5 ms·
You'll know we're serious about climate change when this changes. Manual gets better gas mileage. Sure it might be a small difference but even just 3 miles per
by chiefalchemist 10y ago
You'll know we're serious about climate change when this changes. Manual gets better gas mileage. Sure it might be a small difference but even just 3 miles per gallon is 10% on 30 mpg. Over hundreds of thousands of cars that adds up. But we can't be bothered. It's an inconvenience. You can't drink your soy latte and drive at the same time if the vehicle is manual. I guess you can say it's a matter of priorities.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Broken_Hippo 10y ago> You can't drink your soy latte and drive at the same time.. This is simply not true once driving a manual becomes second nature. Cupholders work to hold it when you need both hands. But in general, I agree that most folks (in the US) can't be bothered to drive one.
- dx034 10y agoThe problem is also congestion. Manual trasmission is great when there's not a lot of traffic, but it's a pain on your morning commute in LA/SF/NY/... In Europe you either live on the countryside or use public transport. Comparably few people are stuck every morning on the highway on their way to work (still a few though).
- Accacin 10y agoHow can you make such a ridiculous and broad statement? I'm in the UK and I commute an hour to work down the motorway/highway. With traffic it's an hour and I drive a manual car like just about everyone else. Most people I know still drive to work, even if the city where we live is pretty good for public transport with a lot of buses and trams available.
- fnj 10y agoFor many years I had a 70 minute commute, too, and it was a breeze in a 5-speed, even though it entailed a lot of through-town and traffic lights. On the whole I enjoyed it very much. What wasn't any fun at all were all the 10-20 minute traffic jams when all the idiots were bumper-to-bumper, oscillating between 3 mph and zero every few seconds. First gear, neutral, first, neutral; accelerate, brake, accelerate brake. Especially on an upgrade. My clutch foot was killing me.
- Accacin 10y agoDepends how often you drive using a clutch. I've always driven using one so now even in long traffic jams I don't really notice my foot aching.. However when I first learned to drive it really used to ache.
- dx034 10y agoI didn't look up data before, but the data seems to confirm my statement. In the UK, 68% of the working population commutes by car [1]. In the US, it's around 88% of commuters that commute by car [2]. In London, the share of commuters by public transport is as high as 50% [3]. An article I found on citylab also confirms my statement somehow (although it refers to Berlin). [4] Now, that this influences automatic vs. manual transmission is very subjective, I can't back that up. I could be wrong there, but the rest of the statement is at least not "rediculous". [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/489894/tsgb-2015.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm... [2] https://www.census.gov/hhes/commuting/files/2014/acs-32.pdf https://www.census.gov/hhes/commuting/files/2014/acs-32.pdf [3] http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20160105160709/http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/mro/news-release/travel-to-work/census-reveals-details-of-how-we-travel-to-work-in-england-and-wales.html http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20160105160709/htt... [4] http://www.citylab.com/commute/2015/09/how-london-and-berlins-daily-travel-habits-compare-to-the-us/406840/ http://www.citylab.com/commute/2015/09/how-london-and-berlin...
- Accacin 10y agoOh I don't doubt more people commute by car in the US at all. Your statement was "In Europe you either live on the countryside or use public transport.", your own sources show that 60% don't use public transport and I don't know how you can be so sure that the other 40% live in the countryside. Unless by countryside you mean "live outside of a city"?
- losvedir 10y agoCan you find me an example of a modern car that this is true for? I'm one of the few Americans (I guess) who can drive a manual transmission car; I just hate it. But if it were really better for the environment and better gas mileage I would consider it. HN has spurred me to look into it, but the Honda Accord had 1 mpg better for manual, the Toyota Camry had exactly even, and the BMW I looked at had better gas mileage for an automatic. So for now I'm chalking it up as HN'ers being irrationally in favor of manuals because that's their culture (since the U.S. hasn't really woken up yet).
- stillworks 10y agoThere are a few comments in here which are claiming manual is better for fuel economy. IMHO, the way to get better mileage is - Drive slow - Accelerate gently - Look ahead and coast to slower speed instead of breaking when you need to reduce speed - If on a motorway, trust your cruise control - Check you tire pressure EVERY TIME you refuel. I have an eight year old six speed auto shifter 2 litre petrol engine car. On motorways, with hard compound tires I have regularly managed 44mpg. With softer tires I have managed 40 mpg. And I think it's down to my driving style rather than the type of gearbox. If I had a more modern car with seven or eight speed box and modern ECU, I am sure I'd able to achieve even better mileage than stated above. Also, I'd be going mad if I had to manually chose and shift between eight ratios !!! It seems that outside of U.S., there is some kind of social stigma attached with automatic cars. One is either a MANual shifter xor a WOMANual shifter. Several of my friends are strong proponents of manual gearboxes. When I ask them why... I don't get to hear much stuff about gear ratios, clutch best practices, torque. It's a plain "I don't like automatic" without much real information. This preference is purely without logic or reason. One of my such friends I noticed drives a for miles without going above third gear in situations I would have easily been turning the engine a lot slower in fifth gear. I think drivers who have to deal with icy conditions may have a case for preferring manuals. We don't have much snow/ice where we are... just lots of rain and in that situation I am usually more paranoid about the state of my tires rather than feeling less masculine about letting my gearbox shift on it's own. I think modern automatic shifters are better for fuel economy (and general peace of mind) than manual ones.
- fnj 10y ago"Accelerate gently" Nope. Absolutely incorrect. Best fuel economy is to accelerate rather strongly to cruising speed, getting into top gear quickly. BMW studied this when they brought out the 528e, and found something like 70% throttle is most efficient for this purpose. Upshift at moderate rpm, to be sure, but dawdling in the lower gears taking forever to reach top gear is a waste of fuel. You don't waste fuel accelerating. Fuel is being converted into potential energy. You waste fuel every single time you touch the brakes. That is turning potential energy into heat. All your other points are spot on. Most of all, drive way ahead! As soon as you see that light change to red far ahead, let off the accelerator and start coasting. Tire pressure is important. People look at me cross-eyed when I tell them I run 40+ psi, but it makes a big difference, and my tires do not wear in the middle.