58 ms·
Surveillance train has left the station, can't be stopped any more. It's just too cheap to use cameras, wireless and large HDDs. AI can sift through videos effi
by visarga 10y ago
Surveillance train has left the station, can't be stopped any more. It's just too cheap to use cameras, wireless and large HDDs. AI can sift through videos efficiently.
So, the only way back to balance is to do government surveillance, and more generally, to have a multi-way surveillance society in which a single actor doesn't have monopoly. We have to go all the way now, short of destroying all surveillance equipment everywhere and making sure nobody recreates it, which, given incentives, it's impossible to enforce.
The main problem now is balance of power, not if we like surveillance or not. This new power must not be put only in the hands of an elite. By the same doctrine of "separation of powers", we should not concentrate all surveillance power in a single point, because it lacks checks and balances.
- Symbiote 10y agoThis act is more about telecommunications data than CCTV cameras. Something that really bothered me is Shami Chakrabarti, previously head of Liberty and a strong supporter of human rights, now shadow Attorney General, abstained from voting.
- throwaway1974 10y ago"They" probably have dirt on him The thing about living in a surveillance society is how good people can be silenced via blackmail.
- chriswarbo 10y ago> "They" probably have dirt on him Her https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shami_Chakrabarti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shami_Chakrabarti
- vonmoltke 10y agoI don't really buy this paranoid viewpoint. If "they" were trying to use information from surveillance to blackmail people into doing what "they" wanted, considering the scale of these programs I find it hard to believe that they would not have tripped over someone who is either functionally unblackmailable or who is willing to take the hit for the greater good. Furthermore, at some point it becomes very difficult to not trace leaks of such information back to government surveillance programs and entities, so every execution of a blackmail threat poses a serious risk to the blackmailers It works against key people when used occasionally, but it can't be used at scale without someone figuring out what is going on.
- superflyguy 10y agoProbably she wants Labour to get elected, and the public are generally behind this sort of intrusion, and political parties are generally not about principles any more, but instead just trying to get elected.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoI agree to a point, that it's an issue of balance of power, but I think the arms race solution could cause a lot more damage to our society than the current arrangements. Surveillance of government could open the floodgates to much broader interpersonal surveillance. For example, imagine a company that offered 'surveillance as a service'. We've been here before with private investigators, but that tended to be a niche market, just imagine if it was mainstream. The mechanisms we'd need to enable ad-hoc surveillance of government officials could also enable the general public to spy on each other to a much greater extent. At what point does that start to impact on our personal relationships and our business relationships? I'd suggest it could cause a much less forgiving society to emerge.
- visarga 10y agoOur current arrangements fill the data coffers of FaceBook, Google, Apple and mobile operators with troves of personal data. It's already a multi-way surveillance society. We need to expand this even more, to surveil the surveillers or have access to their data.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoPerhaps you've misunderstood what I said. I'm suggesting that promoting much more widespread surveillance will seep into civic life, e.g. people spying on employees/employers, neighbours, acquaintances, etc... and at a much greater level than sites like Facebook allow. In other words, I'm suggesting an arms race in the field of surveillance available to the general public is likely to have unwelcome effects on society at large.