3 ms·
My feeling is that large aircraft carriers must be close to being outdated as the UK is close to having a couple of them.
by arethuza 10y ago
My feeling is that large aircraft carriers must be close to being outdated as the UK is close to having a couple of them.
- simonh 10y agoIf we had only bought military assets exclusively useful in a full-on strategic all-out conflict between superpowers for the last 60 years, we'd have been pretty poorly prepared for the actual conflicts and crises we've found ourselves in during that time. For example, suppose the UK found itself in another conflict like the Falklands war? Or supporting medium-intensity operations in the Middle East? Or supporting humanitarian efforts in Africa or Asia? I imagine having a few carriers would be pretty useful. Personally I think it's more likely we'll find ourselves in situations like that, than that we'll find ourselves in an all-our direct engagement with Russia or China.
- arethuza 10y agoI'm not saying that the carriers themselves are useless - just that the rest of the forces are being run down to a point where it's not clear that they can be manned, have aircraft to operate from them or enough escorts to defend them. The only way I can see them being used is as part of a US fleet possibly even carrying US aircraft. So we manage to build some carriers exactly at the time the US looks like it might be less interested in precisely the kinds of wars we might get dragged into. Leaving aside the fact that the domestic appetite for getting involved in unnecessary wars seems at an all time low. For humanitarian work, an RFA vessel seems more appropriate - e.g. the help with the Ebola outbreak last year: http://www.royalnavy.mod.uk/news-and-latest-activity/news/2015/february/06/150206-royal-navy-first-in-fight-against-ebola http://www.royalnavy.mod.uk/news-and-latest-activity/news/20...