4 ms·
Why is the focus on the unethical work of programmers? How about addressing the root cause: People are doing unethical thing as part of their job. Either becau
by mrweasel 10y ago
Why is the focus on the unethical work of programmers?
How about addressing the root cause: People are doing unethical thing as part of their job. Either because they either don't understand the issue or due to their financial situation.
Apparently we have all accepted that business people in general are going to be unethical to the point where there is no fighting it or expectation that it's fixable. How about we address the real issue: The unethical business practises of some company and the people who run them.
But no, let us once again leave it to the developers to fix the problems.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoEthics is unfortunately a privilege of workers who can afford it. Programmers are in demand, so they can stand up to their managers and refuse to do something they deem unethical. Most of the world doesn't have that choice however. The grocery shop clerk can't refuse to wash meat with detergent because they can't afford to lose the job. The customer support person on the phone can't refuse to blatantly lie to customers because they can't afford to lose the job. The more friends I have in "normal" jobs, the more I see that it's not an exception - very many, if not most, small businesses are run by liars and frauds, and are forcing their workers to do unethical things.
- grzm 10y agoI'm with you on the tension between employment and professional ethics. The small business characterization... given the number of small businesses, "many" can be true but the implication that it's a large is off. You do make the qualification "if not most". Is your impression that it's close to 50%? Larger than in larger businesses? In some ways I'd think large business might have an easier time with forcing workers to behave in some way unethically. Losing a single worker for refusing to do something unethical doesn't have as much impact on their business as a whole. I wouldn't go too far with this argument without doing some research, thought. Just a thought experiment. I'm not denying the experience of your friends. I just am unsure of how far this goes towards advancing an argument that an interestingly large number of "small businesses are run by liars and frauds", which I'm admittedly not sure you're making. Which is why I'm asking :)
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI don't know how the situation looks like in larger businesses. As for small businesses, I base my qualification of "very many if not most" based on the sample I have from personal experience - the companies I've worked with, and companies people I know worked in who trust me enough tell me the stories of what things look internally. Still, I'm just saying small business are - in my experience - bad; I'm not saying they're worse than big businesses :). Maybe saying that many small business are run "by liars and frauds" is too much; I admit I get emotional over that sometimes. After all, I don't know those managers/bosses well enough to judge the state of their consciousness. But what I observe is that, nevertheless, the workers are often directly asked to do unethical things that go against the interest of customers. A charitable way of viewing that is that the bosses are forced to cut corners to deal with the pressure[0] or to stay competitive, or that eventually some unethical conduct becomes a standard practice in the industry (I believe that for example washing meat with detergent is such a thing). As for the impact of losing a single worker - when we're talking about regular people doing regular jobs, losing an employee often doesn't have much of an impact on the company, but it has a lot of impact on the employee itself. For people outside of very specialized fields, finding a new job is a nontrivial task. Finding a new job that pays comparably to the one you just left making a stand is doubly nontrivial. Quadruply, if you live in a smaller town. I know first-hand of a particularly successful online book seller who uses this fact to overwork and underpay his staff while forcing them to lie to customers - he knows that none of his employees can afford losing this job. I guess what I'm trying to say is that most of the working class is pretty screwed when it comes to disobeying unethical commands - people in IT often forget that our industry is in a (temporary) golden age, and we can afford to make a stand. -- [0] - I run a non-profit and I know how much pressure can fall on you when things get messy while various deadlines for deals or paperwork approach. I can only imagine a competitive business is even more difficult to manage.
- grzm 10y agoThanks for the thoughtful response. "As for the impact of losing a single worker - when we're talking about regular people doing regular jobs, losing an employee often doesn't have much of an impact on the company, but it has a lot of impact on the employee itself." Completely agree. I meant from the perspective of the company. For the employee depending on an income is a different matter all together.