7 ms·
Microsoft to Tie Executive Bonuses to Company Diversity Goals
- jbuzbee 10y agoOf course there's a danger to the company in this. "My bonus is tied to my diversity goals. I've tried hard, but I'm way behind and my reporting period is almost up! Quick, bypass the standard screening and qualification checks, and hire a bunch of people in underrepresented groups"
- samstokes 10y agoThat's true, but any incentive structure at all has similar hazards. (Ever seen the software quality bar lowered in order to meet a deadline?) So long as the company does have standards, and processes it trusts to enforce those standards, it's possible to guard against that failure mode, just as you'd guard against any other employee misbehaviour. If you do have employees (or execs) bypassing the process or lowering their standards in order to meet short term goals, that in itself is a cultural problem the company would want to address. Edit: it's worth noting that every manager who has more planned work than they can execute with their current head count already has a short-term incentive to lower their hiring bar and get someone in the door quickly. Managers get measured on executing to plan, so that's probably a stronger incentive than any bonus structure. So my point isn't that lowering the bar to game the system will never happen, but that it's a failure mode that already occurs and that the system should already have defences against.
- CyanLite2 10y agoTrue, then you get unqualified people who can't meet your other goals. The point of this bonus is to encourage executives to recruit and hire from non-traditional sources, such as HBCUs. And this is Microsoft we're talking about here. If they come across two very qualified candidates, they will hire them both. Not one over the other.
- fbreduc 10y agolol this is not how you become diverse...
- taurath 10y agoBig chance to poison the well - did you not get the promotion or job because you're not a diversity hire, or was it because the other candidate was better? I've seen Intel do this and animosity increased by a huge amount.
- tuna-piano 10y agoAnd the reverse - did that person get the job because he/she was the most qualified, or because he/she was in a certain class of people? (And would also make the person who got that job question themself)
- kevingadd 10y agoThis is literally just a sorting problem. Diversity quotas imply using a candidate's minority status as part of the sorting key, not the only sorting key. You're still picking a highly qualified candidate, not some random dude off the street. Think about it for five seconds, please :(
- scentedmeat 10y agoAs soon as you tie a persons bonus money to it, it isn't. You are no longer looking at the highest quality candidates, but the ones that match the minimal qualities. And since race/gender has no impact on performance (my asumption), this is a bad key. But, as someone that can check the minority checkbox, woo!
- kevingadd 10y agoBonuses at a company like Microsoft are typically based on an employee's performance - how well they met their stated goals, etc. Obviously, if a company goal is to have a diverse workforce, whether or not that happens is going to influence the bonuses of the people responsible for it. If this is an unacceptable outcome, you're suggesting that diversity can't be a company goal, period. Like I've said before, it's a sorting problem - if implementing an algorithm correctly requires sorting some values to the top and some to the middle, you shouldn't get full credit if your implementation doesn't do that. We're not talking about soviet russia production quotas being exploited here, just about adjusting the way candidates are found and ranked.
- AlexB138 10y agoFocusing your company on hiring people based on their race and gender, rather than their ability, seems like a horrible idea. Not to mention a great way to open yourself to law suits and massive animosity among your employees.
- tenpies 10y agoNot to mention the effect on the person being hired: was I hired because I was the best candidate or because some manager wanted their bonus and had to fill a quota?
- AlexB138 10y agoIndeed. Or the person who wasn't hired. "Was I rejected because I'm white?". Lawsuits aside, that's a great way to build quite a bit of bitterness toward your company.
- kevingadd 10y agoWhy "rather than their ability"? Are you suggesting that hiring diverse candidates makes it impossible to hire skilled workers? Why would that be so?
- AlexB138 10y ago> Why "rather than their ability"? Because that is literally what the article is about. Unless you're under the impression that they previously hired candidates based on something other than ability, I don't see how else you could read this. Companies typically try to hire the most skilled person they can afford for a position. MS is now incentivizing leaders to favor women and certain racial groups because their previous hiring methods didn't result in the desired number of them being hired. > Are you suggesting that hiring diverse candidates makes it impossible to hire skilled workers? Why would that be so? You're intentionally twisting words.
