeds, not actual. Plus you'd want to buffer quickly…
- walshemj 10y agoGood luck getting any range with 1GBS :-)
- Declanomous 10y agoI don't know anyone who even approaches the theoretical speed of any 802.11 technology. Your neighbors on the same channel reduce your bandwidth, and neighbors on channels which overlap yours raise the noise floor a lot. I have a Moto X Pure and a Ubiquiti Unifi AP AC Lite, and I should theoretically get 867 mbit/s. I never even approach that in practice, even if I'm in the same room. There are more than 30 available networks nearby when I look on my phone. Even if I achieved the theoretical rate, the bandwidth falls off a cliff once you leave the room, as 5ghz signals are significantly attenuated by walls. I can max out my internet (75 mbit) if I'm in the same room as my AP, but I can't stream 1080p content on the 5ghz if I have 2 walls between me and my AP. That being said, the Apple APs are the fastest consumer-grade APs out there. If you are going to hit the theoretical maximum, an Apple AP is your best bet. I don't think streaming is where people notice issues with their internet though. In my experience people tend to notice issues in video games, skype, facetime, and other applications where there isn't a buffer to hide issues with dropped packets first.
- com2kid 10y ago> I don't know anyone who even approaches the theoretical speed of any 802.11 technology. I max out my cable modem's connection. I pay for 50mb/s, and 802.11n on a 5Ghz channel is more than sufficient. At work however, yes, that gigabit wired ethernet connection is really nice. :)
- symfoniq 10y agoMy Airport Extreme hits 750-800 mbps pretty routinely, despite my devices being able to pick up about 10 other neighborhood wifi networks. However, I get ~950 mbps over the wire (on a 1 gbps connection), so I still plug in when I'm sitting at my desk and need to transmit large files.
- PaulHoule 10y agoI dunno. iTunes is close to malware in my book.
- Nullabillity 10y ago> and works well with Mac household.. Sad face. Apart from Apple's and Google's idiotic antics, what routers require anything more than a browser to configure?
- NickNameNick 10y agoI've seen a disturbing number of routers which have web interfaces that only work with old versions of IE. Good luck configuring that with a mac....
- wahern 10y agoRequiring a browser implies that the device has a full web stack on it, including one of Perl, PHP, or Node.js. That's the last thing I want on my WiFi router, or any router! As annoying as it is for some, the configuration interface for Apple AirPort used a simple SNMP interface. Now, lots of SNMP software has had bugs and remote exploits, but all things being equal it's a much simpler interface to export and requires shipping less code, not least because it doesn't have to support a GUI, directly or indirectly. That said, I always configure my WiFi router (AirPort or w'ever) in bridging mode and put them behind my gateway. And I try to disable any web GUI entirely if at all possible. People who use the built-in WiFi capabilities of their Cable or DSL modems are begging to be hacked.
- extra88 10y ago> Requiring a browser implies that the device has a full web stack on it, including one of Perl, PHP, or Node.js. Not really, CGI can be written in anything, shell scripting, C, whatever. But security-wise, it doesn't much matter the language because the programmers working on the web interfaces of such embedded devices rarely do a good job.
- Nullabillity 10y ago> That's the last thing I want on my WiFi router, or any router! Considering the amount of crappy C most routers have, that's probably the least of your concerns.
- wahern 10y agoThe new Google WiFi product uses the same secure boot procedure as Chromebook. I really like AirPort for it's simplicity, performance, and lack of a web stack. I think my new WiFi router(s) will be Google WiFi as they seem to have upped the bar on all those points. I'm not thrilled about the autoupdate feature of Google WiFi. I wouldn't be surprised if it's leveraged to benefit Google's analytics, or for government snooping. But the greater risk at this point is from criminal hackers. And I prefer running my WiFi routers in bridging mode, anyhow, making it less likely Google will bother tracking my family's browsing from the LAN. Maintaining my own homegrown router isn't appealing, though. For one thing, all the hardware available for that is sub-par. Solid support for MIMO and beamforming is mostly non-existent except for proprietary stacks; even simultaneous multi-channel is iffy using open source solutions. AirPort always shipped with better than average support for the latest tech, and I'm not keen on going backward in that regard, especially for what should be a performance upgrade.
- pgeorgi 10y ago> I wouldn't be surprised if it's leveraged to benefit Google's analytics, ... https://support.google.com/wifi/answer/6246642 https://support.google.com/wifi/answer/6246642 has a tl;dr version: "Importantly, the Google Wifi app and your Wifi points do not track the websites you visit or collect the content of any traffic on your network. However, your Wifi points does collect data such as Wi-Fi channel, signal strength, and device types that are relevant to optimize your Wi-Fi performance." and a full explanation of everything it does (or does not) collect, and why.
- aab0 10y agoWhich can be changed at any time.
- Declanomous 10y agoI think it is mostly because they don't understand how much better wired internet is than wireless. I've basically forced many people to connect their devices with Ethernet as a "temporary" measure to solve their problems. For the most part, every single person has decided to leave whatever it is connected. Almost all my friends rent too, which is a huge barrier to using wires, since the wires can't be hidden in the walls or ceilings. One of the big things that people don't realize is that bandwidth of wireless is split between every device on that channel. So if you are streaming to your TV/roku/xbox/etc over wifi, you are killing the bandwidth for your laptop and phone as well. Plus, if you live in a city your wireless bandwidth is pretty much guaranteed to suck because every ISP includes wifi with their modems, destroying the noise floor. Comcast modems are a particularly notable example, as they have a "public" 2.4 ghz network in addition to the "private" 2.5 and 5 ghz networks. There are no fewer than 30 wifi networks available inside my house when I check on my phone, and I live in a row house with metal lathe under the plaster, which greatly attenuates wifi signals. I think the biggest barrier to wiring things is that patch cables are incredibly expensive if you buy them at Best Buy, etc. Most non-technical people I know only own the patch cable that came with their modem. Once I get them wired up, they are astounded by how much faster their internet is. They don't have buffering issues, the internet doesn't drop randomly, and it just seems "faster" (which I attribute to lower latency). I toss extra patch cables in my Monoprice orders now and sell them to my friends at-cost. To be honest, it's partially for my own sanity as well, because watching Netflix at 480p on a 50/15 connection drives me nuts.
