4 ms·
This isn't a bubble. There is no stock of assets that are suddenly going to fall in market value. You can see education as an investment, but it's not a tradeab
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
This isn't a bubble. There is no stock of assets that are suddenly going to fall in market value. You can see education as an investment, but it's not a tradeable asset. If I buy an apartment, there's a market that (i) tells me the value of the apartment at any time, (ii) let's me (or the bank) liquidate the apartment and turn it into cash.
University degrees aren't like that. Someone holding a degree doesn't suffer additionally when people stop realising that this type of degree isn't worth the sticker price. He's not selling his degree to new students. Whatever his experience is in the job market is not affected by the price new students pay for their degrees.
- refurb 10y agoThere is no stock of assets that are suddenly going to fall in market value. Sure there is, the loans themselves. Right now a bunch of lenders have $1.3T worth of loans. If those loans don't get paid off, they are $1.3T poorer.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoWhat would cause those assets to suddenly fall in value?
- refurb 10y agoA huge uptick in default rates. The only reason why student loan paper has value is because there is an expectation that it will be paid off.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoOk, then what would cause a huge uptick in default rates?
- jcbrand 10y agoPeople's inability to service/pay their loans, due to not having enough income, due to the job market collapsing, due to a recession (which is already overdue).
- rahimnathwani 10y agoWhat you've described here is the value of an asset (student loan paper) declining due to a change in the underlying cash flows generated by that asset. This is how asset prices are supposed to work. It's not the busting of a bubble.
- stale2002 10y agoOK, how about this. Imagine that employers stop caring about degrees, and evaluate potential hires based on other qualities. This is already happening in tech. If employers no longer cared about degrees, then workers who don't have them would now suddenly be on equal footing. The non degree holders would get much higher paying jobs, and conversely the degree holders would get worse jobs. This causes the "value of education" bubble to pop.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoThen we're back to my earlier point. There is no 'value of education' bubble analogous to a housing bubble. An individual's degree isn't tradable in the same way as a house is, so the value of that individual's degree isn't being bid up by people competing to buy it. So what would it mean for the bubble to burst? If you're talking about a mechanism by which the price of newly-issued degrees were to fall (i.e. college tuition sticker prices fall by 50% within a year or two) then, even if it were to happen, that's just a fall in the price of a consumer good. If the price of laptop computers falls because people realise they can do their work with tablets and chromebooks, we don't think of that as a laptop bubble. Not a perfect analogy but I hope you get my general point: if you're calling something a bubble, then you've got to be able to point to the stock of existing assets whose price is out of whack with fundamental value (e.g. based on future cash flows) due to irrational investors bidding up the price. I'm not claiming tuition fees are in line with fundamental value to the recipient. If they're not, then it's just people buying stuff they shouldn't. If they are in line, but it's for signalling reasons rather than the education received, then there's economic inefficiency due to market failure, but it' seems still not a bubble.