5 ms·
Apple gets away with it because they don't have a monopoly. There's a large variety of non-Apple smartphones and tablets you can buy. Microsoft's behavior was
by mikeash 10y ago
Apple gets away with it because they don't have a monopoly. There's a large variety of non-Apple smartphones and tablets you can buy.
Microsoft's behavior was restricted because they were a monopoly. There were alternatives to Windows, but the court decided that they were sufficiently insignificant that Windows was effectively a monopoly. That changes the rules.
Windows market share at the time was about 95%, Apple's smartphone market share is in the neighborhood of 15-20%.
- izacus 10y agoHmm, correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't monopoly law (at least in EU) dependant on the companies market power (e.g. the ability to sway market / damage consumer rights), not market share?
- mikeash 10y agoI imagine so, but it's hard to be in a position like that when you have less than 20% of the market.
- diminish 10y agoBut Apple had 90% of profits, isnt that a better metric of monopoly?
- grzm 10y agoMonopolies are interesting because they limit choice. Increased profit may be a side effect, but that's it. It's accidental, not essential, to the definition.
- ryanpollock 10y agoit's actually 104% of profits now http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2016/11/04/apple-iphone-profit-market-share/#3048abd21394 http://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2016/11/04/apple-ipho...
- rconti 10y agoNot at all.
- ryanpollock 10y agoAs I understand antitrust law, it is legal for a monopoly in one market to expand into an adjacent market. However, if that monopoly stifles competition in the adjacent market in a way that harms consumers, that monopolist’s acts are illegal. By virtue of Apple integrating the operating system with hardware, iOS has a defacto 100% monopoly on devices compatible with Apple's Ax series chips (e.g. A9 in iPhone 6s). There's nothing illegal about that. The market for Ax series devices is now larger than the Intel-compatible PC market was at under consideration during the Microsoft antitrust case. The question then is whether Apple's policies stifle innovation and harm consumers. I think the answer is "yes".
- mikeash 10y agoI don't think the law defines monopolies so narrowly that it's useful or interesting to narrow it down to "devices compatible with Apple's Ax series chips." Back in the MS monopoly days, there were a ton of things people wanted to do where they had no choice but to buy Windows if they wanted to do them. Today, there is very little that people do which requires an iOS device. Apple has many closed features (the App Store, iMessage, iCloud) but open equivalents are available. Almost nobody is buying an iPhone because they need an iPhone in particular to do something. They're buying iPhones because they need a smartphone, and they prefer an iPhone. I am very much not a fan of Apple's approach here, I just don't see anything illegal about it.
- ryanpollock 10y agoI'm pretty sure Apple doesn't need a monopoly on the entire smartphone market to have monopoly power... Apple already got in trouble for price fixing - a violation of the Sherman antitrust act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Apple_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Apple_Inc. Related to iOS and competition within it, see http://fortune.com/2016/06/30/elizabeth-warren-apple-google/ http://fortune.com/2016/06/30/elizabeth-warren-apple-google/ http://www.thehill.com/opinion/op-ed/272399-time-to-prosecute-apple-for-monopolization http://www.thehill.com/opinion/op-ed/272399-time-to-prosecut... Hopefully more to come from me on this topic...my channel here. https://medium.com/@ryanpollock https://medium.com/@ryanpollock
- benologist 10y agoIs a monopoly suit the only legal way to instigate change?
- skrowl 10y agoVoting with your wallet is easier and often more effective. Apple had to be stubborn here because a full Chrome and Firefox (with extensions and apps) could potential hurt their app store revenue.
- foolfoolz 10y agoi would hope so. do you want your users to legally force you to change your product because it's not what they want?
- benologist 10y agoWe're not talking about "users" we're talking about browser apps that are arbitrarily prohibited from participating properly.
- __jal 10y agoSo the "makers" of browser apps should be considered to have a more important stake in Apple's product than the users?
- benologist 10y agoUsers of iOS don't have any input over Apple policies governing whom may publish what so how are they relevant? But if you replace "users" with "Apple executives" and the end result is Firefox, Chrome, Edge, Opera, and anyone who cares to may create an unimpeded browser... then absolutely that voice should carry more weight than "Apple executives" on this occasion.
- guelo 10y agoA new law could do it. Of course Silicon Valley claims that they are so ingenious that it would be a crime against humanity to regulate them.
- ryanpollock 10y agoMike and others, do you realize how different the web on Android has become from the web on iOS? The gap between the web's abilities on the two operating systems is growing quickly. Grab an iPhone and an Android phone, and visit http://pwa.rocks http://pwa.rocks You'll see very different behavior in Chrome for Android and Chrome for iOS because the latter is required to use WebKit. There are some really big problems with the present situation. The web's fundamental promise of a cross-platform consistent runtime is basically broken, and consumers, developers, and businesses all suffer significant but mostly invisible harm.
- azernik 10y agoThat's a separate question from whether they're doing something illegal. Illegality depends on abuse of monopoly power, not on the technical problems it causes for the industry.
- ryanpollock 10y agoGood reading material here https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/monopolization-defined https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a...
- mikeash 10y agoI'm not sure how that's relevant. Note that I'm not defending Apple, merely explaining why they can legally get away with behavior so similar to what got Microsoft in trouble in the 90s.