8 ms·
I don't actually believe this, but it occurred to me the other day as a funny way to look at a very sad situation: What if Trump does believe global warming is
by snowwrestler 10y ago
I don't actually believe this, but it occurred to me the other day as a funny way to look at a very sad situation:
What if Trump does believe global warming is real, but recognizes that we're too late to stop its worst effects? What if he expects the world to go to hell over the next 50 years and is focused on protecting the U.S. specifically? What would he do?
He'd build a wall across the lower border of the U.S. to keep out southern populations fleeing extreme heat. But he'd keep the border with Canada open, so Americans can flee there if they need to. The oceans will protect us from the rest of the world.
He'd disentangle us from overseas treaty obligations that might draw us into wars we wouldn't otherwise want to fight. And he'd focus international relations on the few biggest countries who are most likely to secure and defend their own societies.
He'd incentivize U.S. companies to manufacture domestically: long supply chains are a risk.
He'd ramp up infrastructure spending--particularly on the coasts--to be ready to build sea walls and other mitigating structures.
He'd strengthen law enforcement to deal with internal unrest.
Like I said, I don't actually believe this...
EDIT: Another (and perhaps more likely) way to look at this is that Trump and his posse are just paranoid nuts, but by ignoring global warming, they will inadvertently bring about the global calamity that they fear.
- zelon88 10y agoI like that the theory has to assume that Canada is just naturally expected to take in American refugees while Mexico can go screw itself. With such ignorant American exceptionalism it's no wonder why we haven't fixed global warming yet.
- jdavis703 10y agoYou do realize a plurality of American voters voted for Hillary Clinton? She's leading by margins larger than Kennedy and Nixon. Edited to use correct terminology.
- grzm 10y agoI understand your point, but plurality ≠ majority. Plurality is more votes than any other candidate. Majority means more than 50% of the vote. This doesn't detract from the point you're trying to make, but it is inaccurate. You strengthen your argument by using the appropriate word.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hueving 10y ago>You do realize a plurality of American voters voted for Hillary Clinton Nobody cares. Both candidate vote totals combined don't even make up the majority of the US population.
- Al-Khwarizmi 10y agoNon-voters are just accepting whatever the majority (er, plurality) of voters decides.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoAnd if the President was selected by popular vote, that would mean something. It isn't, so it doesn't.
- hbt 10y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one who thought this. No one has a solution for climate change that doesn't involve changing personal habits. People don't want to do that. Eating less meat or a carbon tax (i.e taxing the working poor) is not a solution. It's admitting defeat. People don't need to "believe in climate change". We simply need to build a solution that is much better than what they have available now. What that solution is? Plenty of ideas, no one has a clue how to execute them. The current strategy for the left is: let's see how guilty we can make people feel about their consumption habits and scare them with far distant consequences. Talk about funding "green"/eco-friendly businesses which barely make a difference and try to sell people on carbon tax. For the right, the strategy is: deny, deny, deny. Double down on economic growth and hope innovation follows. Of course, "hope and dreams" sells. Admitting defeat wouldn't get you elected. The rhetoric is adjusted accordingly.
- maxerickson 10y agoWind is almost 5% of US electric production. Solar is finally ready to make a difference (look at the last 5 years of the table: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_States#Generation_.28PV_and_CSP.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_Stat... ). Adding 0.3% of generation each year isn't fast enough, but it's ridiculous to say that no one knows how to execute a move towards clean electricity and that it can barely make a difference. And batteries are almost there as far as being affordable storage.
- yungchin 10y ago> Eating less meat or a carbon tax (i.e taxing the working poor) is not a solution. As for taxing the poor, that's fixable: the legislation should have all revenues from a carbon tax returned as per-capita "rebates" (I'd think of it as a Basic Income paid for by polluters).
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Eating less meat or a carbon tax (i.e taxing the working poor) is not a solution. The poor emit disproportionately little CO2. A carbon tax mostly taxes industry.
- jhobag 10y agothank you for writing down what's been going through my head for the past 2 years
- madaxe_again 10y agoI do. At any rate, I do in the case of world leaders and the actions of states over the last decades. Or at any rate I'd like to believe I do. Virtually everything has been consistent with preparing for the worst case climate disaster. You might think that if we knew it was unavoidable it might comprise protecting populations in cities and so-forth by building huge coastal works, or moving populations, or other such huge projects, but were you to do something so overt you would instill mass panic and bring about a preemptive disaster. No. You would play a very subtle hand. You would tighten border security, and normalise surveillance and the idea of searches, scans, and armed police. You would instill a fear of refugees and migrants - this makes it far easier down the line when we hear how many hundreds of millions are in "temporary accommodation". They're far off. They're different to us. Callousness is a survival attribute, if the suddenly popular zombie horror and post apocalyptic genres tell us anything. You'd saturate popular media with programmes in favour of securitised states, and which deal with unmanageable mindless hordes that need mowing down for the greater good. You'd engage in wars which build a security apparatus and provide a distraction, while simultaneously feeding your black budgets for the preservation of the, hm, economically and socially valuable sectors of society and technology. You hold hope around the idea of escape to another world to keep those whom might act problematically mollified until it's too late. In your end game you start moving your population. Again, you don't want it done in chaotic panic, so you do it piecemeal. A move to the political right, you send your liberal elite scarpering to new climes, and while they're at it they pick places that they think will be mitigated against climate change because they think it might be a problem in their lives. A bit of civil unrest, more leave. Start a war. People flee. People die. Those without the means to flee get left behind - remember that desensitisation bit, and the whole concentrating upwards of wealth - if you wanted to design a system that would leave the majority of humanity unempowered and in the lurch if it all gets climatic, but give the "economically productive elite" a fire escape, you'd build it like what we have today. I don't actually believe this either (although it would almost be comforting to, as it provides an explanation of sorts for the world), but I do wonder what home truths made Obama want to jump after his security briefings eight years ago - and that DoD report from a while back about the defence (civil and national) implications of climate change revealed a sobering level of thought has already gone into some rather dire possibilities. It's a fairly crap hypothesis as one can't readily prove or disprove it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ced 10y agorecognizes that we're too late to stop its worst effects I see this sentiment a lot on HN these days. What's the reasoning behind it? If the temperature in my room increases, I'll go from feeling uncomfortable, to sweating profusely, to fainting, to death. Is there any scientific reason to believe that, say, a 4C increase gives us horrible outcomes, but a 8C increase will be "not much worse"?
