3 ms·
I earned Eagle Scout in 2000, one month shy of turning 18. I agree with your comment 100%. Earning merit badges is akin to preparing for standardized tests; i
by spking 17y ago
I earned Eagle Scout in 2000, one month shy of turning 18. I agree with your comment 100%. Earning merit badges is akin to preparing for standardized tests; it's simply regurgitating ideas and concepts to fulfill a list of requirements. It was the non-merit badge activities that I gained and learned the most from, where there was less structure involved. Running an Eagle Scout project introduced me to budget constraints, solving problems creatively and managing a team. I don't know much about the Girl Scouts, but if they are similar in spirit to the BSA I'll definitely encourage my daughter to participate.
- seehafer 17y agoUnless of course the merit badge covers a concrete skill: I learned a great deal by completing the Rifle Shooting, First Aid, and Wilderness Survival merit badges. I agree with your point, though: some are the equivalent of 'read the book, regurgitate the contents on a test'.
- leftnode 17y agoWithout a doubt, Wilderness Survival was my favorite merit badge of all time. I don't think it was Eagle required, but boy was it fun and I learned a ton. But you're right, having to do my Eagle project taught me the most. Organizing some 150 volunteers on New Years Eve was no small feat, but I felt a great deal of accomplishment when it was done.