4 ms·
> Carbon credits are at least in principle meant to accomplish a reasonable goal. The argument is not whether the goal is reasonable, but whether are money is
by smsm42 10y ago
> Carbon credits are at least in principle meant to accomplish a reasonable goal.
The argument is not whether the goal is reasonable, but whether are money is play. With carbon credits, there certainly are, and a lot of it.
> As for relying on taxpayer-financed investments, that's exactly what tax money is meant to be used for.
Nope, it's exactly what tax money are not meant to be used for. Tax money should be used to protect the citizens, to provide for law enforcement, defense, common infrastructure, taking care of the poor and ill. High-risk venture investment is not what it should be used for. That's what private VCs are for. And if VCs wouldn't want to touch it with ten-foot pole, maybe there's a reason for that.
> Tesla is the golden standard of using government loans efficiently, for the betterment of society, and even paying them back in full ahead of schedule!
Exactly because they profited so much out of "green credits" mandate, effectively taxing owners of all other cars to their advantage. Getting hundreds of millions by government mandate is a pretty sweet deal, especially if their direct competitors have to pay it.
- guelo 10y agoThis whole line of reasoning is far fetched. "The world is ending, give us money", you're suggesting that climate change is a hoax perpetrated by green credit market participants? It's just twisting the obvious, that climate change comes from concerned scientists, to try to add some evil ulterior motive. All to shove reality into your preferred worldview that liberal masterminds are trying to ruin the world, or something.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> High-risk venture investment is not what it should be used for. That's what private VCs are for. And if VCs wouldn't want to touch it with ten-foot pole, maybe there's a reason for that. VCs are glorified gamblers. I think you need to take a good look at how advanced science and technology has been done since there is science and technology; you'll quickly realize it always has direct or indirect government backing - because market itself doesn't exactly favour anything more long-term than your next quarterly report. > effectively taxing owners of all other cars to their advantage If that was true, I'd actually be pretty happy about it - about time someone made polluters pay for the externalities. But this isn't true, in fact it's government who decides that certain areas of technology (like green energy, green transportation) should be developed further, and offers loans and grants as a way of incentivizing companies to work in those areas.
- smsm42 10y ago> VCs are glorified gamblers So instead of gambling with the money from affluent people, given voluntarily, we should gamble with tax money, taken coercively from much poorer people, competing with budgets for welfare, hospitals, schools, etc. - and gamble with that. Brilliant. > because market itself doesn't exactly favour anything more long-term than your next quarterly report. It's bullcrap, easily disproven by existance of multiple companies with hundred-year histories. And existance of whole divisions in those companies doing long-term projects. > If that was true, What you mean "if"? That's a fact. Easily verifyable. Tesla sells credits to other auto-makers. It has been reported many times and widely known.