4 ms·
> This is actually incorrect. Pilot wave theory gives a deterministic explanation of phenomenon that the standard model treats as frequentist random events. Th
by amluto 10y ago
> This is actually incorrect. Pilot wave theory gives a deterministic explanation of phenomenon that the standard model treats as frequentist random events.
That's a remarkably incorrect statement. Let's see:
* The "standard model" is a quantum field theory and has essentially nothing to do with this discussion.
* Standard quantum mechanism says nothing about frequentist vs Bayesian interpretations of anything.
* Standard quantum mechanism is a deterministic theory, too. Take a look at the Schrödinger equation: it's deterministic.
Determinism is tricky. Suppose you have a particle doing its thing (going through double slits or whatever) and then you measure its position. In standard QM, you have two choices: you use the Born rule (or a fancier version -- I like the POVM formalism) and get a distribution of outcomes and a new post-measurement wavefunction, or you can include the measurement apparatus in your system and you end up with many worlds. In PWT, I think you have two similar choices. You can start with a distribution of your (hidden) initial condition and get an resulting distribution over the outcomes (which will be the same as the Born rule distribution if you calculate it correctly). If you do this, you still need to model decoherence, and I believe it looks at least as artificial as the standard QM case. Alternatively, you could presumably add degrees of freedom and more hidden variables to describe the measurement apparatus and you end up with an IMO extremely messy version of many worlds.
<aside>My personal view is that standard QM with many worlds is the best theory we have. If you start with the many worlds hypothesis and assume that it's totally impractical to devise an experiment that actually detects coherence between large-scale states, you can ignore this coherence, average it out, recover the Born rule, etc, as an approximation. IOW I think that decoherence is a limitation of our ability to build crazy experiments rather than a fundamental property of the universe.</aside>