3 ms·
Admitting that the problem is hard is important but not very helpful for actually solving the problem. Are you trying to discourage people from trying to solve
by Jach 17y ago
Admitting that the problem is hard is important but not very helpful for actually solving the problem. Are you trying to discourage people from trying to solve it? Why, when the benefits should they succeed are astronomical? I agree that a lot of people have rosy-eyed views of an AI future, even ignoring the entire problem of Friendly AI, but why are you attacking them by just stating the difficulty of the problem instead of trying to suggest solutions? Hell, you could even donate some money to the people who do pay attention to the problems: http://www.singinst.org/ http://www.singinst.org/
I don't know how accurate all of your "we" statements are, I'd bet at least one of them is wrong or will be wrong in the near future, considering there's about 7 billion of us and I doubt you've polled us all.
- simonsquiff 17y ago>Are you trying to discourage people from trying to solve it? Not at all, the complete opposite. It's a fascinating area but I feel the expectations are completely out of whack with reality. Most of the articles like this have people saying we're only a decade or two away from proper AI, when I'm arguing that that is just not backed up at all - and people are underestimating what work is involved here. When expectations are set wrong, and people eventually realise it, it can damage research in this area as people don't take it seriously any more. Ref the'AI Winter' - the dramatic cut in funding when governments realised most of the experts in the field had massively over-promised and under-delivered. I think we need to break this down into smaller chunks of bounded problems. There is some amazing research around using human like neural networks and similar processes steps for machine vision - e.g. for object recognition, trying to mimic what happens in nature. This is greatly achievable. Trying to model the entire human brain, with talk about how this will lead in the near future to intelligent, reasoning - even sentient AI - is fun but for the reasons I outlined needs an expectation reboot.