6 ms·
Monty - In Defense of Ogg's Good Name
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 17y agoThought it was worth posting Monty's response, since the original anti-Ogg piece got a lot of discussion here a few months ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1164161 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1164161
- mmastrac 17y agoMonty's response is well-thought-out and well-supported. I was hoping to see the other side of the argument when this came out before, thanks.
- blasdel 17y agoHe does a very good job of bringing the nerd rage but unfortunately reality doesn't back him up — even his own implementation doesn't support his design choices very well and the ones in larger systems basically ignore them.
- oconnor0 17y agoHow so?
- blasdel 17y agoSeeking is frequently broken, especially wherever OGG support has been added to a larger system as a plugin like with Quicktime or ffdshow. FLAC is much worse on this. You can't actually use any non-Xiph codecs in an OGG container in the real world (except through the OGM hack that they repudiate), because they don't document any of it and nobody tests against it. You won't even get sensible errors. It's worse if they implement OGG support by just linking with liboggplay (the path of least resistance), so the container is implemented separately bundled with only its own codecs.
- viraptor 17y ago> Seeking is frequently broken, especially wherever OGG support has been added to a larger system as a plugin like with Quicktime or ffdshow. Surely, that's not really connected to the container design. If it's broken in the implementation, or in a plugin, that doesn't say much about the specification (unless you can prove everyone makes the same mistake because of something being underspecified).
- blasdel 17y agoIt is entirely the design. You might say that everyone else who tries out your artifact is a moron if they can't use it correctly. They would just say that you're a terrible designer with no concern for usability. Even the parts that are well-specified don't line up with how everyone else thinks about the problem space.
- viraptor 17y agoNot sure what does "how everyone else thinks about the problem space" have to do with a description of an algorithm / data structure. You either implement it correctly, or you don't. It doesn't matter what other people think about it. Many clever algorithms are good, exactly because they don't line up with how you normally think about the problem space. Why do you have to like the solution to implement it correctly?
- blasdel 17y agoBecause it's weird in ways that provide no real benefit except towards the gratification of the designer for having done something novel, and uses those novelties as an excuse to willfully leave out the data that's normally used for that. You do need to understand it to implement it correctly (or rather, as correctly as its design will allow you to), but there's a naive implementation right within grasp — so the people implementing it in a larger playback system will do that because they already have full support for everything else and aren't about to refactor everything for your fanciful shit. They just want to tick a checkbox on a feature list that their real users don't really care about.
- akkartik 17y agoSentence-by-sentence rebuttals are not very effective. And they're never the best you can do. Why are you wasting my time nitpicking on 'legend tells us'? It's silly to tell me I needn't bother with the original - and then take me in excruciating detail through it.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIt's not explicit in the original or explained well in this rebuttal but the "legend tells us" is basically a way for the original author to call the current author a liar without actually coming out and saying so. The line after that phrase is about Ogg being designed for Video codecs, something he clearly doesn't believe as later in the same document he suggests it was originally only intended for Vorbis audio. See footnote 26 and the section that references it in the Monty document for a counter to this popular misconception.
- akkartik 17y agoThanks for replying amidst the downvotes. You're right that those points are valid (as are the rest). Nits don't happen because some people like to dawdle. They happen because there's a lot of valid points to make. Which makes it particularly important to spend time finding the right ordering for them! (and to prune the ones that don't flow. Which would you prefer, that 10% read everything or that 75% read the 10 most important points you want to make?)