3 ms·
It's easy to trust Wikileaks. The only standard they have to adhere to is to not invent, adulterate, or filter material. That's a pretty low standard. By contra
by wahern 10y ago
It's easy to trust Wikileaks. The only standard they have to adhere to is to not invent, adulterate, or filter material. That's a pretty low standard. By contrast, professional journalists seek out and independently confirm leaks with other insiders. They associate, summarize, and contextualize. Wikileaks doesn't do this--they can't do this--because their sources are anonymous, and because Wikileaks has foresworn taking upon itself the responsibility and concomitant risk (of error, of bias) of doing those other things.
That means Wikileaks is in no better position than anyone else. Their value add, beyond serving as an initial depot for leaks, is thin. And that's fine. Similarly, there's little to criticize. (I've seen claims on HN that Assange rejected some purported Trump leaks, but I didn't check on that myself.)
I absolutely think Wikileaks is useful and essential. But if the outlet you trust the most is Wikileaks, you'll never really know or understanding anything. It's like saying the only source of information you can trust is the Internet. What does that even mean? How can you possibly think you can consume all of that data unassisted?
While you claim Wikileaks is the most trustworthy, I suspect that most of your opinions (whatever they are) were principally informed by other journalists reviewing, criticizing, and editorializing on what Wikileaks publishes. You're flying blind if you don't realize that.
For example, you claim that CNN is lying about the legality of possessing classified documents. How did you form that opinion? All on your own? Are you a lawyer specializing in the confluence of national security and free speech law?
The person spreading falsehood here is Sarah Hannon. She said,
CNN has even suggested, wrongly, that readers may have legal
troubles if they download documents from our site.
The reality--which you can confirm with a few moments of Googling--is that the government interprets the relevant statues such that if you hold a security clearance, then reading classified material without authorization, no matter where it came from, is considered illegal. You have an affirmative duty not to read it under their interpretation. That rule makes more sense than you'd think because you don't want people claiming that they "stumbled" onto classified information. Criminal law in the U.S. requires intention, and without the law requiring that you affirmatively avoid classified information, it's much easier to get out of a charge on a technicality. It also incentivizes people who do stumble onto classified information to notify authorities.
Furthermore, acquiring a security clearance is something you choose to do, not something forced upon you, which means typical Free Speech defenses are far less likely to help you. And that presumes that it is legal for everyone else to possess _any_ classified information that has been published via Wikileaks. (Which is, at best, highly debatable. And I definitely cannot see SCOTUS creating a blanket, bright-line rule like that without leaving a caveat for unforeseen circumstances.)
And on top of that, Hannon even acknowledges that CNN hedged with "may have legal troubles". Clearly they're less comfortable making such absolute claims than Hannon.
Now, we can agree or disagree with the law or the government's interpretation. I'm not about to defend any aspect of how the U.S. government classifies and manages information. (Which is to say, I think much of the system is ethically indefensible.) But facts are far tricker things than you'd think. Not acknowledging that is very dangerous.
- rdtsc 10y ago> How did you form that opinion? All on your own? Are you a lawyer specializing in the confluence of national security and free speech law? I worked in the defense industry for almost 10 years. I know how that works. > -is that the government interprets the relevant statues such that if you hold a security clearance, So CNN's Cuomo was acting as the trusty Security Officer and was just caring for the poor souls who have clearance. How kind of him ;-) Now, let's be honest, do think he said what he said just because of the security clearance aspect? > You have an affirmative duty not to read it under their interpretation. If you need CNN to remind you of that duty, you'd probably be in trouble one way or another at some point. Also since you seem to know a bit about this stuff. Curious what you think about Hillary's private email server with TS SAP material on it. Do you think she should have been prosecuted and not allowed to run for President? Why do you think she wasn't? I've heard of people going to jail and at best lost their jobs and probably a chance to get clearance forever for a lot less.
