7 ms·
I've worked with phased array flat panel antennas used for geostationary Ku and Ka band two way satellite access. Phased array flat panel antennas cannot be pu
by walrus01 10y ago
I've worked with phased array flat panel antennas used for geostationary Ku and Ka band two way satellite access.
Phased array flat panel antennas cannot be purely software steered sufficiently to track a low earth orbit satellite from horizon to horizon. It's not good enough to just put a flat panel phased array facing straight up, you won't have enough gain aimed in the direction where the satellite actually is at any given moment. Assuming a CPE device that measures 1.5'x1.5' to 2'x2' in size, it will still need a motorized azimuth and elevation stepper motor system (or equivalent) to track a LEO satellite.
If you're trying to do multi-Mbps data to/from a satellite in bands >10GHz (and probably >18GHz), the path loss through the atmosphere and RF parameters mean that you want as much gain as possible... This is why the most economical solutions for high capacity two way satellite through geostationary transponder capacity involve 1.8 to 3.0 meter size dish antennas. Gain is important. Gain and enough signal over noise ratio that you can do higher order QAMs and not spend half your bitrate on FEC.
You could, I suppose, if the antenna system was cheap enough and large enough build a non moving, cone or pyramid shaped antenna covered in phase array segments that could maintain a high bandwidth connection in the >10GHz bands to a moving LEO satellite. But it would be pretty large.
edit: for those who are curious and want to see an example of a parabolic (steered) use for moving satellite comms:
https://www.google.com/search?q=melco+antenna+mitsubishi&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b https://www.google.com/search?q=melco+antenna+mitsubishi&ie=...
http://proceedings.kaconf.org/papers/2015/bsw_4.pdf http://proceedings.kaconf.org/papers/2015/bsw_4.pdf
there is also an israeli company which is a competitor to mitsubishi in this space. and a few others.
if you watch the weekly FCC filings for new satellite equipment licenses, there's a lot of MELCO antennas flying around on top of mid and large sized jet aircraft.
- manicdee 10y agoThey will not be tracking any one satellite across the sky, only those of the 4000 best suited to that particular site at that particular time.
- walrus01 10y agoI'm trying to visualize how it might be set up, from the perspective of the satellite... If you're familiar with how an o3b satellite uses numerous relatively focused high-Ka-band spot beams, I'm imagining each of these 4000 satellites doing something similar but with much smaller spot beams and tighter focus (but also the satellite is smaller, lower power and has smaller antennas so less gain). The really curious part is how the satellite to ground trunk link will be accomplished, if they're going to try to build something like a modern version of the satellite-to-satellite links that Iridium satellites use, but at much higher capacities, draining traffic from multiple satellites through whichever one happens to be over a gateway earth station at a particular time. Or perhaps the satellites will be able to do that and also opportunistically connect to operator-owned earth stations when they are in LOS.
- patrickyeon 10y agoI hope you don't mind, but I'm interested in talking to you about satellite comms and antennas specifically. You don't have any contact info listed in your profile, but if you'd like to talk you can either hit my personal address listed in my profile, or my planet.com one where my username is patrick.
- schiffern 10y agoThanks, great comment. Mark my words, SpaceX is quietly working toward nothing less than a revolution in global data infrastructure, just as Tesla is working to accelerate a revolution in global energy infrastructure. Sneaking in some software, onboard storage, putting them on all Tesla cars, mesh networking the terrestrial base stations with MIMO links, etc. Cars suddenly become a global peer-to-peer mesh sneakernet. It would be fun if Tesla distributed data via "pulses" between passing cars... (signed high resolution maps? deep learning connectomes? the latest Netflix original series? :D) >Phased array flat panel antennas cannot be purely software steered sufficiently to track a low earth orbit satellite from horizon to horizon. Righto. SpaceX plans to steer the beam down to 40° from the horizon. This also minimized path losses. Drawing from the SpaceX filing: http://i.imgur.com/7zOZ7kr.png http://i.imgur.com/7zOZ7kr.png >All Ku-band downlink spot beams on each SpaceX satellite are independently steerable over the full field of view of the Earth. However, user terminals at the customers’ premises communicate only with satellites at an elevation angle of at least 40 degrees. Consequently, as shown in Figure A.3.1-1 below, each satellite operating at an altitude of 1,150 km will provide service only up to 40.46 degrees away from boresight (nadir), covering an area of about 3.5 million square kilometers (1,060 km radius) source: Figure A.3.1-1 on pp6 of the FCC technical information document, currently 404, via /u/SkywayCheerios https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/5d9724/spacex_has_filed_for_their_massive_constellation/da2qjj7/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/5d9724/spacex_has_f... https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=1158350 https://licensing.fcc.gov/myibfs/download.do?attachment_key=... http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Alicensing.fcc.gov%2Fmyibfs%2Fdownload.do%3Fattachment_key%3D1158350 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Alicen...
- walrus01 10y agoyeah, I tried to retrieve the docs from the FCC website and gave up. it appears to be suffering under a severe slashdot effect at the moment.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- loourr 10y agoWouldn't it not need to? Presumably if there are 4000 satellites it wouldn't need to look from horizon to horizon, just approximately up.
- walrus01 10y agoIt really depends on how they're designing the CPE and network architecture for handoffs from one satellite to another, since from the point of view of a CPE on the ground the satellites are constantly moving. That's kind of opaque right now until more technical details come out, and examples of what the end user terminal hardware might look like (FCC test lab reports, etc).
- tbabb 10y agoThose gains would make sense for geostationary satellites, but SpaceX is planning on putting its fleet into LEO, at just a few hundred km. Would you expect the same for that altitude? Also with 4000 satellites, you probably wouldn't have to track one all the way to the horizon.
- walrus01 10y agoIt still matters: Try engineering a high capacity (350 to 1000 Mbps) PTP microwave link at a distance of 80 km between two mountaintops... Path loss and channel capacity are real issues to deal with even at distances much shorter than GEO.
- tbabb 10y agoAgain, not my field of expertise, but worth asking: There's going to be much much more air between two mountains 80km apart than between the surface and 80km altitude. I believe the quantity of air in a column above you at sea level is about equal to 9km of sea-level air. How would that change the problem?
- jerich 10y agoAhh, memory lane. LEO satellite internet is one of the subjects that bring me out of lurking. My first job out of school in 1998 was writing test plans for the antenna pointing and tracking for the Teledesic CPE at Motorola. If I remember right, the initial plan was to have dual steerable dishes inside a pair of radomes—like a pair of Mickey Mouse ears. There was a vague future plan for phased-array antennas, but at the time it wasn't realistic to talk about getting them on roofs at a reasonable price point. The bigger challenge was the optical intersatellite links; routing traffic between LEO satellites using lasers. The lasers had to track satellites in adjacent planes of the constellation that were traveling in the opposite direction. It's interesting to see the same general idea for the large constellation come up every few years. If we had actually started building it in 1998, it would've been on a second or maybe even third generation by now. I'm a little surprised that Apple hasn't given it a try with their billions sitting around. 4K FaceTime, or even just downloading movies or apps instantly would be a selling point for their other hardware.
- schiffern 10y ago>The lasers had to track satellites in adjacent planes of the constellation that were traveling in the opposite direction. Didn't Iridium get around that by having a single "seam" between adjacent oncoming planes which signals don't pass, but for all other adjacencies using crosslinks between planes?