5 ms·
I gather I'm pretty unusual among sf fans in not enjoying the Culture novels, which I find maybe a little sere in their prose and a little too far gone in their
by throwanem 10y ago
I gather I'm pretty unusual among sf fans in not enjoying the Culture novels, which I find maybe a little sere in their prose and a little too far gone in their post-Singularity space opera to really resonate. I do like the ship names, though.
I also suspect that series plays a heavy role in inspiring Howard Tayler's webcomic Schlock Mercenary, whose very humble beginnings I've had the distinct pleasure of watching it far outgrow over the years. Definitely worth a look for any sf fan, mil-sf fans especially.
- ethbro 10y agoI came at the Culture novels after a childhood of (mi)spent cyberpunk reading and enjoyed them immensely. But there are novels enough for all of us to find what works for us. Banks' stuff feels surprisingly similar to Gibson's post-scifi novels to me, though I can't put a finger on the shared characteristic. Thanks for the recommendation!
- agentgt 10y agoI too came from a cyberpunk reading habit and a friend recommended the Culture series as a change. I didn't like the first book I read which I believe is the first in the series. I guess I just am a Tech Noir / Hardboiled kind of guy (I like hard scifi as well). My problem with "world/universe/space operas" books is I don't want to read them in a linear manner. I prefer to read it in a wikipedia like format where I can explore the author's created world instead of going through a story (there are exceptions of course). For example in a story when they passingly mention some alien civilization I immediately want to know everything about that civilization and am annoyed I have to wait 4 novels later to find out. In fact I have often read one book from a series and just go ahead and read up on wikipedia the plots of the rest of the novels. I often wonder if I'm the only one who thinks like this. It would be interesting if a world building type author had a wiki style pay to read collection of writings. I know some authors or fan-authors will write encyclopedias (e.g. Tolkien). The exception of course is extremely suspenseful stories. Those I can enjoy in a non encyclopedia manner.
- throwaway-hn123 10y agoThe Culture books aren't strictly a series - they're all quite independent, and you can easily read them in any order you want IMO.
- ape4 10y agoYes, its a Set.
- ethbro 10y agoTo me, world building through pacing is one of the aspects I enjoy. I guess you could call it lazy exposition evaluation. My favorite feature of cyberpunk and derivates was the willingness to mention a thing in passing, that the author knew the reader had no idea about, then gradually shade in context through the story. The "how quickly can you figure out what this thing is in this world" schtick feels... more engaged with the reader as a sentient creature than "brain dump, here's a bunch of information." Or, in the writer's quip, "Show [with skill], don't tell."
- wbl 10y agoSCP is the only one I know.
- latch 10y agoNot crazy about them either. For me, the issue is that they're basically gods (level 8 civilisation) and everything just feels like one big deus ex machina. Excession stood out as better than the rest.
- warfangle 10y agoI think that was the point? :) It's some of the most subversively existential SF I've ever read.
- ethbro 10y agoVernor Vinge's two Deep books (I haven't read the third) were right up there for me. Albeit simultaneously terrible from a "Jesus, this is %&#$ed up, but also plausible" perspective.
- throwanem 10y agoWill you elaborate? I know those words, but still the point you seek to make with them eludes me.
- schwarrrtz 10y agoOne of the big themes in the series is how people find meaning in their lives given that they basically want for nothing. When you can have any material possession created for you on demand, what do you do with yourself? For example, in The Player of Games, Gurgeh devotes his life to games of strategy, and Yay to orbital architecture. Neither character needs to work for a living, so why bother working at all?
- romaniv 10y agoIMO, there are much better novels about this subject not involving any techno-magic. Lem's Return from the Stars is an excellent work that explores this very question, and unlike Culture novels, it's down-to-earth and fully self-aware. Hard to explain what that means. Lem realized that the very notion of "meaning" will change in the future. Many works by Strugackiy brothers also deal with this question. I realize these writers belong to preceding generations of SF, but their works are still very much relevant and (IMO) far more plausible than futures of Vinge and Banks.
- jandrese 10y agoI tried to like them, but too often the main character is a total asshole and nobody calls him on it. Also, the author is a little too enthusiastic about too-clever narrative tricks like having the story told forward and backwards in alternating chapters. But mostly I got annoyed at the protagonists naval gazing and being only concerned with their immediate problems (that they usually created) when there was a giant interesting universe shoved into the background. I also tried reading one of his non-culture novels (Transition), and it had exactly the same problem of a main character that just seems to be killing time until the novel ends. My favorite characters in the Culture books are the AIs, not the humans they are keeping around as pets.