- wahern 10y agoNow, let's be honest, do think he said what he said just because of the security clearance aspect? I think he said that because he was parroting what administration officials have continually shouted. Presumably CNN verified the credibility of the statement, which made it even more newsworthy. He's basically communicating information given him by another source, judged to be newsworthy because at least one (very significant) party thinks it incredibly important to communicate, and as best he knew it was true and pertinent. That's precisely what Wikileaks does, does it not? Or do we call a piece of news a talking point when we don't like it, and just the facts when it's something we approve of? Wikileaks gets a pass for shoveling everything sent its way, but now you're unhappy because CNN failed to affirmatively apply some editorial license? That's what I mean by saying that it's easier to find fault with other news outlets than it is with Wikileaks. You're holding CNN to a higher standard than Wikileaks. And you know what? You should! But that also means that determining what's "trustworthy" is a heck of alot messier. Also since you seem to know a bit about this stuff. Curious what you think about Hillary's private email server with TS SAP material on it. Do you think she should have been prosecuted and not allowed to run for President? Why do you think she wasn't? I've heard of people going to jail and at best lost their jobs and probably a chance to get clearance forever for a lot less. Regarding Hillary, I think it was much ado about nothing, even ignoring the partisan angle. Colin Powell and countless other officials did and presumably still do the same thing. That alone isn't an excuse. But if government IT is anything like corporate IT, I'm not surprised people felt hindered and unproductive dealing with the rules, and neither surprised nor upset that such officials felt entitled to skirt the rules. And, frankly, I think a cabinet level official has and should have (perhaps as a matter of law, but certainly as a practical matter) significant license. A C-level executive isn't going to get in trouble for violating one of IT's rules, nor should they. Their productivity is paramount, and there's no objective way to tell them that they're wrong in that regard. I think what Bush Whitehouse officials did with their private e-mail servers was far more suspect, but even at the time I was dubious on the illegality of it. High-level officials play by different rules, for good reason. There are limits to the laws Congress can pass to constrain the executive without violating fundamental separation of powers principles. We can quibble about how immune Hillary would be to liability for ignoring procedural IT rules and regulations, but there's a very strong case that she had Constitutionally-protected authority to disclose classified material however she saw fit had she chosen to do so. Just like I believed Dick Cheney did, presuming he intentionally leaked or ordered the leak of the identity of Valeri Plame. (And, by god, I truly believe Cheney is a fscking malevolent sociopath, though unlike Trump being a narcissist I understand that's taking a leap.) Libby went to prison for perjury, not for disclosure. I'd bet money if Libby just admitted it, and he defended himself all the way to SCOTUS, that the charges wouldn't stick. That other people have been punished for the same thing Hillary did is beside the point. First, while I think the rules are applied inconsistently, I'd simply prefer that we loosen them up for everybody. I'm not about to argue for throwing the book at Hillary out of spite. And in any event, high-level officials, especially Cabinet appointees, have inherent powers which makes them legitimately exceptional. Second, I think the over-classification of material harms national security. They sure as hell didn't stop the OPM breach or countless other breaches. They provide a false sense of security, including the sense that IT systems can be secured at the edges with trivial procedures and limitations rather than systemic improvements to data security and exfiltration prevention. If they did that then government might realize that by classifying everything under the sun, they're making it more difficult to secure the truly sensitive stuff. Finally, there's little reason to think Hillary's e-mail damaged national security. First of all, nothing in the published e-mail was damaging, even presuming it was classified then or later. (A _big_ presumption.) Certainly nothing that would even be remotely surprising to Russia or China. Second, however secure her personal server, I'd be shocked if her server was substantively less secure than whatever the State Department was using. As I've posted elsewhere, I think the election of Trump has been a travesty. I think the man has a mental disorder. More to the point, I won't be surprised when he intentionally or unintentionally leaks national secrets all over Twitter, whether from his NSA-provided smartphone or his personal iPhone. And other officials will likely do the same thing. The left will flip out and the right will shut their ears or spin it. But regardless, it'll be Trump and his officials' fscking prerogative, and I'll be happy to defend that prerogative, as a matter of law, even when it's exercised for nakedly partisan purposes.