3 ms·
Yeah, I was wondering about that, too. Granted, the BSD base is arguably one step removed from Apple (as that was NeXTSTEP, which Apple acquired), and both Darw
by grzm 10y ago
Yeah, I was wondering about that, too. Granted, the BSD base is arguably one step removed from Apple (as that was NeXTSTEP, which Apple acquired), and both Darwin and OpenStep are open source. Apple continues to release the source of some of their software.[0] According to the "Myths" page at FreeBSD, "FreeBSD 9.1 and later include a C++ stack and compiler that were originally developed for OS X, with major parts of the work done by Apple employees",[1] so it hasn't completely been freeloading.
I don't know enough about the levels of contribution to either to make a strong comparison, and I'm more than willing to grant IBM and Red Hat make much larger contributions to Linux than Apple does to FreeBSD. And I sympathize with the desire to have more contributions. The "how Apple treated BSD" phrasing sounds like there is more active bad treatment rather than not contributing enough. Maybe the hiring of Jordan Hubbard is considered active bad treatment? (Honest question)
[0]: https://opensource.apple.com https://opensource.apple.com
[1]: https://wiki.freebsd.org/Myths#FreeBSD_is_Just_OS_X_Without_the_Good_Bits https://wiki.freebsd.org/Myths#FreeBSD_is_Just_OS_X_Without_...
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"so it hasn't completely been freeloading." That's Clang/LLVM compiler that gets them off GCC's GPL codebase. It also allows them to keep more extensions proprietary if they choose. It's been beneficial to the OSS community but I'd say it's barely altruistic. An exception rather than the rule. " The "how Apple treated BSD" phrasing sounds like there is more active bad treatment rather than not contributing enough" Helps to remember that it's how a lack of contributions is commonly phrased. Freeloading is probably the dominant model for both users and companies far as FOSS. It's just how they word the gripe. I agree they should probably use clearer phrasing for others not deep into this subject matter.
- this-dang-guy 10y agoYou are correct, I should have been more clear in my phrasing.