7 ms·
> "The Alt Right believes we must secure the existence of white people and a future for white children." This is literally a white supremacist slogan: https://
by geofft 10y ago
> "The Alt Right believes we must secure the existence of white people and a future for white children."
This is literally a white supremacist slogan: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words
You are absolutely correct that that, in the abstract, those words could describe a perfectly reasonable and honest sentiment. But one wouldn't stumble on these exact fourteen words by mistake when trying to express that sentiment.
- tptacek 10y agoHold on a sec. I see where you're coming from here and it's good impulse to try to address the most charitable interpretation of an argument but you've gone past "charitable" into "gullible". Even had he not quoted the "fourteen words" slogan, the words themselves have a plain racist meaning. I feel compelled again to remind people: there is a reason we have "black history museums" and not "white history museums", and it's not because "all history is white history". It's because there is a coherent black culture, which was created by the forced relocation of African people to the United States, a process which stripped them not just of their original culture but of their very names. There is not in fact a coherent "white culture". There are Irish Americans and there are Italian Americans and Polish Americans and Anglo-Americans and German-Americans, all with their own museums and parades and cultures. There is not much overlap between Irish culture and Italian culture: they don't eat the same foods, speak the same languages, or play the same music. "White" means a lot of different things; it is a fucked up term in the same sense as "hacker" is. You have to evaluate it in context. So when I say "I hacked a bank", you know I did something that was very probably illegal, and when I say "I hacked together a PDF renderer" you know it wasn't. But the original meaning of the term "white" is racist. It's the term Anglo- and Germanic- Americans used to make common cause with the Irish and Italians Catholics they'd been hating at the turn of the century, when the end of Jim Crow escalated the threat they felt from black people. In fact, to this day, a significant faction of white nationalists that Italians aren't white. "We must secure a future for white children" is like "I hacked a bank". It's intrinsically racist.
- alphapapa 10y ago> "We must secure a future for white children" is like "I hacked a bank". It's intrinsically racist. I agree, and by the same token, any statement of the form, "We must secure a future for [skin color] children," is intrinsically racist as well. Some people think that, for certain values of skin color, certain kinds of racism are legitimate, but that's another matter--the fact remains that it's racist.
- tptacek 10y agoI feel like that's a statement reasonable people can disagree about, and so feel no real urge to litigate it.
- nyolfen 10y ago>There is not in fact a coherent "white culture". There are Irish Americans and there are Italian Americans and Polish Americans and Anglo-Americans and German-Americans, all with their own museums and parades and cultures. There is not much overlap between Irish culture and Italian culture: they don't eat the same foods, speak the same languages, or play the same music. this is a little like saying "there is no han chinese culture" because it was largely an fabricated as an ethnicity for the purpose of national unity by the ccp in the mid-century. maybe historically 'white culture' wasn't a singular thing, but we have many decades of culture behind us now of people identifying primarily as white. my ancestors were scottish but i don't identify that way -- i'm a white dude, that's my lived experience in the american context. a lot of things i do, my speech patterns, many of my hobbies, are, maybe not exclusive, but perhaps more common among other white people -- i'd speculatively call that white culture.
- tptacek 10y agoNo, you missed a bit in the middle there. I am not saying that constructed cultures aren't valid or real --- in fact, American black culture is one of the most prominent examples of a "synthesized" or "syncretic" culture! I'm saying that "white culture" isn't an example of one of those. We're linguistically disposed to assume it is, because if there's black culture, there must be white culture. But no, that's not how it works. Before there was "whiteness", there was racism (or ethnic discrimination or whatever you want to call it) against the Irish almost as virulent as racism against African Americans. The cutting edge of anti-Irish discrimination began blunting at the same period as "whiteness" started becoming a thing. It's hard to imagine --- as in, William of Ockham would have a thing or two to say about it --- that this simply because the English, Irish, and Italians suddenly and spontaneously synthesized a new culture.