- stouset 10y ago4˙C is already reaching an extinction-level event for humanity.
- mike10010100 10y agoNot really for humanity directly. We'd survive. But the plants and animals we depend on probably wouldn't have a very good time, and our biodiversity as a planet would significantly decrease. Not quite extinction level, perhaps another Great Dying, though.
- rybosome 10y ago> Not really for humanity directly...perhaps another Great Dying, though. It seems hard to believe that such a drastic shock to our planet won't trigger panic and resource wars which have the potential to finish us off.
- crpatino 10y agoA great decrease in population, yes. That is different from extintion.
- mike10010100 10y agoFinish us off? I doubt it. We're a tenuous species.
- stouset 10y ago> We'd survive. But the plants and animals we depend on probably wouldn't have a very good time... I'm not sure how you can reconcile these two adjacent statements. Yes, some humans would undoubtedly exist somewhere. But only a tiny fraction of our current world population.
- hourislate 10y agoIt's an interesting theory but I doubt he has looked that far ahead. What you have laid out would be something more along the lines of US Strategic Thinking for the next 100 years. The one thing most folks over look is how far are we ready to go to protect America? Global warming will unleash the largest migration the world has ever seen. There will be more than 2.5 billion people trying to escape somewhere more hospitable. You will have millions showing up on your shores from the far reaches of the world. An example is the 400 Sri Lankans that showed up in a boat off the coast of British Columbia 3 years ago. What to do? At some point there could be a million people showing up on the shores of North America (US/Canada) every month, can you imagine the chaos.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoNo, Trump is not the God-Emperor of Mankind and does not possess century-level prescience. You can totally make a decent science fiction novel out of this, though.
- mmel 10y agoThere is already fanfiction depicting Donald Trump as Warhammer 40,000's Emperor of The Imperium of Man. https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=donald+trump+warhammer+40k https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=donald+trump+warham...
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYes, including memes depicting him as a "Holy Duo" with Vladimir Putin. Fascist and fascist, together at last. All of which misses the point that the Emperor is the bad guy, because it's grimdark: there are no good guys.
- nhaehnle 10y agoI like and upvoted your comment for the discussion and thought it encourages. However, realistically speaking it's extremely unlikely that Trump thinks like that. All the evidence points towards him being extremely incompetent, even completely misunderstanding the extent of the office he's been elected for. He's not the guy to pull off smart conspiracies. The clearest evidence for this is his repeated emphasis on increasing the use of coal and oil. Even if you believe massive global upheaval of societies can no longer be avoided, burning more coal and oil is still going to hurt you.
- spacehacker 10y agoHere is a disturbing summary of potential effects of sea level rise (but be warned that this subreddit tends to be a bit alarmist): https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/5abz8e/why_rising_sea_levels_are_a_problem_for_everybody/ https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/5abz8e/why_rising...
- mzw_mzw 10y ago> But he'd keep the border with Canada open, so Americans can flee there if they need to. See, this kind of loopy apocalypse-mongering is why you guys are having such a hard time persuading average voters that your cause is legit. Under what possible worst-case scenario are Americans going to need to "flee" to Canada? Is that one-foot ocean rise over the next hundred years going to flood the United States all the way to Grand Forks?
- EdSharkey 10y agoI believe "stop pollution" was always the goal and they had to crank the message to alarmist levels to get any traction. As technology progresses and we get better at keeping our local environments clean, I predict their predictions will become increasingly dire. These doomsday warnings are just a sign that we're improving.
- pas 10y agoOr, you know, that things are getting dire. We shall see who was right though.
- mzw_mzw 10y agoDire enough that the population of the United States is going to have to evacuate en masse to Canada? Really?
- pas 10y agoOf course not. But the math is pretty simple. More and bigger waves, more and bigger storms on the coasts. The sea level will rise slowly, but surely. It will take 100+ years, but it'll rise by at least 10 meters, of course if we don't do something against it. And it's not impossible to build dikes and levees, but they'd look like huge hills on the shore. Not so bad, we have plenty of time to move a lot of dirt, but maybe a few people would spend that on preventing sea level rise instead.