18 ms·
Well there is considerably less threat to workers in regards to automation in the West than in the developing world, we've outsourced everything already to the
by dogma1138 10y ago
Well there is considerably less threat to workers in regards to automation in the West than in the developing world, we've outsourced everything already to the developing world, now the developing world is about the experience the same thing.
The west has sufficient capital and social infrastructure to get by even without a preemptive socioeconomic changes the developing world doesn't have the luxury.
The girls that work in sweatshops in Bangladesh won't be able to retrain or become master crafters selling overpriced crap on Etsy because you'll going to be buying clothes from a dispensary that would 3D print or weave the clothes in minutes to fit your size and specifications perfectly, while people in the west can.
Truck drivers will likely to find other things to do since there will be sufficient capital to pay for jobs, newer generations would have jobs that don't exist yet, heck as long as the west keeps generating wealth the "self employed neohipster economy" can continue growing, we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think, you can make a pretty good money from selling bamboo sticks on Etsy, and when everyone will have a 3D printer, weaver and CNC milling machine in their home or at the local 7/11 people would be able to sell their designs on the printer's template store.
Just like smartphones enabled everyone with even basic programming skills to make a decent income from selling apps, like youtube and other sites enabled people to make money by generating content, automation including on-demand manufacturing will generate new opportunities.
But these opportunities will likely to be limited to the already privileged just like every other opportunity beforehand, the developing world always gets the scraps of the table.
- collinmanderson 10y ago> we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think I'd be curious what percentage of YouTube channels are actually profitable. Sure, there are probably a lot of people making millions, but I bet there are even more failures out there. Self employment probably won't work for everyone.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf you actually put in the required effort and make it a full time job you can make money, if you dick around then you won't. https://socialblade.com/ https://socialblade.com/ and other similar sites have pretty good estimates, even if you lower the income of pretty much every full time production channel by 10 it's still more than enough to live on.
- dvtv75 10y ago> If you actually put in the required effort and make it a full time job you can make money, > if you dick around then you won't. This is literally "If you work hard you will be rewarded." Unfortunately, that's ideology rather than fact.
- zlynx 10y agoPossibly. However, the reverse is much more true. "If you don't work hard, you will not be rewarded." If you want any chance at all then you have to put in the work. For every Lindsey Sterling there's thousands of people playing violin, badly, in their sweatpants with a Mt. Dew in the background.
- intended 10y agoI beg to differ. 1) there's the illustration of people ignoring a world Class violinist playing on the subway when dressed as a busker 2) there's a lot of superlative, good and very good art out there today. It means art is cheap. 3) art like sports has a log distribution of wealth and success. Only a very small minority of people will make money out of it, and a handful of people will make good money out of it. Even if you work extremely hard and constantly. Take a look at the number of profiles of people on deviant art and the quality of work being put out, and then the prices and amount of money made. It's the same for music.
- goodcanadian 10y ago1) there's the illustration of people ignoring a world Class violinist playing on the subway when dressed as a busker I hate to see this brought up over and over. There is a great contextual difference between a concert hall and a subway station. People go to the concert hall to hear music. People go to the subway to get to work. It is not that they don't recognise the quality of the music; they are simply not paying attention to the music at all. Even if they do notice the music and notice that it is unusually good, they are still not all that likely to stop. They have a train to catch and things to do. Why is it surprising that people would ignore a busker in the subway no matter how good they are?
- gutnor 10y ago> we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think The top 0.1% of the world richest, that 7 million people, that´s a lot of people ... Seriously you make money on youtube by having an extra-large volume of views, and that by definition is going to be a vast minority of the content on youtube. > Just like smartphones enabled everyone with even basic programming skills to make a decent income from selling apps Not everyone. Same thing, the vast majority of app developer don´t make any money. Anyway, why talk about an hypothetical future, why not look at the current world. Since people are currently employed in traditional job and the competition is lower, artists must make an absolute killing, right ? Photographer, Singer, Actor, Music player, Painter, ... surely we must have noticed a massive increase in wealth in those fields and that´s the reason there are so few people going into STEM ?
- mdpopescu 10y agoI don't know about the other artists, but there is a huge growth in the indie writer market. Surprise, who knew that removing middlemen improved the producer's income? I am also seeing more-than-decent incomes in the esports community. People making thousands of dollars a month playing, or commenting, video games. I think people are starting to discover that the way to get an income is to do something other people enjoy.
