5 ms·
> This also makes Trumps promise to bring manufacturing back to the US quite interesting.... The voting in of Trump shows how conservative and not forward-look
by grecy 10y ago
> This also makes Trumps promise to bring manufacturing back to the US quite interesting....
The voting in of Trump shows how conservative and not forward-looking the US is. Vast swaths of the South are hell-bent on keeping things the way they are (for better or worse).
The US has also been one of the "lower" OECD countries for a decade or two in a lot of measures [1].
I won't be surprised if it's one of the last OECD countries to have a strong manufacturing sector, requiring humans to do a lot of work that in other countries has been replaced. Other countries will figure out how to rethink economies, happiness, purpose, etc, and the US will just keep doing what it's always done.
I think there will be tens of millions in OECD countries living with basic income (or something in a similar vein) with tens of millions in the US are still laboring at work.
[1] The US is at or very near the worst among OECD countries in: infant mortality, child poverty, child health and safety, life expectancy at birth, healthy life expectancy, rate of obesity, disability-adjusted life years, doctors per 1000 people, deaths from treatable conditions, rate of mental health disorders, rate of drug abuse, rate of prescription drug use, incarceration rate, rate of assaults, rate of homicides, income inequality, wealth inequality, and economic
mobility.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoSure, but in terms of GDP per capita we're one of the best (and the best overall large country)! U-S-A! U-S-A!
- disordinary 10y agoIt's very easy to judge, but when you're in the situation that you've lost your job of 20 years because the plant you work at is no longer competitive, your bank is about to foreclose on your house, and you have to pull your kids out of university because you can no longer pay the tuition. Then the promises of the Trump campaign (and Brexit) become very persuasive. The scary thing is if the politicians themselves actually believe in what they're saying. But maybe they're right, the US has the benefit of being a huge country with most of the resources it needs to survive within its borders, perhaps you tear up trade agreements and start a policy of being more reclusive to protect your industries and employment. I see one huge advantage that the US has in a global world though, and that is (at least for now) it is by far the dominant player in the web space. Countries like Russia and China have their own services that are playing catch up on their US counterparts, but they are still well behind for the most part. In any future imaginable the web, or a successor is going to continue to be the biggest part of our lives and therefore the worlds money will continue to flow into the US. Despite what I just said, I too worry about the US. There seems to be a deep seated suspicion of anything socialist and most of the solutions to a massively automated society seem to be socialist ones (i.e. a universal basic income, or the government regulating businesses to provide for the common good). You'd hope that if it came to that scenario the US would follow suit and provide for its citizens that cannot work. But there is precedent for the opposite, the world went through a similar scenario in the 30's with the great depression. Most countries in the OECD came out of that decade with comprehensive social welfare systems, the US did not.
- grecy 10y ago> It's very easy to judge, but when you're in the situation.... I wasn't trying to judge, or to say my comments are pointing out things are inherently good or bad, just that I think that's how things are. Who knows, maybe in 50-100 years tons of OECD countries will have homeless millions out of work, while the US is more-or-less similar to today...?
- disordinary 10y agoSorry @grecy, I wasn't really talking about you - just a note in general and to myself as much as anyone else. :) We can say that people are backwards looking but we don't really understand their circumstances. Unfortunately a lot of hurt is going to come and a lot of people are not going to be happy. Expect a continued wave of conservatism, because change is scary.
- T-A 10y ago> In any future imaginable the web, or a successor is going to continue to be the biggest part of our lives Reality check: the Internet economy (all of it, not just the web) contributes ~5% to US GDP [1]. https://www.statista.com/statistics/250703/forecast-of-internet-economy-as-percentage-of-gdp-in-g-20-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/250703/forecast-of-inter... I would also not be so quick to dismiss especially China's web companies. It's a different world on the other side of the Great Firewall.
- disordinary 10y agoI was talking about the flow of the worlds money in the future.
- visarga 10y agoBefore we can pass BHI, another simpler measure might be easier to achieve - public works. If the government invests in infrastructure and public works, it can hire back some jobless people. It's a stopgap measure until automation becomes almost complete.
- grecy 10y agoI always imagine what the US would be like if the trillions of dollars and millions of man hours had been spent on domestic projects instead of foreign wars. Infrastructure, education, training, transport, logistics, etc.
- drieddust 10y ago> The voting in of Trump shows how conservative and not forward-looking the US is. Vast swaths of the South are hell-bent on keeping things the way they are (for better or worse). This is also shows there are problems boiling under the surface of growth. World is now becoming more and more like it was in middle age where a handful of kings commanded absolute power over their subjects. AI fulled highly optimized corporations could be the new kings of this world and they will command their subjects to work to death or perhaps they will just organize online gladiator games just for fun. Most of the world's population is at risk of becoming useless unless world wakes up now to put the right safe guards.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe manufacturing sector in the US is perfectly happy to automate. It's not like the countries higher than the US in the measures you list don't have jobs and manufacturing and so on, they just tend to have stronger social safety nets and sane healthcare systems.