4 ms·
"and lost all of a $110,000 personal loan he’d taken out from PNC Bank." The man had no job, maxed out credit card, and a bank gave him a loan of 110k? Am I cr
by gambiting 10y ago
"and lost all of a $110,000 personal loan he’d taken out from PNC Bank."
The man had no job, maxed out credit card, and a bank gave him a loan of 110k? Am I crazy to think this is insane on the bank's behalf?
- Kenji 10y agoNo. Any bank with sane procedures would never approve such a thing.
- acedinlowball 10y agoCan you share more of your experiences working in the banking industry?
- Kenji 10y agoSure, what do you want to know? My time at the bank was brief (I like tech more) but I got at least some insight.
- grzm 10y agoDefinitions of sanity aside, whether or not its a "good" idea is a matter of perspective. The 2008 financial crises showed how a lot of money can be made with no real repercussions approving loans, so probably looked like a very good idea to those who profited. Same with the S&L crisis in the 80s and 90s.
- Kenji 10y agoI worked at a bank before, throughout and after the 2008 financial crisis. That bank wouldn't have dared to give a broke and jobless person a loan, not a penny. Unless there are good reasons to assume it can be paid back, like securities in the form of a house or shares.
- grzm 10y agoI know of banks that wouldn't have approved loans like that, either. However, some banks did, and made money doing so. Many banks don't keep the loans they approve on their own books.
- Kenji 10y agoMany banks don't keep the loans they approve on their own books. That is dirty, dirty business. Giving out loans that will never be paid back, bundling them up and selling an opaque package full of risks. They said that was a big part of what started the crisis. I'm glad I wasn't part of that.
- grzm 10y agoYup. I completely agree. And there were a lot of steps in the chain. As I understand it, it wasn't the issuing banks that were doing the bundling: they just sold the loans to other financial service companies. Given the amount of money and the fact that a lot of them effectively got away with it, from their point of view it was good business. This is an example of situations where I see arguments along the lines of "it was legal, so it wasn't wrong". Grr...
- Retric 10y agoDepends on if they can sell the loan to someone else. PNC Bank may have actually made money from the deal. Another consideration is the person making the loan at PNC can be better off even if PNC is worse off.
- zardo 10y agoI'm guessing the bank doesn't keep the loan, they pass on the shit to get polished, repackaged, and resold.
- twblalock 10y agoHe may have lied to the bank about his income and credit history. Addicts tend to do that kind of thing. Before 2008, it was trivially easy to get away with it.
- mikestew 10y agoMy guess is that he took an equity loan on the house. Based on their website, PNC looks to be like most other banks as far as business model and services offered, so a plain ol' home equity line of credit makes the most sense.
- gwern 10y agoHe might also have been running off his past credit score. He was making 6-figures for decades, spending heavily on presumably his credit card, and always paid his bills. If the bank doesn't see the embezzled funds he was spending (and why would they when the funds belonged to the company), he probably looked like a great credit risk: a high-flying executive with a long sterling history who would no doubt get another great job after a few months of negotiation and had plenty of assets.