4 ms·
It is a common misconception that the theory of global warming, and the concern about global warming, is based on the results of global climate models (GCMs). I
by snowwrestler 10y ago
It is a common misconception that the theory of global warming, and the concern about global warming, is based on the results of global climate models (GCMs). It is not.
In fact, the opposite is true: it is skepticism of global warming that depends on the correctness of GCMs.
In the simplest model, which any kid can test in middle school, you take a plexiglass box full of air (representing the atmosphere), add some extra CO2 to it, and see if the temperature goes up. It does.
Well, since the mid-1800s, we have been adding CO2 to the atmosphere. We know that we've burned a lot of fossil fuels (that were underground), and we have directly measured an increase in the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. So based on the simplest model, we'd expect to see the temperature going up. And we do! Yay, science works.
Of course there are a lot of ways to say that the simple model is wrong. But they all involve the construction of a more complex model. In order to see if anything will mitigate or compensate the basic physics of how more CO2 traps more heat, you have to add in additional factors.
So when someone goes on and on and on about the shortcomings of super-complex GCMs, remember this. GCMs are important tools for making detailed predictions and policy decisions, but we don't need them to predict the basic fact of global warming.
In fact the original hypothesis of global warming dates back to about 1900, well before anyone was using computers to model anything. The theory of global warming rests on basic thermodynamics, and it was first proposed not long after those basics were discovered.
- serge2k 10y agoIs this how we ended up shifting from "global warming" to "climate change"? Improved models showing that things won't just get warmer, they'll go all kinds of sideways?
- snowwrestler 10y agoThe change in terminology doesn't have scientific significance, it was done to try to improve public understanding. Basically "warming" in popular usage means "I can take my jacket off now", whereas warming in scientific usage means "increasing the heat energy stored in a given volume." Scientists have known for a long time that global warming (increasing the heat stored in the atmosphere) would create both local heating in some areas and local cooling in others (it's chaotic). But when a regular person hears "warming" and then the temperature goes down, they're confused. Hence "climate change." Incidentally, predicting the local effects of warming is a major goal of GCMs, and one for which no other tool will do. But it's damn hard (again: it's chaotic).
- flukus 10y agoWhen do you think this shift took place? The IPCC was established in the 80's.
- jackmott 10y agoJust to add to that, we know the increase in the atmosphere is mostly due to fossil fuels because that co2 source has unique isotope signatures compared to other sources like rotting plants and forest fires, and we know the basic plexiglass box scenario is actually playing out from satellite observations, which directly observe that it is co2 (and methane) spectra of heat specifically that is being blocked, not other wavelengths, and that the degree of change is in accordance with what would be expected given the amount of co2 we have added. In other words everything is very clear, it all adds up, it has added up and been clear since the early 1990s.
- kapitza 10y agoThis is slightly misleading. What we've understood for a century is the thermal forcing due to CO2, which is a logarithmic function of the CO2 concentration (ie, forcing == O(log n) in CO2 concentration). What we don't understand (unless we decide GCMs are predictive and can be validated) is the impact of a given thermal forcing on planetary temperature. This is the "climate sensitivity." Unfortunately, this is the number we actually care about. If climate sensitivity is low (negative feedback), Earth is thermally buffered and we have to worry less. If climate sensitivity is high (positive feedback), the opposite. (Note also that Arrhenius, the discoverer of this effect, and pretty much everyone through the '60s, assumed that global warming was a positive side effect of burning fossil fuel, just from the preindustrial assumption that warm winters and high crop yields are good for humanity.)
- andrewla 10y agoWorth noting that although this analysis is a good one, and helps calm down the knee-jerk responses of "global warming is a fraud", your comment does not contradict the linked article, which does not argue that climate change is not real, but rather than GCMs are a tool of limited utility for predicting climate change or forming policy guidance around mitigating climate change. The article does not discount the utility of GCMs in furthering our understanding of the climate in general, but reaches the conclusion that existing models are of limited utility when attempting to forecast the affect of policy changes (or the lack thereof) on climate trends.