7 ms·
I thought this was a joke when I read the abstract, but it appears to be a genuine paper. This paragraph in particular is one of the worst examples I've ever s
by nl 10y ago
I thought this was a joke when I read the abstract, but it appears to be a genuine paper.
This paragraph in particular is one of the worst examples I've ever seen of researchers NOT UNDERSTANDING WHAT THEY ARE DOING:
Unlike a human examiner/judge, a computer vision algorithm or classifier has absolutely no subjective baggages, having no emotions, no biases whatsoever due to past experience, race, religion, political doctrine, gender, age, etc., no mental fatigue, no preconditioning of a bad sleep or meal. The automated inference on criminality eliminates the variable of meta-accuracy (the competence of the human judge/examiner) all together.
Please, read Weapons of Math Destruction and understand how excellent machine learning is at discovering and exploiting the biases in datasets.
Edit, no, sorry, it gets worse:
the upper lip curvature is on average 23.4% larger for criminals than for non-criminals.
the distance d between two eye inner corners for criminals is slightly shorter (5.6%) than for non-criminals
- united893 10y agoI think it's meant to be satire, in the form of "A modest proposal" but applied to ML classifying criminals.
- nl 10y agoI really, really hope so.
- jkfkjajlkejk 10y agoUp until a couple weeks ago, I also had no idea how much biases can affect people's decisions and brains My brain seems to have since rewired itself, to be able to understand biases and find out how to misconstrue anyone's intents, to the point of being able to delude myself, or other people who I can share communication with Maybe a simple way of "teaching" them would be to communicate to them how they are potentially part of a large conspiracy, and that they have not yet realized? Hopefully also teaching them how to question authority, including the authority over themselves and others before doing so, in order to minimize risk of harm to anyone involved. The only thing you can be forced to do in this world is die. The rest is all in your head.
- leblancfg 10y agoI am just as shocked and appalled that it's getting upvoted. It's so un-scientific, it should be taught in class as a counterexample.
- AbrahamParangi 10y agoI agree in general that this sort of work has a long and storied history of being junk science (like phrenology), and one might even be tempted to describe this sort of work as irresponsible- But I think we shouldn't get too prescriptive about what constitutes interesting and useful science. There may be very interesting relationships to uncover that we will otherwise miss. Previous research suggests that the correlation between attractiveness and 'averageness of features' is a strong one and one thesis is that this is because having features 'matching the template' is indicative of general fitness and resistance to disease. Based on this research you might wonder about whether or not a person having perceived low fitness was a risk factor for criminality. Or perhaps the low fitness itself somehow causes criminality? Indeed there are many other interesting interpretations that we might miss out on if we judge all 'dangerous' work at face value. Perhaps we as a society are willing to give up on those ideas in our desire to avoid the atrocities of the past, but personally I am not. Onwards and upwards, they say.
- kashkhan 10y agoobviously because faces physically change when you do crime. charles manson was a happy camper before he started a murderin. All in the upper lip curvature, because why would a criminal smile in a mugshot.
- nl 10y agoI'm not sure if you are trolling or not. Please don't. All in the upper lip curvature, because why would a criminal smile in a mugshot. Why would a non-criminal smile in a mugshot?
- jedwards1211 10y agothat brings up an important point -- being convicted or incarcerated might affect one's daily mood enough to change their resting facial expression -- so to control for that the study should have made sure to only use photos of criminals taken before their first arrest or conviction, perhaps even before their first confessed criminal act if possible.
- glglwty 10y agoTheir data set may be more valuable than paper itself...
- fhadley 10y agoFirst of all, I don't think this is satire. I'll admit that the use of a gmail account by a researcher at a Chinese uni is facially suspicious, but it's not that odd given that cursory googling shows that both authors appear to be faculty members at Shanghai Jiao Tong University as claimed on the paper- though neither appears to have much, if any, background or expertise in machine learning. I'm not much of a fan of a lot of the arguments made in Weapons of Math Destruction, but I do appreciate that in summarizing you draw the distinction between the biases of the engineer or (illogically, but oft-claimed nonetheless) the algorithm itself and the data which is used to train said model, and I think it's quite a valuable concept in regards to this particular paper. For instance, the data set they're using here is fairly small, and while, they did use 10-fold cross-validation, that's still a bit on the less than ideal side generally speaking neural nets, especially CNN architectures, which are usually pretty deep. Furthermore, the dataset itself seems fairly questionable to me. I'm not sure how much I trust the Chinese criminal justice system to adequately adjudicate culpability in the first place, but even setting aside such admittedly conspiratorial notions, it seems rather odd indeed that nearly half of their positive samples are not in fact convicted criminals but merely suspects. I do not find their attempts at devil's advocate persuasive as it's not readily obvious exactly how they used or obtained any of their testing with the three different data sets. As for the appropriateness of the broader topic, I'm more or less of the persuasion that all questions deserve to be examined, and that provided the work does not cause direct harm, it's hard for me to support a prohibition on examination of a given topic. That said, I do think that the more controversial the question, the higher quality of research required, and, good lord, does this mess fall well short of the mark. Perhaps if there existed a hypothetical criminal justice system free of systemic biases or, more realistically, a method by which to exactly define those prejudices and account for them in the composition of a data set, this could be a potentially useful question to investigate, but even then it seems to me quite unlikely that there's any particularly significant relationship between one's upper lip curvature and criminal disposition.
- seekupdown 10y agoThe first author is a well established academic in Canada: https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=ZuQnEIgAAAAJ&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=ZuQnEIgAAAAJ&hl=en All positive instances ARE convicted criminals, among whom there are NO political prisoners, just for your information.
- dang 10y agoI'm sure we all agree with you about phrenology revivals but please don't use uppercase for emphasis! https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- rofer 10y agoI think the point of what they're saying is that the algorithm largely doesn't bring additional biases. This paper is showing there's a detectable difference between the criminal and non-criminal faces in their dataset. Obviously, this would be the case if criminals actually had different faces. However, it could also be the case that people with more extreme faces are more likely to be convicted. That is, this paper could be showing that their dataset is biased. Personally, I find this paper really interesting. I wouldn't have previously believed you could train a classifier so accurate just from facial images. It could be revealing some really strong biases in the criminal justice system and I'd love to see this kind of work used to help combat human biases rather than simply reinforce them (which seems to be how most people envision this will be used).