3 ms·
I don't think the problem of the article is with quantitative methods per se. Rather, I read it as a gripe about the specific metrics employed, frex, the h-inde
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
I don't think the problem of the article is with quantitative methods per se. Rather, I read it as a gripe about the specific metrics employed, frex, the h-index.
A problem is that any such metric is only ever going to be a proxy for some assumed real value, and such a proxy is always going to be controversial, particularly if it's used to control access to funding.
Which I think at the end of the day is the big issue here. All this soul-searching is just a big attempt to decide what we spend money on. Who gets to be a scientist, and who gets to become a person with a lot of useless knowledge and an incurable sense of failure.
- infinity0 10y agoIt could be read either way - it doesn't talk too much about differences between metrics, and groups them as near-equivalent. Anyway the exact intention of the author/article is not so important. My point is to say that one way that you could (and I'm sure some will) interpret it, is not good. Certainly we need to look at our social reward/incentive systems from an adversarial point of view, in science, economics, politics and elsewhere. Game theory is useful for that, and it can help us develop systems that are less-easily susceptible to the flaws that the article mentions.
- hx87 10y ago> Who gets to be a scientist, and who gets to become a person with a lot of useless knowledge and an incurable sense of failure. And who goes into finance, software engineering, or some other tangentially related field where the skillset is very useful.