- vwoolf 10y agoI think it is mostly because they don't understand how much better wired internet is than wireless. I've basically forced many people to connect their devices with Ethernet as a "temporary" measure to solve their problems. For the most part, every single person has decided to leave whatever it is connected. Yes. Same here. Ethernet is an oddly underrated technology. And Monoprice is one of these things that nerds know about and no one else does. There may be other companies like that—someone above mentioned an enterprise router company that sells better stuff than most consumer companies. Yet I've already forgotten its name.
- stcredzero 10y agoI remember seeing an Ethernet like network that used infrared lasers bounced off of a particular spot on the ceiling. It should be possible to get multi-gigabyte rates out of something like that, and it should be immune to interference from the neighbors. For a game machine, you'd want to be careful where you placed the transmitter and the ceiling spot. Also, I wouldn't put it past a teenage competitive gamer to mess up a rival with an infrared laser pointed through a window.
- lostlogin 10y agoOr find that when you pay a pro to do it tidily they actually do even more of a hack job.
- korethr 10y agoOne neeed not lift floorboards, or drill through floors and ceilings to run wires. What I have done in my apartment, and what friends have done in their houses is run the wires along the base or tops of walls, tucked out of the way. Then one need not worry about pets or vacuum cleaners getting at the wires to chew them up, or getting tripped up by wires laying loose across the floor. There's a 100' meter limit for copper cables for ethernet. In my experience, that's plenty for most homes and offices, even when running along the walls.
- revscat 10y agoCan you recommend something for attaching cables to ceilings in a nondestructive manner? I also live in an apartment and this is a concern.
- extra88 10y agoGoogle "nail in cable clips." A small nail makes a small hole but if you run the cable along a wooden baseboard or molding, the holes aren't really noticeable (not like a hole in the wall from hanging a picture). There are adhesive cable clips but I've never used them, they're probably more expensive especially if they're the "Command(tm)" adhesive that's supposed to come off cleanly.
- baq 10y ago3m has everything necessary: http://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/~/Command-Clear-Small-Cord-Clips?N=5924736+3294529207+3294737326&rt=rud http://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/~/Command-C... http://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/?N=5924736+3294529207+3294737327&rt=rud http://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/?N=5924736+...
- wang_li 10y agoIf your rooms are carpeted, there is actually a gap between the baseboard and the floor. With care you can fit coax or cat5 in there no problem. It ends up completely hidden.
- mjevans 10y ago
- VMG 10y agopowerline is an option as well
- speleding 10y agoPeople seem not to be very rational about it though. I know people who spend $20K and several weeks redecorating the kitchen and yet they keep futzing around and complaining about poor internet connectivity in their house that a professional could fix for well below $1K.
- pyre 10y agoSpending $20k on your kitchen can be rationalized into the resale value of your house. The wiring less so.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoWhile obviously not as good as Ethernet, the internet-over-power-cable (powerline) solutions aren't a terrible option. In my apartment, the biggest issue I face is interference from other wireless routers. Because of this, the powerline performance is about 40% faster on my desktop (right above the router one floor) and much more consistent. It also does help with wireless congestion, and really helps with using my desktop as a PLEX server. Before, higher bitrates would cause serious issues, and now it just works. I'm not sure if the tech has matured recently or I just had a good use-case for it, but it's miles better than WiFi. I'm using TP-Link's product.
- s_q_b 10y agoOne current high-speed option is a MoCA 2.0 network through the existing coax, which has bandwidth up to 1 Gbps. I have a MoCA adapter next to each TV, wire the television through Ethernet from the adapter, and hook up a WiFi repeater as well.
- jlgaddis 10y agoI'm a network engineer so I have a "proper" setup at home: fiber-to-the-home, enterprise-class network devices (access points, switches, etc.), and so on. We were at Best Buy a while back and, while browsing around, I saw some of these "powerline" adapters on the shelf and, mostly out of curiosity, decided to buy a pair [0] of them to see how well they worked; I was doubtful of the "1200 Mbps" claim on the box. For testing, I plugged them into AC outlets along the same wall in the same room, with ~14 feet separating them. After getting them linked up (very simple), I connected laptops to each unit, manually assigned IP addresses to the laptops, and used iPerf [1] to run throughput tests. I'll spare you my rant about them but peak speeds were extremely disappointing, just shy of 50 Mbps. I honestly didn't expect anywhere near the advertised 1200 Mbps but I was expecting speeds relatively close to what I can get over my existing wireless. 50 Mbps may be quite acceptable to some, especially if one's Internet connection isn't that fast, but it was far from acceptable for me. They would also randomly "freeze" or "pause" for 20-30 seconds at a time but I didn't really investigate that issue. [0]: https://www.netgear.com/home/products/networking/powerline/PL1200.aspx?cid=wmt_netgear_organic https://www.netgear.com/home/products/networking/powerline/P... [1]: https://iperf.fr https://iperf.fr