3 ms·
I read the first one, and it was incredibly interesting, but mostly from the cultural and historical perspectives. The "magic" bit I referenced seemed ... overp
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
I read the first one, and it was incredibly interesting, but mostly from the cultural and historical perspectives. The "magic" bit I referenced seemed ... overpowered and yet underused. It's incredibly difficult to imagine an intelligence that can come up with that, but not extrapolate any further.
Potential spoiler alert: Using that particular plot device to fool scientists into believing the laws of physics weren't constant struck me as ludicrous. The part where physicists start committing suicide instead of seeing this as the start of a revolution in their understanding of the universe was almost plausible by comparison.
I need to read the second two, but I heard that the translations aren't as good :/
- pjc50 10y agoTaking the plot device entirely literally misses the point of the book somewhat; it's so highly metaphorical and so much of it is told through the "VR" dream sequence exposition. It's really a book about the question: how do we know what we know? Specifically, how do we find truth when powerful forces have devoted themselves to obfuscating it for us? In other words, the "cultural revolution" in China. And by extension, the present day wǔmáo dǎng era.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI haven't read the sequels, but the Sophon bit seemed pretty explicitly literal. How can I not read that part literally? Either the Sophons have the power ascribed, or the plot is nonsense.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoObviously it is literal, it has to be - it's relevant to the object-level plot both in the first book and in the latter two. Whether or not it has layers of additional "meta" meaning associated with it, that's another topic. Though I'm not sure about the indirect references to various political events that people seek in the story - the author himself wrote explicitly in the afterword for American readers that he is not writing sci-fi to explore contemporary issues in different settings.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoMy current "head canon" theory explaining the underutilization of sophons is like this: at first, they weren't meant to be discovered, so they were used primarily for covert communications and locking down particle physics research. Later, they may have decided not to abuse them to wreck havoc with advanced technology in order not to incentivize humans to invest too heavily into sophon-proofing. I don't know Chinese so I can't evaluate the accuracy of the translations of the other two books, but taken at face value, IMO they're pretty good pieces of writing. I didn't notice any obvious problems, and on the other hand I very much appreciated frequent inclusion of translator's notes that explained things like untranslatable humour, and provided the cultural background for things that may be obscure to Western readers.