3 ms·
The reason zero-rating is harmful is that it gives the ISP cover for monopoly abuse. Suppose your ISP is owned by Facebook, so they zero-rate Facebook and char
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
The reason zero-rating is harmful is that it gives the ISP cover for monopoly abuse.
Suppose your ISP is owned by Facebook, so they zero-rate Facebook and charge high rates for all other data. Now those ISP customers are going to prefer Facebook over its competitors unless the competitors pay for zero-rating too. So Facebook gets to charge its competitors whatever they please for zero-rating, and they'll naturally want to charge a lot. They can even charge "themselves" the same amount because then it's just moving money from one pocket to another. So all they have to do is charge an amount that will put their competitors out of business and they'll have no more competitors.
> are we trying to protect consumers or content creators?
It's the same thing. Giving the ISP a monopoly on content harms consumers.
> If zero-rating is fine, would it be okay for AT&T to charge some data at higher rates, and then split the profit with the content creators? :) Eg, "AT&T now offers Netflix as a premium service; all AT&T customers now have a full access to the Netflix service! (Note, higher premium data usage rates apply when viewing premium Netflix content)" Would that be okay? Would it be harmful? To whom would it be harmful? :)
Let's consider why that might happen. If equal or less than the entire premium over the base data rate goes to Netflix then Netflix would just offer the service independent of AT&T, so it has to be that Netflix is receiving more than that. Let's consider why AT&T would do that. It's clearly not because AT&T has any interest in subsidizing Netflix.
But AT&T could set the base data rate higher than their own costs, so that any customer who uses any video service independent of AT&T is already paying AT&T a premium for that bandwidth. Then AT&T strikes deals with Netflix to charge an even slightly higher rate for Netflix bandwidth, and gives Netflix that increase plus a small percentage of the base rate. That forces Netflix to sign up for the deal with AT&T because it's the only way they can claw back even a part of the high base rate AT&T is charging to their customers.
And AT&T can decide who gets that deal, so AT&T gets to decide which video services are economically viable for AT&T ISP customers. Which harms competition and therefore consumers.
The reason this was traditionally less trouble with 1-800 numbers is that AT&T was never in competition with Zapatos to provide customer service to people who buy shoes, but they are in competition with Netflix et al to provide video service. And 1-800 numbers are available to everyone at the same published rates.