4 ms·
Nice to see the courts doing the right thing here... While I feel that most Police Officers are mostly good, and that a lot of the anti-police rhetoric exceeds
by tracker1 10y ago
Nice to see the courts doing the right thing here... While I feel that most Police Officers are mostly good, and that a lot of the anti-police rhetoric exceeds reasonable; I do believe it's become a systemic issue wrt Police organizations exceeding their positions and violating the rights of the people they are meant to serve.
- jrs235 10y agoFrom the comments on the site: "One of the facts that bothers me most -- other than the officers behavior -- is that this comes from the APPEALS court. The District court apparently found no problem with the violation of his constitutional rights."
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoNot necessarily? It seems reasonable the MPD could & would have appealed if the district ruled against, especially given this case hadn't made national media. And although there were egregious comments made, this is the kind of situation where precedent and judicial restraint almost always ends up favoring the PD. Edit: District court did rule in MPD's favor. Which isn't surprising of course. Still, wouldn't have been surprised if MPD appealed had it gone against them, for above mentioned reasons.
- jrs235 10y agoMatthew Corrigan is the Appellant meaning he was the one appealing the lower courts decision.
- vilhelm_s 10y agoThe court opinion is linked in the first paragraph of the article. It begins > [Corrigan] now appeals the grant of summary judgment to the defendants, challenging the district court’s rulings that there was no constitutional violation and that the officers were entitled to qualified immunity. Also interesting is how close this case was: the appeals court panel was split 2-1. The dissenting judge agrees that there was a constitutional violation, but says this law was not "clearly established" so the officers should have immunity. It goes to show how low the qualified immunity bar is.
- baldfat 10y agoWOW if this doesn't just go to show how far we have gone in terms of our policies.
- gohrt 10y agoFor context, I'm curious if you think that a lot of the pro-police rhetoric also exceeds reasonable.
- tracker1 10y agoSome of it... An example I saw regarding a restaurant offering meals to uniformed police... depending on jurisdiction this may be considered a bribe, and not allowed. It really just depends on the specific case. For the most part, most cops are mostly good... there are some very bad apples out there, and some jurisdictions are definitely worse than others.
- Grishnakh 10y agoNo, they're all bad apples. Have you ever seen what happens when you leave a bad apple in with a bunch of good apples? Very quickly, the entire bunch of apples is bad. That's why we have the whole saying about "bad apples". It utterly amazes me that people constantly use this "bad apples" expression without understanding this. Anyone who eats apples should have this basic understanding about bad apples. Anyway, from what I can tell, whether cops are good or bad is basically department-wide: either a department has decent cops, or they're all horrible and complicit. It's exactly like the "bad apples" analogy, and it depends on the leadership of the department. Notice that it's usually the same departments that come up over and over in the news.