4 ms·
The Wall Street bailout was only...what, a trillion? If we bailed out real estate speculators, I wouldn't be surprised if something happened with college grads
by paulddraper 10y ago
The Wall Street bailout was only...what, a trillion?
If we bailed out real estate speculators, I wouldn't be surprised if something happened with college grads.
Unfortunately. I hate assuming responsibly for monetary decisions other than mine, but judging the trend, that's where we're headed.
- knz 10y agoIt'll never happen. They couldn't even agree to refinance Federal loans during the great recession - students were/are paying 6.8% when interest rates are at historic lows.
- melling 10y agoWasn't most of that money repaid with interest? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Progra...
- aikah 10y ago> Wasn't most of that money repaid with interest? But how much did it cost to borrow the bailout money at first place ? I'm pretty sure the US government didn't have trillions in cash at that time.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe cost was very low, treasury rates dipped below 1%. https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/Pages/TextView.aspx?data=yieldYear&year=2008 https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/i...
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBecause the Federal Reseve printed trillions of dollars out of thin air.
- TuringNYC 10y agoThe cost was not low -- rates dipped below 1% because the Fed printed money. But printing money is not free. The common person pays for it by earning less on savings and in the form of inflation, especially retirees who diligently saved through their lives hoping to earn and live off interest in their old age. Every person purchasing a house pays more for low rates because housing prices go up, so do all the associated fees which are on the Notional value (e.g., title insurance.) Pension funds "pay" for it because they cannot easily make money via bonds any longer.
- paulmd 10y agoIt all depends on whether you're a net debtor or a creditor, and at what rates. Printing money tends to increase interest rates, which benefits debtors (anyone who owes money on a credit card, student loan, or a mortgage - which is pretty much everyone). If inflation is happening, you get to pay back your today-money-debts in weaker-future-money which means you pay less in real terms. Regardless, not all that much of the quantitative easing money actually entered the economy because it was largely hoarded by banks to shore up their balance sheets post-collapse.
- TuringNYC 10y ago"not all that much of the quantitative easing money actually entered the economy" Consider housing prices being at enormous highs throughout the country -- that is directly related to low interest rates. It affects all people who dont own a home. It benefits land and home owners. It is a lop-sided benefit bourne by the young and poor.
- maxerickson 10y agoTreasury rates are set by a market auction, the Fed can't drive them down just by printing money. If investors anticipate inflation, they will factor it into their bids. I guess whether you think the negative effect of the bailout on savings and such were worth it depends on whether you think the entire insurance market almost collapsed.
- TuringNYC 10y agoTARP is just one of many bailout facilities. There are others by the Fed, for example Quantitative Easing. Another is allowing banks to essentially print money by allowing them to borrow from the discount window and immediately then park the cash into higher-yielding assets.
- 75j 10y agoSo, I am not at all an expert in finance, but there are claims (from Jill Stein for example) that the real cost of the bailout was much, much higher. Here's a Mother Jones article that takes this position: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/12/behind-real-size-bailout http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/12/behind-real-size... Can someone with more knowledge break down whether or not this is accurate?
- maxerickson 10y agoThe numbers used there are the size of the bailout, not the cost. If I loan you $1000 today and you pay me back $1001 tomorrow, my cost is not $1000. A whole lot of those programs look like that, short term loans or purchases of actual assets or whatnot.
- TuringNYC 10y ago@maxerickson has a valid response, but there is a larger story here. Consider hidden bailouts and also consider the unfairness of such hidden bailout. I would argue that the bailout was indeed much larger. For example, the Fed started buying distressed mortgage bonds via Quantitative Easing, QE2, and POMO. Should the Fed purchase an asset that is trading at 27 cents on the dollar for 60 cents? That seems unfair...it was a hidden bailout. Imagine you buy a house for $500,000, the value goes down to $150,000. The government, instead of paying $155,000 pays you $450,000. That sounds like an "open market transaction" but it is a gift, a bailout just by another name. Unfortunately they didn't do that with homes, they did it with mortgage bonds and CDOs, which meant that most of the gifts went to a small sector of society in lower Manhattan and around Greenwich Connecticut.
- Lazare 10y agoThose are very old numbers trying to estimate the total size of the bailout, and the total potential downside. They aren't trying to estimate the actual net cost, nor are they trying to compare it to the total potential downside of the alternatives. So it's technically right, in a sense (or it was when it was written last decade), but it isn't trying to answer the question you're asking, it's horribly outdated, and it's larded with weasel words. "[T]hese guarantees could have potentially cost the federal government more than $3 trillion..." but actually didn't. "[T]he government's potential exposure from the PPIF is between $500 million and $1 trillion..." but they ended up turning a profit on it. "As of December 21, 2009, $117.5 billion of that has been repaid..." and subsequently the rest of it was too. "The Treasury has bought $200 million in preferred stock from Fannie Mae" and then ended up quasi-nationalizing it and has since been making a hefty profit on it. And so on, and so forth. What the report shows is that the financial crisis had enormous potential price tags attached to it, but the bills never ended up coming due. Whether that was luck or skill remains to be shown. :) > the real cost of the bailout was much, much higher No. You can argue about the true underlying risks, and the proper risk adjusted interest rate to nominally charge when lending government funds to a quasi-government entity with an effective government guarantee, and the option value of the bailout, and you can argue that it, on balance, cost a few billion, or quite a few billion, or maybe even turned a profit. I think the CBO scored it at $60 billion a while back; I'd lean towards the "cost a couple hundred billion" answer, but it's ultimately too complicated a question to ever really have an answer. Especially if you try and estimate the cost compared to some other policy. :)