4 ms·
Human HIV was discovered probably 5 decades if not more after it jumped. We know it didn't originate in humans, because we can estimate how old SIV and HIV are
by dogma1138 10y ago
Human HIV was discovered probably 5 decades if not more after it jumped.
We know it didn't originate in humans, because we can estimate how old SIV and HIV are based on their genetic material and other factors.
And we also know how old SIV at least is because we've tested primates on isolated islands and found that they are also infected, so if you find SIV infected primates on an island that was isolated from mainland Africa 30,000 years ago and it's preset within 100% of the primate population you know it's at least that old.
Another thing you can do is look at the DNA of the host and see if any viral DNA has been embedded within it, depending on where it is you can also estimate a timeline based on known processes and mutation rates.
There is very little to no doubt that HIV originated from SIV, the question is why now.
And yes we've discovered SIV later because AIDS happened then we found that it's a virus and not because they are gay, so people started looking at it's source and discovered SIV, FIV, EIAV and others.
You also need to understand that viruses are very hard to find, it's not like you just look at blood samples and see them, there are also not that many generic tests that can simply detect if a virus is present or not, it takes years to decades to isolate, classify and then develop methods to identify a virus and it's not like in the 1980's you could just order a full genome to be sequenced at will.
- nonbel 10y ago>"we've tested primates on isolated islands and found that they are also infected, so if you find SIV infected primates on an island that was isolated from mainland Africa 30,000 years ago and it's preset within 100% of the primate population you know it's at least that old." This sounds familiar, do you remember the ref? From what I remember the degree of "isolation" was questionable.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere were multiple studies some in islands, others in jungles. http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100521/full/news.2010.259.html http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100521/full/news.2010.259.ht... It's important to note that even if the location is not isolated it doesn't matter, and we do have proof that it is, what we look at is the molecular clock of the virus basically it's molecular structure based on the mutation rate of each virus. When you calculate the drift between different strains you can estimate the age, more isolated populations help since they tend to have less types of infections, while it's not common to find a primate with multiple strains on the mainland primates in the deep jungles of south america and on isolated islands off the coast of africa usually only have a single strain due to their relative isolation from other primate populations.
- nonbel 10y agoNot much more time for me to read into this today but I see that the molecular clock estimate is based on the "isolation" estimate. So these are not independent measures: "Crucially, he knew from geological records that the island separated from continental Africa around 12,000 years ago. Assuming that the strains had had at least 12,000 years to evolve apart, he determined that the mutation rate of SIV is much slower than originally thought." I find it difficult to believe that for 10k years a plausible scenario is that nothing happened like eg: A) someone was hunting monkeys from more populated areas and traveled to "isolated" islands/regions to get more. B) monkey on a branch gets thrown out to sea and floats to the island.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe molecular clock isn't dependant only on the isolation estimate, it comes from in vitro studies of a given virus and each of it's offshoots combined with our understanding of it's replication rates in a host. Again it doesn't need to have a perfect isolation, and the fact that the island is home to completely different strains which are unique to that island and can be genetically studied for drift and mutation rates does show that there was sufficient isolation to prevent transmission between the mainland and the islands. All isolation is relative, N. Korea is isolated it doesn't mean that nothing gets in or out, same thing here a monkey on a branch might be thrown out to the ocean but it doesn't mean it will become a transmission vector. Strain X exists only on Island Y while strain M N and O exist only on Mainland Z but not vice versa is enough proof for isolation for the studies to be valid.
- nonbel 10y ago>"The molecular clock isn't dependant only on the isolation estimate" Sure, not only, but according to your source it is dependent on the assumption the island was "isolated" for 10k years. We would have to look at the model to tell what effects relaxing this assumption and definition may have.
- dogma1138 10y ago
- nonbel 10y ago>"And yes we've discovered SIV later because AIDS happened then we found that it's a virus and not because they are gay, so people started looking at it's source and discovered SIV, FIV, EIAV and others." This doesn't really fit with the narrative in the paper I linked. They give this reason: "It was the impression of workers at the New England Regional Primate Research Center that there had been an increase in the number of deaths in its macaque colony."
- dogma1138 10y agoThe paper you linked is from 1983 before any genetic and even epidemiological studies were conducted, AIDS was clinically observed in the US in 1980 or 1981, it wasn't even called AIDS until 1982, and HIV was only identified in 1983. So what's exactly the surprise in the fact that an article from 35 years ago that was written at the dawn of HIV and AIDS research doesn't exactly fit with our modern understandings of the disease?
- nonbel 10y agoGiven that the research animals are much more heavily monitored it is surprising that the simian analogue only showed up in that environment after the human version became a big deal. As quoted earlier, they say the study was initiated because they noticed the animals dying more often than usual. You don't need genetic/epidemiological data to notice something like that. I do not understand what relevance that should have.
- dogma1138 10y agoIn 1983 AIDS wasn't still a big deal, no all primates have SIV strains, some primates never develop AIDS, we know some species for primates can effectively suppress SIV permanently, while some do develop immunodeficiency syndromes, heck it's even possible that the species or sub group of primates in the research was introduce to SIV from another species because of humans (mostly because the research does states that they have had 14 different species locked in their research center), it is however not possible for HIV to be the origin of the virus since we now have genetic models of the disease. When that research was conducted we didn't even knew what was causing AIDS as neither SIV nor HIV have been identified yet. Also research animals die all the time in great numbers, if it's a research laboratory then they'll probably die or be put to death way before they'll develop AIDS, if it's a conservation then they die to natural causes all the time, it's more likely that no one bothered to think why primates die to various infectious diseases more frequently than they should beforehand and then when AIDS research began to be published some one made a connection and looked into it. It's not like in 1983 or prior to that we commonly had 100's of primates locked in for a multi decade research in a state of the art habitat which was constantly monitored, they were either lab rats that lived a very short life or at best simply tracked for conservation purposes on a reservation. In fact after reading the research fully, it looks to me like they've unintentionally introduced SIV to Asian Macaca Cyclopis from an African species M. Mulatta (commonly known as a rhesus monkey) since SIV is not commonly present in Asia it's no real wonder why an Asian primate species would be considerably more affected as African species would be more or completely immune to AIDS while being SIV carriers. If anything this paper proves that African primates coexisted with SIV for a long enough time to develop an immunity or high tolerance to the virus while species from other regions that did not have SIV strains did not. And you can chuck this again to the fact that in 1983 no one knew that AIDS was caused by HIV, SIV, FIV and other similar viruses.