6 ms·
For a period as a child, I was thrown in among the happy-clappy sort of evangelical Christian [1] whose answer to every problem was, "Jesus can help you with th
by wpietri 10y ago
For a period as a child, I was thrown in among the happy-clappy sort of evangelical Christian [1] whose answer to every problem was, "Jesus can help you with that!" No money? Pray to Jesus. Sick? Pray to Jesus. Husband beating you? Pray to Jesus. Not sure if Jesus is real or just Santa Claus for adults? Pray to Jesus!
This was an awful experience, but I learned a valuable lesson. When a group of people have exactly one answer to a problem, it's not even worth engaging with them. Even if they have learned to sound reasonable, their conclusion is predetermined. Evangelical fundamentalists of any sort are a waste of time.
[1] Side note: I eventually met more reasonable Christians who found this kind of horseshit just as ridiculous as I did. They had plenty of thoughtful views; even where we disagreed, we could have interesting discussions. So my objection here is not to Christianity (or blockchains), just people who have found their first shiny idea and have let it completely overwhelm them.
- heliumcraft 10y agoYou're assuming or at least implying that everyone in the Blockchain/Decentralization community thinks that Blockchain is the answer to everything which in my experience is not the case.
- dmoy 10y agoThat's not really what they said though. They explicitly said not every person who is interested in blockchain is behaving like a fundamentalist, but that perhaps people who make the leap from "blockchain works for Bitcoin" to "blockchain is going to change our political system" may be thinking like a fundamentalist. I would posit that the overwhelming majority of Bitcoin enthusiasts don't think that the blockchain is going to somehow disrupt the massive political machine we have. By nature the problems there are not really technical.
- wpietri 10y agoI am neither assuming nor implying that. You are inferring that. Incorrectly, as I was explicit that some Christians are reasonable.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoany adult who talks about jesus or god in a serious manner should be embarrassed with themselves
- chrispeel 10y agoAs a counter example to your implication that blockchain enthusiasts are fanatics, I offer my opinion that centralized tech is the right choice in many cases. For context, I'm the organizer of the Silicon Valley Ethereum meetup[1] and am hopeful that blockchains and related distributed technology will have a big impact on society. Many compare the rise of blockchain tech to the rise of the Internet; I think blockchain tech is in the protocol development stage (1970s, maybe 80s), and that it will take 5 to 25 years for the tech to evolve to the point that average person will use it (90s and 2000's). For context, in the cryptocurrency world, often the word maximalist is used to refer to hardcore tech evangelicals; so there are bitcoin maximalists and blockchain maximalists. Even though I am naturally a skeptic and not a maximalist, I don't want to discourage them. Yes, they're crazy[2]; a part of that craziness is a hope for a better future that I find refreshing. [1] http://www.meetup.com/EthereumSiliconValley/ http://www.meetup.com/EthereumSiliconValley/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8rwsuXHA7RA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8rwsuXHA7RA
- maxerickson 10y agoAre there really any successes beyond Bitcoin? (which I would call a qualified success, I think it is handy for a small group of people more than it is really having any impact on society)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- erikpukinskis 10y agoHow do you measure impact on society?
- maxerickson 10y agoIf you are just holding up a small claim of success to make your grand claim seem less silly the specifics of it don't matter a lot.
- 10y ago
- CyberDildonics 10y agoI don't see how this is remotely relevant. For starters, there is evidence that shared distributed ledgers actually exist.
- wpietri 10y agoOk. I accept you don't see it. Since I posted it, I obviously do see relevancy. Is there some way I can help you?
- CyberDildonics 10y agoYou don't realize you are conflating the idea that 'people with a hammer see everything as a nail' with 'belief in a power despite evidence of existence will solve all problems?
- gbrindisi 10y ago"If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail"
- drcode 10y agoTo be fair, in the 1800s some people started saying the answer to everything is "science" and in the 1900s others said the answer to everything is "mass production" and in those cases the people were right and we all live far better lives because of it.
- rubidium 10y agoAnd the people who claimed such things were also the ones who in 1900 said there would be no more multi-national wars. Will blockchain be a big deal? Maybe. Will it disrupt civilization as we know it. No.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- brilliantcode 10y ago> This was an awful experience, but I learned a valuable lesson. When a group of people have exactly one answer to a problem, it's not even worth engaging with them. Even if they have learned to sound reasonable, their conclusion is predetermined. Evangelical fundamentalists of any sort are a waste of time. I think you've hit the nail on the head with this one. Cryptocoin communities have reached a religious cult status. Ethereum is a good example of this. It's leaders are seen as infallible and omnipresent. Any criticism or voice of reason are quickly silenced and shunned as "shills for bitcoin". You are absolutely right that it's impossible to engage in a meaningful dialogue with such people who have such constricted views of reality. It's a waste of time and I'm going to cut it out.
- drcode 10y ago> It's leaders are seen as infallible This line amuses me because I'm definitely a complete convert in the ethereum cult and I genuinely can't think of anything Vitalik has ever said that I don't agree with 100% [1]. but I can't help it, he's genuinely an insightful guy that happens to have sensible positions on most issues. [1] OK he said some dumb things about quantum computing in 2010 when he was like 16 years old.
- brilliantcode 10y agoCurious to know what aspect of ethereum are you excited about that current solutions aren't addressing?
- drcode 10y ago1. People being able to manage their own universal identity instead of using "Sign in with Facebook" 2. Transparent financial markets on arbitrary derivates (like etherdelta.com) 3. Eventually, people authoring and managing their own content, instead of acting as free labor to generate advertising revenue for Twitter/Facebook/etc
- brilliantcode 10y ago
- walshemj 10y agoYes the article doesn't explain what problems with the various parliamentary systems are that block chain will solve. The problems with hacking of electronic voting Is solved by using paper ballots counted by hand as we do in the UK. And the problems of entryisam that the GOP has is solvable by OMOV and moving to a modern party system and not the 18th century cabals of rich land owners.