- desireco42 10y ago"self employed neohipster economy" love this part
- skissane 10y ago> Truck drivers will likely to find other things to do since there will be sufficient capital to pay for jobs I think some types of road transport jobs will defy automation for far longer than others. Consider for example a removalist – driving a truck from A to B is far easier to automate than loading and unloading furniture and household effects. By contrast, moving goods between warehouses could be fully automated, since the loading dock at each end could be purpose built to support robotic loading/unloading.
- gozur88 10y agoIf they get the kinks out of automated trucks, automated forklifts will be pretty easy. In a warehouse you have much more control over the environment.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere are already quite a few automated forklifts, some airports also automate baggage delivery lorries and there are automated taxi bots in airports for some time now.
- SiVal 10y agoI half agree. The road transport portion can easily be automated when self-driving trucks are automated. It's just the loading and unloading (from, as you suggest, a private home) that will be much harder to automate. So, you call a service that auto-drives a big container over to you, puts it in your driveway, and leaves. You load your furniture into the big container or hire "loaders" to come do it for you. You call the service, and an automated truck comes, picks up the box, drives it to its destination, puts it in the new driveway, and leaves. You unload it yourself or hire someone, and when it's empty, another automated truck comes by and gets the container. For urban destinations (no driveways), you call the truck and have loaders/unloaders waiting. For driveways that are blocked by cars or whatever, the truck calls home and a remote operator makes some choices, but he won't have to stay with the truck on the road, so he can manage a whole fleet and doesn't do any loading or unloading. The loading and unloading? Yes, some humans will have to do it for a long time. The road transport? You can automate that part separately.
- mattnewton 10y agoI am not so sure we're going to adjust outside of the bubble of Silicon Valley or New York. There are a lot of American jobs too that will go away, maybe more so than the third world because American workers are so much more expernsive.
- disordinary 10y agoThe west is going to loose millions of jobs, and you're talking about replacing them with thousands. The mainstay of developed countries are the service industries, but already we've lost bank tellers, checkout operators, petrol station concierges, etc. to automation. Next in line will be couriers, truck drivers, taxi drivers, etc. Eventually most jobs will be lost. As a developer, if I'm lucky enough to have a job in the future, it will be writing specifications for code that will be automatically generated. We aren't going to replace all of those jobs with hand crafted jewelry.
- intended 10y agoWhat people need to consider is that new jobs are being made and economics has not stopped working. The question is - are the new jobs as well paying as the jobs which are lost.
- disordinary 10y agoOr if they're FTE positions, in the future we may work 3 day weeks.
- anigbrowl 10y agoSome new jobs are being made, but not enough. Actually, serious economists are beginning to worry that macroeconomics is broken and that the existing models of economic development are no longer functioning as expected. I think the chief economist at the World Bank counts as a 'serious economist' and urge you to read his paper described in this news article: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/policy-trends/world-banks-chief-economist-romer-says-macroeconomics-in-trouble/articleshow/55508187.cms http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/policy-trends/... I really love economics, but you've got to realize that while microeconomics is extremely rigorous and everyone should know some of it, macroeconomics involves a great deal of ideological assumptions and hand-waving, and doesn't have a good theory of technological disruption any more than it has a really good theory of oligopoly.
- Roritharr 10y agoOne could argue that if you are not writing straight ASM, you ARE writing specifications for Code already...
- anigbrowl 10y agoThanks for your considered reply, but I'm sorry to say I disagree with almost everything you wrote. Other posters have made the same basic points I would have, so I'll just add that the logic of automation is so inexorable and one-way that there is no conceivable upside for the vast majority of people to compete to be the last to run out of cash.
- petra 10y ago>> we have youtube stars that make millions each year, and there aren't as few of them as you think, Last time i researched this issue, i came to the conclusion there are only about a few thousand youtubers, globally , are making a living.
- anigbrowl 10y agowe've outsourced everything already to the developing world LOL no. If I had a few billions of capital to deploy I could put a lot more people out of work in the US within a few years. This is great from a consumer point of view (personally I often prefer using a machine to having to deal with a person) but it's pretty terrible from an macroeconomic standpoint because you have an ever-shrinking pool of people earning money relative to the size of the population as a whole.