2 ms·
I agree with everything except your last paragraph. You're mostly on track with what I'm talking about. There are plenty of people who throw a bunch of bullshit
by hammock 10y ago
I agree with everything except your last paragraph. You're mostly on track with what I'm talking about. There are plenty of people who throw a bunch of bullshit into a "grand-sounding theory." And on the other hand, just because something isn't backed by a mathematical theorem, doesn't mean it isn't true, or useful!
- infinity0 10y agoAgreed that unproven does not imply false, and there is a tendency for people purporting to be "skeptics" to make this fallacy. There's even a name for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_fallacy However, it's too easy for bullshit-artists to hide behind this, as a way to deflect criticism of the theories that they're proposing, or the general area of work that they've chosen to pursue. We're all human so it's perfectly reasonable to believe in something that's unproven - but then be honest about it, and explore the topic from a critical viewpoint without getting personally defensive. Unfortunately I see many more cases of this, than instances of the fallacy-fallacy.