5 ms·
Do you think the "alt-right" is the only major problem? Try tweeting something against a Hillary or Obama policy during the election or challenge a 'liberal' pe
by briandear 10y ago
Do you think the "alt-right" is the only major problem? Try tweeting something against a Hillary or Obama policy during the election or challenge a 'liberal' person -- the responses can be no less harassing and vitriolic.
This idea that the 'right' is a problem is in itself part of the problem.
There is plenty of harassment from those that claim they are more tolerant than the rest of us.
I do agree with your echo chamber point though -- one needs only to spend a few minutes on Mother Jones's comment section to read all manner of hate against those who have different opinions from their own.
You are exactly correct -- the public sphere ought to welcome all viewpoints as sunlight is ultimately the best disinfectant.
One of the reasons Hillary lost the election is that her campaign seemed to be in a bubble -- holding valid concerns of many groups in contempt while surrounding itself with voices that spent more time self congratulating or feeling intellectually superior whilst many Americans (such as in the Rust Belt) found themselves marginalized. The Obama campaign by contrast actually reached out to the so-called deplorables.
- jessedhillon 10y agoYes, a left wing bubble exists. However, without any qualifications of scope and scale, it sounds like you're suggesting that the vitriol approaches a comparable level to that of the alt-right. That's just a plainly false equivalency.
- tnone 10y agoYou say that, when the alt right is an artificial internet meme, while leftist dogma rules over universities and continues to go after people's jobs for wrongthink. Vitriol is clearly a bad measure when subjective interpretation rules are becoming official policy. Even Twitter now has special treatment for particular groups enshrined in its policy. You can be as vitriolic as you want, as long as it's against the "correct" group.
- someguydave 10y agoHear hear. Equality before the law is the true egalitarian ideal.
- hga 10y agoOne problem is that, to the extent the inchoate Alt Right has decided upon this (and I think it has), we explicitly reject egalitarianism AKA equalitarianism (they're cognate, right?). In Vox Day's first cut 16 point formulation, Point 7 is: The Alt Right is anti-equalitarian. It rejects the idea of equality for the same reason it rejects the ideas of unicorns and leprechauns, noting that human equality does not exist in any observable scientific, legal, material, intellectual, sexual, or spiritual form. From http://voxday.blogspot.com/2016/08/what-alt-right-is.html http://voxday.blogspot.com/2016/08/what-alt-right-is.html
- nickpsecurity 10y agoWell, I appreciate you sharing a clear statement on what it is. I haven't seen one before this. Although plenty is debatable here, No 14 and 15 look immediately contradictory as one leads to laws with a preference for whites or discrimination against blacks while other implies a pure meritocracy. I don't have to guess about this, though, given I live in the South whose history shows how it plays out. ;) Good that there's a number of items on the list I agree with. Some common ground.
- hga 10y agoNote that #14 is simply a version of this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words Besides being cute in making it #14, I suspect he felt it needs to be explicitly stated since its inverse is an explicit goal of our enemies. Although Vox Day himself isn't "white", and I'll note as a matter of taxonomy divides the Alt Right into the Alt West and Alt White, the latter a very small subset. The general answer to the apparent contradiction is generally found in the other points and implied in #15: complete separation, e.g. #11 "The Alt Right understands that diversity + proximity = war." No proximity, no war of that sort e.g. embedded in those laws you refer to, and therefore no problems with #14 of those sorts. Also, I should make clear this is Vox Day's first cut of a statement of what the Alt Right is, but he thinks it's solid enough to get it translated into quite a few languages now. But the Alt Right is still seriously inchoate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- agotasaidwhat 10y agoI don't see how extreme left with it's blatant racism and sexism is that much better than alt-right? #killallmen #killallwhites
- douche 10y agoYou really shouldn't be getting downvoted for a simple statement of fact like this. The only real difference between extremists on the left and extremists on the right is that the leftists wrap themselves in the armor of holier-than-thou self-righteousness.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThe fact that this entire sub-thread about censorship or attacks by leftists is greyed out supports the claim. They pretend to be righteous folks that have civilized discussions, weigh the evidence, support equality, etc. Then, they're trying to disappear the comments, jobs, or whatever of those that voice dissenting opinions. They're no different except the what and how of their preferences and attacks.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoI think the alt-right is a major problem because alt-right ideas are supported by a network of sites that create and propagate outright lies. The lies are then propagated further through Twitter accounts and FB groups to create a movement that literally wouldn't exist without its popular untruths. The UK's Brexit vote was swung by the fact that some of our newspapers have lied about the EU for decades. The list of lies is breathtaking. They literally just make shit up to further their cause. The Left doesn't lie and manipulate on an industrial scale like this. The Left sometimes gets facts wrong, but there is no industrial fake-news network supporting left-leaning ideas. (And no - the mainstream media are not that network. The MSM are primarily pro-corporate and pro-establishment, not left-leaning.) Once you start lying and manipulating professionally and commercially, notions of free speech no longer apply. Industrial dishonesty is toxic to democracy. It's also an easy and cheap tool of influence for hostile nation states who want to undermine shared values.
- aaron-lebo 10y ago> Industrial dishonesty is toxic to democracy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Drn0Lg5gIRc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Drn0Lg5gIRc That's one of numerous examples of selective editing by CNN. > The Left doesn't lie and manipulate on an industrial scale like this. The Left sometimes gets facts wrong, but there is no industrial fake-news network supporting left-leaning ideas. (And no - the mainstream media are not that network. The MSM are primarily pro-corporate and pro-establishment, not left-leaning.) Even if that is true now (and it's a very dubious claim), you don't have to go back very far in history to see the left bending over backwards to justify the socialist utopia Stalin was building in the USSR. If you believe in truth, if you believe in honesty, stop making excuses when the liars are on your side. Stop using the no true Scotsman fallacy to excuse liars. Dishonesty is used by human beings of all classes and political stripes. It always has and it always will be.
- grzm 10y agoI agree that the news situation is terrible. I don't know if it's useful to make it a partisan issue. From what I've seen on HN, people of all political persuasions aren't happy about it. Let's call it out when we see it, leaving partisanship out if it as much as we can. This could be an issue that unites us, rather than splits us. Something that makes this increasingly difficult is that we're having difficulty agreeing on shared truth. I think it's right to increase scrutiny on sources that are proving themselves untrustworthy, but we need to start trusting (and verifying) somewhere.