5 ms·
> Gay people getting married deprives no one of anything. There's an opportunity cost. I expanded on that a few days ago, and rather than rehearse it again, I'
by throwanem 10y ago
> Gay people getting married deprives no one of anything.
There's an opportunity cost. I expanded on that a few days ago, and rather than rehearse it again, I'll link the answer I gave to "What do anti-gay-marriage people gain?": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12933668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12933668
- trhway 10y agofrom that your comment: >Homosexual partnerships, which are incapable of producing children, thus are of no benefit to the state, and can only be an unproductive diversion of funds which otherwise would be allocated to the benefit of heterosexual marriages which can and often do produce children. i think you're completely wrong here. Homosexual couples do adopt children and given the number of children in the foster care one can see how a homosexual couple adopting an existing child may be of even bigger benefit to the state/society/planet than a heterosexual couple producing a brand new child. Like with most of the "liberal/progressive" agenda - ecology/climate, marijuana legalization, education, healthcare, social safety net, death penalty abolishment, equal gay and others rights, etc... - i wish to think that this is we, humans, becoming morally better, yet it is also very easy to notice that when the wide society accepts those ideas it is almost always correlates ("correlation is no causation"?) with the fact that at the time of accepting of the given idea that acceptance is economically more beneficial than the not-acceptance. Well, better carrot than the stick...
- throwanem 10y ago> Homosexual couples do adopt children and given the number of children in the foster care [...] A commonly cited argument, to be sure. Let's look at the magnitude of its impact in practice. Per federal statistics, roughly five hundred thousand US children are in foster care, which is roughly two-thirds of a percent of children in the US, or six per thousand. Figures on the number of children adopted by homosexual couples are somewhat harder to come by, but the highest number I found cited by a pro- group calls it about 22,000, which works out to about 4.4 percent of children in care, or 26 per hundred thousand of all children in the US. Does this benefit seem likely to outweigh the cost to the other 99,974 children and their families? Does it justify a federal transfer of wealth from those families - who, given the fashion by which the tax benefits we discuss are distributed, will tend toward the lower end of the income scale - to those homosexual couples already wealthy enough to consider adoption and be likely to gain approval? There's an argument to be made that these figures aren't representative because homosexual marriage is so new, and will increase over time, and that's fair. Let's look at the best possible case. Roughly 1.5 percent of the US population identifies as homosexual. (We disregard self-identified bisexuals in this analysis; when they make up their minds, they all but unanimously settle on heterosexualism.) Out of call it 240 hundred million Americans, if every two homosexuals equate to one marriage, we have 1.8 million couples. With half a million children in care, to reach full coverage, the overall adoption rate among those couples needs to be a bit more than one in four. Does this seem likely? That's four orders of magnitude, and roughly a factor of three thousand, over the general adoption rate - and if we disregard intercountry adoptions, as we have throughout this discussion and properly should here, it becomes more like a factor of five thousand. I do not dispute that homosexual couples, unable themselves to produce children absent extensive scientific and medical intervention, are more likely than others to adopt. But five thousand times more likely?
- StavrosK 10y agoAs I replied to your linked comment, you're conflating the arguments. If you believe that marriage should be allowed if and only if a couple bears/adopts a child, then make parenthood a prerequsite for marriage, there's no point in instituting complex heuristics to try to guess whether a couple wants kids or not beforehand.
- throwanem 10y agoIf that were the argument I was making, you'd have a point. But it's not, although I can see how it would be misgathered as such. The essential difference I see isn't one of individual probability of parenthood, but of aggregate. Not all heterosexual couples rear children, true. But the likelihood of a randomly selected example rearing children is vastly higher than that for a randomly selected homosexual couple. That, I argue, is what makes it worthwhile for the state to support the former and not the latter. To go into individual personal detail, as you seem to think I advocate, might in theory be a natural corollary of what I describe - but to do so in practice not only massively increases the bureaucracy and cost involved and brings in creepy edge cases, but requires a panopticon state in order to work.
- throwaway-hn123 10y agoOk, so single out homosexual couples, because it's easy.
- StavrosK 10y ago> But the likelihood of a randomly selected example rearing children is vastly higher than that for a randomly selected homosexual couple. Okay, but why guess? We already register children and parents, so only issue marriage licenses when a couple has a child. That takes the guessing out of it. > but to do so in practice not only massively increases the bureaucracy and cost involved and brings in creepy edge cases, but requires a panopticon state in order to work. I don't see how, the state already knows who a child's parents are.
- 10y ago
- alistproducer2 10y agoI read you comment. I get your point on why the state provides benefits for marriage. You're argument that civil unions should suffice misses the point and is ignorant of the facts. The fight for marriage equality is not because gay people are overly attached to the nomenclature, there's a real practical difference between unions and marriage[1]. Also you quoted me in your response, but your comments made no argument against my quote. Care to shed light on why people you don't know getting married deprives you of something? 1: http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/marriage-compared-to-civil-unions.html http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/marriage-compa...
- throwanem 10y agoThe comment I linked constitutes the counterargument you request, and also addresses the question of civil unions in detail. It is fairly substantial, which is why I linked it instead of repeating the same arguments in my direct reply to your comment.
- aminorex 10y agoI think the reasonable thing is to eliminate the institution of state marriage.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 7952 10y agoSurely this entire argument is an artifact of the governments uneccessarry intervention in private and family life. If we remove the governments role in marriage completely then people can decide for themselves what role it should play. Small government is a sensible ethos but never seems to be applied to these conservative hot button issues.
- throwanem 10y agoIs it, though? The argument I advance against homosexual marriage proceeds from the legitimate interest of the state in supporting marriage and reproduction. If it helps any, I hardly more often find myself in agreement with conservatives on most issues than with progressives...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 7952 10y ago>> the legitimate interest of the state in supporting marriage and reproduction. Why is that a legitimate interest of the state?
- throwanem 10y agoBecause it perpetuates the state's existence.
- 7952 10y agoYou don't need state intervention to encourage people to reproduce. I am sure that groups that believe in waiting until marriage to have sex would acknowledge church marriages as they always did. Cynically you could argue that the state benefits far more from dysfunctional families who are more likely to become dependant. I would rather the government spend money on sex education and contraception for teens than supporting married couples.
- matt4077 10y agoSeriously, you've lost that fight so hard – gay rights is the one thing where even Donald Trump thinks your time has passed.
- throwanem 10y agoI'm not sure my motivation is clear. As above, rather than rehearse it, I'll link a prior comment in which I did so at length: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12457439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12457439
- norea-armozel 10y agoYour assertion that LGBT rights activists didn't come up with civil unions isn't backed in history. In fact during the time DOMA was proposed many activists supported civil unions as a compromise. It was the right wing that chose to oppose that as well as the ENDA bill even when transgender protections (for folks like me) were ejected from the bill. So, I suggest you correct your statements on that post to be historically accurate.
- throwanem 10y agoIf I'm wrong, I'd like not to be, but I'm having trouble finding references to substantiate this claim. Would you happen to have something suitable at hand?
- norea-armozel 10y agoGoogle it, trust me. Plenty of noise on the right during the 1990s/early-2000s was in strong opposition to civil unions as a whole. Whether it was Falwell and Roberts or the RNC talking heads it was always responded to negatively. They saw it as a slippery slope to full civil marriage.