7 ms·
Wow. It feels like a miracle whenever anyone takes a principled stand despite the hype and pressure of Silicon Valley and startup culture, never mind the usual
by danso 10y ago
Wow. It feels like a miracle whenever anyone takes a principled stand despite the hype and pressure of Silicon Valley and startup culture, never mind the usual corporate pressure. But this kid stood up to his own family, and lawyers hired by his family.
Fairly or not, Stanford will always have some association with the legend of Elizabeth Holmes, but the engineering school can feel proud that they produced a graduate who showed real ethical backbone. It's fairly easy to imagine oneself bravely standing up to Theranos after reading the WSJ investigation last year. It's another thing to be the guy who launched it despite legal and familial pressure.
- Dowwie 10y agoStanford didn't produce this young man.
- user837387 10y agoRight on. Stanford was lucky that he honored them with their willingness to go study there. I would credit his parents. Maybe.
- Hitard 10y agoNeither did it produce Elizabeth Holmes.
- jrowley 10y ago> the engineering school can feel proud that they produced a graduate It says in the article he graduated with a degree in Biology, but point taken.
- pinewurst 10y ago"He had just graduated after changing his major to biology to better prepare for a career at the startup, he says."
- cft 10y agoIf an ordinary employee tried to take such a stand, he would be ignored, shut up, fired, sued, or perhaps jailed, depending on how firmly he was willing and able to take it. FYI: "As household staff served them dinner in the formal dining room, the elder Mr. Shultz said Ms. Holmes had told him Theranos’s blood-testing devices worked so well that they were being used in medevac helicopters and hospital operating rooms, Tyler Shultz recalls. He and his colleague knew that wasn’t true."
- prostoalex 10y agoThe whistleblower laws allow some degree of anonynimity precisely for the reasons above. From the article: "Using an alias, Tyler Shultz contacted New York state’s public-health lab ..." "... Mr. Shultz began speaking to a Journal reporter as a confidential source." "... regulatory complaint Mr. Shultz had filed under the alias Colin Ramirez" The decision to confront the CEO personally was his own, he could've chosen the anonymous path all along.
- kylec 10y agoFair or not, when I think of Stanford I think of Brock Turner and Elizabeth Holmes.
- trhway 10y agoThese both didn't make it past a one year at Stanford.
- zhemao 10y ago> But this kid stood up to his own family, and lawyers hired by his family If I'm reading the article correctly, the lawyers who harassed him were hired by the company and not by his grandfather. The only lawyers his family hired were the ones fighting for him.
- danso 10y agoAh yes, you're correct. The lawyers were at his grandfather's home, but not directly hired by him: > His grandfather asked if he would sign a one-page confidentiality agreement to give Theranos peace of mind. According to Tyler Shultz, when he said yes, his grandfather revealed that two lawyers were waiting upstairs with the agreement...Tyler Shultz says his grandfather protested to the lawyers that this wasn’t what he and Ms. Holmes had agreed to earlier, but that Mr. Brille kept pressing the younger Mr. Shultz to admit he had spoken to the Journal. Still, the grandfather was working in concert with Ms. Holmes, and I imagine at the time, it would've been difficult for Tyler to give his grandfather the benefit of the doubt, assuming that Tyler was not expecting lawyers to jump out at his grandfather's command. I actually missed the paragraph where it's mentioned that his parents "pleaded with him to agree to whatever Theranos wanted" and told him that they might sell their house to deal with the legal costs. Add that to the checklist of things I'm not sure I could do if I were in his shoes. (That his parents only responded to the WSJ reporter via a prepared statement suggests that there's still tension.)
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIntegrity is a costly thing, rarely appreciated by the people who should. Over the years I've discovered that the scummier the management the more it costs so in that way what it will cost you is sort of determined by your manager (or maybe their manager as well). I've also asked people who were looking to hire me how highly they valued integrity. Sadly both bad managers and good managers say they value it highly, but bad managers will work to get rid of you as soon as they realize you really meant it :-)
- madaxe_again 10y agoIntegrity is costly, but only if you view financial loss as the sole cost, and ignore the upside of being able to live with yourself. I'd love to believe that being honest and ethical will one day provide some kind of reward, but the reality is that it doesn't - in fact in this world you are indeed punished for it - so you just have to accept that being good is its own reward. It's something I really struggle with - the fact that the more dishonest you are, the more willing you are to lie, cheat, steal, kill, mislead, destroy, hurt, insult, and all the rest, the more successful you will be. I've seen it over and over in business - retail magnates practically eat children for breakfast. I remember "do you employ any n-ggers" lady, who runs a major UK fashion label, and "I know we said we'd pay but what the fuck are you going to do about it, my brother's the local magistrate" with particular fondness. The worst part about the former was watching others in the business not care and still want to do the deal - I had to torpedo it, as there was no way I'd be able to work with this inhumane individual. I mean - look at the PeOTUS - he's a shining example of what this world now holds as good. Hell, I remember posting 18 months ago about how Holmes wasn't all she seemed to be and HN calling me every shitty name under the sun (I was a misogynist, jealous, rageface, you name it), and yet now that it's the majority view that she's not all she seemed to be, that opinion is fine. Tribes who blindly support the strong angry man, rather than the honest man. We'd rather go stick heads on poles over a yam theft than admit we didn't plant the yam in the first place. Nothing has changed.
- user837387 10y ago>>I'd love to believe that being honest and ethical will one day provide some kind of reward, but the reality is that it doesn't - in fact in this world you are indeed punished for it - so you just have to accept that being good is its own reward. What you are saying is true. Trump got rewarded the presidency for his lack of integrity. The lesson seems to be that only morons allow their sense of integrity to rule them.