8 ms·
None. The people who opposed Trump would still have opposed him, and the people who supported him would have brought up the Clinton email scandal and accused th
by krapp 10y ago
None. The people who opposed Trump would still have opposed him, and the people who supported him would have brought up the Clinton email scandal and accused the media of slander and propaganda for even trying to equivocate him with "crooked Hillary."
Trump quipped during the election that he could shoot somebody and not lose voters, and I kind of suspect he wasn't wrong. His support was a matter of reactionist ideology - it didn't matter if he was honest, competent, or sincere, only that he served as the vessel for the right wing zeitgeist.
- icanhackit 10y agoIt makes you wonder how many people consider politics to be like sport - you have your team and stick with them. Even if a player on a team is accused of a crime (usually sexual) fans often stick with them and blame the victim instead.
- nickthemagicman 10y agoIts all.belief and tribalism. Just like religion and sports. Fundamental lizard brain stuff. Scary to see where thats led us throughout history.
- krapp 10y agoknee-jerk tribalism a difficult trap to avoid. Even on HN, which is supposed to self-select for high intellect and curiosity, politics seems to short-circuit otherwise reasonable and intelligent people's rational thinking. I've fallen prey to it a number of times without even realizing it.
- grzm 10y agoAgreed. Forums do have one advantage: you have the opportunity to review what you wrote before you submit. And if we can note politely when we see it in others, maybe we can build better habits. Who knows? We manage to shape our speech in different contexts. Maybe I could have a little js script (that I run myself) that detects language I'd rather not use. Kind of like a spell checker. I could choose to turn it on, and I could choose to ignore its suggestions. Or maybe more like an ignition interlock, but one I can override :)
- tedunangst 10y agoAll the people on the other team. My side only supports decent people, though.
- emp_zealoth 10y agoYour absurd reductionism is so simple and nice. Shame it has no grounding in reality and only makes the whole shithole we live in worse. Sure, we can spew bs how its racists misoginists haters and worst of all white men Or we could have a discussion about facts and issues People are tired of rampant "social justice" that is vindictive and spiteful People are tired of being called racists wholesale Clinton gave some random dude highest clearance, he stepped down right after the press found it out She took bribes not to declare tourism area dangerous even though she was advised to do so by pretty much everybody She is mixed in so many scandals, sure, Trump is a scumbag, but what was her message in the race? The worst possible identity politics - vote for me, otherwise you are racist deplorable trash. I MEAN WHAT
- krapp 10y agoWell, someone's jimmies are rustled. >Sure, we can spew bs how its racists misoginists haters and worst of all white men We can, as you apparently are, but I never did. I'm guessing this is where you try to set me up as some kind of SJW strawman, tell me what I really believe and then proceed to tear down the arguments I never actually made? >People are tired of rampant "social justice" that is vindictive and spiteful >People are tired of being called racists wholesale Sure, some people are. But Trump can't outlaw "social justice" and can't force people not to accept political correctness, so I have to ask, whether these complaints are relevant in the context of this particular discussion? >She is mixed in so many scandals, sure, Trump is a scumbag, but what was her message in the race? >The worst possible identity politics - vote for me, otherwise you are racist deplorable trash. That wasn't her message, and you probably know perfectly well that it wasn't. Your comment provides an example of exactly the reactionist ideology I was talking about. You want to discuss "facts and issues" but provide little more than an emotionally charged and intellectually vacant polemic, appealing to anti-left stereotypes and hyperbole. You accuse me of absurd reductionism while apparently blind to the degree to which you're engaging in it yourself, thereby proving my point.
- emp_zealoth 10y agoYou see, I'm actually proper leftist. I'm from Europe and I laugh my ass off watching your failing healthcare, your nuclear student debt, your crime, the like I'm a proper leftist - I want taxes for the rich, singlepayer healthcare, free education, worker rights, real environment protection, etc etc I'm just outraged at what the fuck is happening. The "left" is so laughable that in Poland we have an upcoming dictator that just took over supreme court, is building a second, volounteer "defence army" that the ruling party just struck down regulation prohibiting it from being used against polish citizens and is on the record saying "we must hold onto power no matter what" You've got brexit, you've got Trump. In Sweden you got SD, France is looking more and more that Le Pen will win. And you know why? It's your own fault. The "left" is not able to deal in reality no more and it was busy alienating and radicalising the right The "clinton email" scandal you put into sweet quotation marks has emails that nicely explain it all as it was happening. She is THE "devil". She is the epitome of what's wrong with your politics. She is a sellout, she fucked Bernie with a giant cactus (A man who I was so rooting for). She is so despicable that she was unable to beat Trump, who you could tell after 15 minutes of the debate has no fucking clue. At least he looked genuine, he was uncomfortable and pissed during the debate I watched. She just pandered and pandered and slinged shit at him. Yes, my jimmies are rustled. Not because Trump won, I'm not happy Clinton lost, as it was pyrrhic victory. I'm pissed because the response (from the media) to the "end times" (as I see it) is more bullshit and idiocy, more "ZOMG RACISM, ZOMG WHITELASH" What the fuck?!