17 ms·
I think I (living in the UK, currently an EU country) understand the mentality behind the US healthcare system(s). I think it's along the lines of "Why should
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
I think I (living in the UK, currently an EU country) understand the mentality behind the US healthcare system(s).
I think it's along the lines of "Why should I pay for someone else's healthcare?".
I've heard similar arguments from British people (I'm rather more socialist in my outlook than average, for a UK resident, I fear) and I don't really have an answer to that. Why indeed?
I'm probably conditioned to answer this with a "duh, because they're your fellow citizens". But I guess that's not everyone's cup of tea.
- trprog 10y ago>"Why should I pay for someone else's healthcare?". >and I don't really have an answer to that. Why indeed? Because you don't know what is going to happen in the future. One day you may wind up broke and be diagnosed with a serious illness. And what about any children you may have. Wouldn't you like to know that they will receive care after you are dead no matter what is going on in their life?
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoActually, I know exactly what's going to happen (to me) in the future: I'll eventually grow old, get sick and die in pain. Or maybe I'll just get the "die in pain" part. That's how it goes, right? And in the past I was very young and couldn't yet fend for myself. I benefitted from being born in a developed nation and, like you say, if my parents had died while I was young, I'd have been taken care of (though in my country's case it would probably be my extended family that'd have looked after me, first, and the state would only intervene if I had noone to care for me). Like, I totally get what you're saying, but a significant number of people don't see it that way. Maybe they forget they were once too young, or that they will one day be too old. Maybe they just think they can do well enough for themselves that they'll just wing it. My point is that for many people contributing to things like public healthcare doesn't make sense. For instance- in the UK education is not free, and you will hear lots of people saying, indeed "why should I pay for someone else's education?". That's much more common than grumbling about having to pay for the NHS, but in the end it's just the same thing.
- AsyncAwait 10y agoI supported Jeremy Corbyn, so I am also way more socialist than you average Brit, but the answer to "Why should I pay for someone else's healthcare?" is actually quite simple - human decency. Do you really want people to actually DIE? I hope not and that you'll rather pay "for someone else's healthcare" than to see them suffer and if YOU are ever bad on your luck and need the help, I'll gladly pay for your healthcare if you need it, because I know that you paid into the system when you could and now we're just paying you back. I am already paying taxes for a lot of things that I may not want to anyway, like overbudget defense spending, over the top salaries for MPs, failed research, government websites that cost way more than they should and other initiatives that nobody asked for, financial support for hugely profitable multinationals etc. etc. - if I am paying for that, OF COURSE I'll pay into a system that will help a human being when they need it and be confident that I or my family members can expect the same, should it ever come to it. It always seemed to me that in the U.S. they're fed up with having to pay for an excessive budget, yet they always blame the wrong part of it for their high taxes - don't blame healthcare spending, blame the way it's implemented, blame the fact that over 50% of your tax dolars is spent on the military, blame the failed, overbudget F-35 project etc. etc. DON'T blame Flint residents who don't even have access to clean water - where's the logic in that?
- wnkrshm 10y agoI think it's interesting to ask why people separate themselves from other people, I.e. people who are sick and possibly dieing, who need help. Something I read on hn a while ago involved trying to place others who have had bad things happen to them in mental categories apart from oneself, to not have to deal with the possibility of bad things happening to yourself without any reason. E.g. a traffic accident, cancer etc. With traffic accidents, is very instructive to see that people will reflexively think that the persons involved did something wrong, this removes the need to accept that life isn't safe and that our behavior often has little influence at all on wether bad things happen to us. I think it's the same with healthcare. The defense mechanism is: they got sick so they must have lived unhealthily - granted, there are a lot of things your behavior can influence: cardiopulmonary disease, some forms of cancer but not all of the tragedies of health that can befall you are in any way under ones control. By sticking together we can shoulder the burden of the few that didn't have any blame on their fate.
- vixen99 10y agoYour virtue signaling trivializes a vastly difficult issue. The immensely complex question remains, putting aside the problem of organizing a massive state system, of how you balance non-infinite resources with never-ending demand continually extended by medical advances of which people naturally enough wish to take advantage? Given no financial constraints, you don't have to be a socialist to assent to free health treatment for all comers.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoOK, but maybe don't assume any motives on my part? What I'm saying is that free healthcare and education (and other stuff like that) is a cost that civilised societies are prepared to pay to remain civilised, and it's weird that one such society seems to think very differently than the rest in that respect.