3 ms·
Purely focussing on race and gender does seem like a horrible idea. Do you think race and gender should have any role at all in hiring decisions? There's a diff
by grzm 10y ago
Purely focussing on race and gender does seem like a horrible idea. Do you think race and gender should have any role at all in hiring decisions? There's a difference between "focussing" and taking it into account. Can race and gender be proxies for adding additional perspective? First example that comes to mind is, say, if you're looking to expand your market into new demographics.
Edited to add: If you choose to down vote, I'd appreciate a comment as to why in the interest of communication. Given the amount of discussion that still goes on around these topics, it's far from a settled issue. Understanding how others think about them is important to figuring out some kind of agreement or acceptable solution. If the solution is obvious to you, please share, as it's not obvious to me.
- kevingadd 10y agoYeah, studies have in fact shown that this is the case - in certain problem spaces if your team isn't diverse you can fail to find the correct solution to the problem because you have too few different perspectives on it. i.e. https://hbr.org/2013/12/how-diversity-can-drive-innovation https://hbr.org/2013/12/how-diversity-can-drive-innovation On the other hand there have definitely been studies showing negative outcomes from diversity programs, so there's an interesting conflict there.
- grzm 10y agoThanks for the link. It's also great to see a more nuanced take on a lot of this. Some people do see it in black and white. Sometimes I wish I did, as it would make some things easier. Unfortunately (?), I'm not at that point of certainty yet.
- AlexB138 10y ago> Do you think race and gender should have any role at all in hiring decisions? In general, no, unless there is some specific reason why a role needs to consider those qualities, which you alluded to. > Can race and gender be proxies for adding additional perspective? I should think so, but at the same time I find it a bit insulting to suggest that they're primary indicators for perspective. For example, a wealthy British black man and a wealthy American white woman have significantly more in common than a poor black man and the same wealthy black man. Using race as primary indicators is actually a bit racist.
- grzm 10y agoThanks for the civil and thoughtful reply. These types of topics can so easily escalate out of control! Agreed all around. Add to that is how to properly measure how a given employee will work out with for a company. Determining the best measures of ability and that oft-discussed ever-elusive "fit" are not easy tasks for some jobs, and something companies are continually trying to improve. Hiring for diversity is itself a proxy of sorts, isn't it? I doubt Microsoft is hiring for diversity for diversity's sake. There are inequalities in society as a whole that appear to break to some extent along racial and gender lines. You bring two others with respect to nationality and income or economic class. (I mention all of these without making a moral judgement.) There's a lot of different ideas as to why these inequalities exist. I'm speculating, but one reason Microsoft may be hiring for diversity is that they see that the demographic make up of their employee base is significantly different from the make up of society as a whole. Is there a merit/ability reason why this should be? If there isn't, should the company take steps to change the disparity? This gets into questions of the role of the company in society. Does/can/should a company have responsibilities beyond short term profit? Are people good at making decisions that affect the long-term? Do the effects of pure capitalism affect societal change at a rate that maximizes societal good (for some measure) on scales comparable to the average human life? Should we be concerned about these things? Throw up our hands? Try to figure out solutions outside pure meritocracy? I'm just riffing now in a pretty non-structured way. I'd be happy for others to push against them and see how quickly they fall over. I also recognize that not everybody is interested in these questions. The HN forums are a good place to get exposed to other ideas from different perspectives. I'm pretty sure we're not going to figure all of this out in this thread, but it is good stuff to think about overall.