- kevingadd 10y agoWhy does including race or gender as a factor in the evaluation of a candidate exclude ability? All hiring is based on a variety of factors, not just 'ability'. Availability for the position, quantity of experience, leadership skill, willingness to learn, familiarity with the problem space, quality of personal references, interpersonal skills... all that along with 'how good are you at writing code'. What is the huge negative impact of adding 'diversity' to that set of evaluation factors? Are you arguing that adding diversity would actually push the most qualified candidates to the bottom of the pile somehow? If all things are truly equal, adding diversity to the sort has no impact on the ability of qualified candidates to get hired.
- tuna-piano 10y agoIf there was an equally qualified man and woman- choosing the man over the woman because he is a man would be considered sexism. Choosing the woman over the man because she is a woman is considered progress. Asians are way over represented at Microsoft vs our country. We need to boost the white percentage as well. To me, race "diversity" is a foolish kind of diversity, because of how shallow it is. I don't think skin color makes you a different person, so I don't really think that more people of different colors in a company makes anything better. And I guess that makes me the bigoted one?
- kevingadd 10y agoIf it's shallow then wouldn't that imply it has no bearing on whether the person is qualified, and the pools of candidates of a certain race or gender are all equally qualified? If so, then why are diversity quotas a problem?
- nightski 10y agoJust because race or gender has no factor in whether a candidate is qualified does not mean that qualified candidates are equally represented among races and/or genders.
- kevingadd 10y agoYes, but the GP suggested that weighting based on race or gender is a problem, which implies that qualified candidates are unequally represented. Why would this be so? Is there evidence to support it? They also suggested that the white percentage needs to be 'boosted', because there are too many asians? Why would that be? What are the correct numbers?
- tuna-piano 10y agoI think it's pretty clear that qualified candidates are not equally represented. There are probably a lot of reasons for this, socioeconomic, educational, etc. But take a look at the SAT scores by race, or chosen academic majors in college. I'm on mobile with bad internet so I can't link to actual figures now. And my (sarcastic) logic for white percentage boosting is the same as Microsoft's black percentage boosting goal. Asians are significantly over represented at Microsoft (and most of the big tech cos) vs our US population. Microsoft wants to increase the black/Hispanic employee percentage to get more in line with the US distribution. They should also want to do the same with whites, which leaves the Asians set to be decreased significantly.
- rosege 10y agoI work for a fairly large company and they are doing this too (just for gender though). The way I see it you can either have diversity goals or you can be a meritocracy. To be honest Im not 100% sure which is better - I want to say meritocracy but then you have the Enron's that were meant to be the smartest guys in the room. But as a white male I see my career here quite limited due to me not being their preferred demographic.
- home_boi 10y agoIsn't it illegal to make pay based on a protected class?
- adrenalinelol 10y agoWon't this attach a stigma to those hired (who aren't white/asian male)? It's quite literally a quota.
- yuhong 10y agoI have dislike anti-discrimination laws for a while now. For example, one of the methods used to enforce them (particularly in things like hiring) is statistics, most of which assumes employees are interchangeable commodities. Not to mention the problems with "performance" reviews and "PIPs" too. They were designed back in the 1960s for things like manual labor jobs. I am willing to suggest a compromise to limit them to these kinds of jobs.
- codeonfire 10y agoSatya Nadella was born in India. I am 100% sure this policy is not going to apply to Microsoft's nine offices in India which are 100% one race. If you don't think this is about anything other than using race politics for corporate power, ask why diversity isn't important in Microsoft's other locations.
- mbrodersen 10y agoThat is already part of their job as managers. So what's next? Getting a bonus for showing up at work? Or maybe getting a bonus for playing less golf? Or perhaps a bonus for interrupt people who do real work with more useless meetings? Actually the last one isn't needed. They already do that. A lot.
- frugalmail 10y agoThe problem isn't at the executive level, it's at the schools. The expected levels should be set based on what was happening in the education system, not the population in general. I work at a place where this bullshit is happening and it's clear they're putting barely qualified people based on gender. In the end the company, all its employees, and the people it serves will be harmed. Instead they should work on getting more diversity in the STEM degrees and fix root cause. If they truely want it to be fair they should use "blind interviews" voice changers over the phone, written exams, etc... Not bullshit targets and incentives.