4 ms·
The French health system has its own problems. There is little evaluation of physicians so picking a hospital is very much a lottery, unless you know insiders
by cm2187 10y ago
The French health system has its own problems.
There is little evaluation of physicians so picking a hospital is very much a lottery, unless you know insiders who will tell you where to go and not to go.
The system runs a massive financial deficit.
It is run in an administrative way which creates odds behaviors. For instance department allowances based on % of occupation of hospital beds, which lead them to keep people overnight unnecessarily to preserve their budgets.
The system is very liberal in term of allowing you to see specialists. That's great in certain ways. The UK suffers from the opposite, where generalists' job seem to be to prevent people from seeing a specialist. But it is also a paradise for hypochondriac patients who will do dozens of useless exams subsidised by the tax payer.
Like many centralised etatic system (and particularly in France), friends in the right places, political affiliation and freemasonry are more important drivers for a career than medecine.
- simias 10y ago>There is little evaluation of physician so picking a hospital is very much a lottery, unless you know insiders who will tell you where to go and not to go. There are always variations, obviously but in general we have pretty good doctors AFAIK. If anything we don't have enough of them. I'm not sure how it relates to the article though, would a more liberal system improve the average quality of hospitals? Are US hospitals and doctors offer better service that the french ones? I'm really asking, I honestly don't know about that. >The system runs a massive financial deficit. It's still pretty massive but it's steadily shrinking these past few years, although parts of it might be caused by degrading the service slightly. The government plans for a balanced budget in 2017, although the opposition says it's not completely true: http://www.publicsenat.fr/lcp/politique/budget-securite-sociale-quasi-l-equilibre-arrive-senat-1562864 http://www.publicsenat.fr/lcp/politique/budget-securite-soci... This article gives a good overview of the situation as far as I can tell: http://www.lemonde.fr/financement-de-la-sante/article/2016/09/22/le-deficit-de-la-securite-sociale-reduit-a-son-plus-bas-niveau-depuis-2002_5002108_1655421.html http://www.lemonde.fr/financement-de-la-sante/article/2016/0... >Like many centralised etatic system (and particularly in France), friends in the right places, political affiliation and freemasonry are more important drivers for a career than medecine. What does that even mean? You went full tinfoil here. Whose career are you talking about anyway? Do you have any source?
- cm2187 10y ago> would a more liberal system improve the average quality of hospitals? Are US hospitals and doctors offer better service that the french ones? I am not sure it is a liberal vs non liberal. But doctors like any profession need to have a way to be evaluated. It is a fact that there are good, average and bad doctors (like any other profession). I understand that in the US, insurance companies play this role. They are maintaining detailed statistics of acceptable success rates and will apply pressure when they see physicians underperforming. On careers, I come from a family of doctors, so it's rather a long succession of first hand anecdotes than articles. Careers in public hospitals are very much driven by these things at a more senior level. I'm afraid no tinfoil there.
- ElKrist 10y ago> The system runs a massive financial deficit. French person here. Although the deficit of the healthcare system is often pointed at by the media, it is far from "massive". From [1] translated in English: "This budget is in deficit, (...) but this deficit is far less than the budget of the State. In 2011, the deficit of the Social Security represented 2,66% of its total budget (11,7 / 440,8 billions €) compared to 45% for the State budget (92 / 200 billions €)." I'm not saying that it's OK to have a deficit because the State deficit is bigger. But we should keep orders of magnitude in mind (the French budget would be in super-duper-massive deficit then?). Plus, as you can also see in [1], the deficit is shrinking since 2010 and getting close to zero. Yes, there are some optimizations possible in the French Social Security. I can't find the source anymore but the cost of running the public Social Security is lower, in percentage, than French private healthcares (if my memory is right its 8% vs 25% of the total budget of each organization) It is not hard to imagine that economies of scale play a major impact for this. [1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_de_la_S%C3%A9curit%C3%A9_sociale https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_de_la_S%C3%A9curit%C3%A...
- nraynaud 10y agoCareful, I think you lumped together the retirement and health branches, the health side has a lower deficit than the retirement side, that means that the health insurance has a lower deficit than what you stated.
- ElKrist 10y agoYes. And in my quote it is mentioned "Social Security" not "Healthcare branch of the Social Security". I took the Social Security as a whole because it's the total deficit of the Social Security that is often pointed at by the media. The "Healthcare branch" is not the one performing the best but the order of magnitudes are the same
- rtpg 10y agoYou know what also runs a deficit? Your gym membership. Going to the movies. Eating at restaurants. Sometimes things cost money. I imagine that keeping the country healthy is a plus. Not to say that making improvements isn't a bad idea, but a cost-centric view on things almost always ends in bad decision-making. Decisions based on revenue generation, instead of the "real" objective (keeping people healthy).
- cm2187 10y agoThe analogy is more like if I was borrowing money to pay for my gym membership or going to restaurants. And pass on my debt to my children.