4 ms·
There is a benefit to countries and to the world when the people pool their money for something big. Yes there is, at least sometimes. But, the choice to do th
by mindcrime 10y ago
There is a benefit to countries and to the world when the people pool their money for something big.
Yes there is, at least sometimes. But, the choice to do that should be voluntary, otherwise it's an immoral and unjust situation. And given that the State is - at it's core - a mechanism rooted in violence, this kind of thing is not an appropriate role for government.
- simonh 10y agoIt's immoral and unjust that someone should grow up and live within the protective environment of a society, enjoying use of it's shared services and resources, while refusing to contribute towards the support of the services which make that environment possible. If you don't think it's a good deal, leave.
- malloryerik 10y agoWhile I'm sympathetic to most of your argument, it does beg the question, move where?
- sangnoir 10y agoSomalia[1] looks like a good place to go if I didn't want to be burdened by government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somalia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somalia
- simonh 10y agoPerhaps my final statement was a bit glib, but personally I feel we are born into this world with a whole ton of obligations. We are nurtured, educated, protected. In many parts of the world, we are assigned inalienable rights just through the fact of being human beings. Whatever we do is founded on the hard work and achievements of others, but in most countries in the modern era very few claims are made on us in return. In past ages we were expected, or even required to die or at least kill and risk death in defense of our society. Nowadays you can be brought up, educated to a decent standard, benefit from all of society's resources and benefits to the age of adulthood and then swan off to some other part of the world for the rest of our lives, obligation free. That's a pretty amazing deal, by historical or really any standards.
- mindcrime 10y agobut personally I feel we are born into this world with a whole ton of obligations. How in the world can one be born with obligations? Especially considering that you didn't even ask to be born to begin with? When you're born you certainly haven't had a chance to voluntarily enter into any contracts, or accept any burdens. What you're talking about sounds like slavery to me.
- simonh 10y agoLaws and their enforcement are inherently coercive, but slavery is a specific thing distinguished by the fact that it is imposed through an asymmetric application of the law. Slaves and the owners are unreasonably assigned different rights under the law. That's the primary distinction that makes it immoral. Do you feel unfairly and unreasonably constrained by the laws which oblige you to refrain from wantonly murdering and abusing those around you at will? Do you feel enslaved by those laws, or merely coerced?
- mindcrime 10y agoLaws and their enforcement are inherently coercive Not if the law is no more than the collective extension to our individual, innate right to self-defense.[1] [1]: http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html http://bastiat.org/en/the_law.html
- malloryerik 10y agoSorry to reply so late. But like you, it seems, I'm also interested in the tension between social welfare (education, medicine) and national borders. I'm saying this as someone who wants 10 million new immigrants to the USA per year.
- mindcrime 10y agoIt's immoral and unjust that someone should grow up and live within the protective environment of a society, enjoying use of it's shared services and resources, while refusing to contribute towards the support of the services which make that environment possible. Not when you were never asked if you wanted any of that stuff, and aren't given a choice as to whether or not to participate. If you don't think it's a good deal, leave. What, because a bunch of dead people drew some lines on a map and said "this is Whateveristan, and anybody inside these lines is bound to our decisions for all time"? Screw that. I'm with Thomas Paine who argued that there is no mechanism by which the dead can bind the living.
- hackuser 10y ago> Not when you were never asked if you wanted any of that stuff You are indeed asked. You may be outvoted, but that's only fair. Laws are not immortal; they can be changed any time.
- mindcrime 10y agoYou may be outvoted, but that's only fair. No, it isn't "fair". Voting is a sham. "Democracy" is just a euphemism for "mob rule" and "might makes right". As the old saying goes "Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner. Liberty is a well armed sheep contesting the outcome." The reality is, if you vote, but are on the losing side, you're just a minority suffering the Tyranny of the Majority[1]. The representative system we use in the US purports to try and avoid that, but it really doesn't. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority and aren't given a choice as to whether or not to participate. Interesting that you elided this bit in your response. Because this matters... no one is really given a choice as to whether or not to participate in "the system". If you work, the government presumes the authority to steal a portion of your income, no matter what decisions you make. And if you try too hard to not participate, men with guns will come and arrest or kill you. And, no, before you say it, "leave" isn't a valid choice. See above about "Whateveristan". Given wherever one happened to be born, there's no reason one should have to leave in order to enjoy Liberty.